Bird flu virus: interfering with interferon

The virulent influenza A subtype H5N1, known colloquially as bird flu, has caused sporadic cases of human disease but has not yet become a pandemic strain. There are several things which still separate H5N1 from the kind of seasonal influenza infections that are a serious periodic public health threat to humans. A significant population immunity to the seasonal virus subtypes is probably a major factor preventing seasonal flu from being the pandemic monster that the 1918 flu became. But there are other differences, too.
H5N1 currently seems to prefer birds to humans, a second difference. We are only just beginning to unravel the reasons for species preference in influenza viruses. Even when the occasional person becomes infected with H5N1, there seems to be much less chance to transmit to other people. Seasonal influenza is easily transmitted between people. And while seasonal flu can be a nasty and sometimes fatal disease, the case fatality ratio is usually only about 0.1%. By contrast, the current H5N1 infections are highly virulent, meaning that infections with the virus are extremely serious. Current case fatality ratios are in excess of 60%. So there are a lot of things still to understand about H5N1.

A new paper in Nature (Zachary A. Bornholdt, B. V. Venkataram Prasad, X-ray structure of NS1 from a highly pathogenic H5N1 influenza virus, Nature, doi:10.1038/nature07444) looks at the virulence question. What makes H5N1 such a nasty bug once a human is infected? The H and N in the subtype designation H5N1 represent two viral proteins, hemagglutinin and neuraminidase, but there are another 9 proteins the virus makes. Most are not "seen" by the immune system but play important roles in viral infection. One is a protein designated NS1, for non-structural protein 1. We know that NS1 plays some roles in viral virulence and that one role involves interfering with the innate immune response to a viral infection. The objective of a virus is pretty simple: make copies of itself. It does this by gaining access to the cell's protein and genetic factories and tricks it into making copies of itself instead of proteins and genetic material the cell needs to function. Cell's have defenses against this kind of criminal activity by viruses, however. When a cell sees that viral genetic material is being manufactured (as indicated by the presence of double stranded RNA), it triggers a response to manufacture a natural antiviral cytokine, interferon. NS1 seems to aid viral infection by combatting interferon. But how?

The Nature paper by Bornholdt and Prasad at Baylor College of Medicine, succeeded in crystallizing H5N1's NS1 protein and revealing its probable three dimensional structure by x-ray crystallography. Proteins are characterized, first, by their amino acid sequences. The sequence of amino acids is determined by your cell's DNA or, for the influenza virus, its genetic material (which is RNA). But just knowing the sequence isn't enough. We know the amino acid sequence of NS1. But the long chain of amino acids also folds into a complicated three dimensional structure which determines its biology. Mutations may alter the amino acid sequence but it is the folding and 3-D changes that are produced that make the biological difference. By knowing what H5N1 and other flu virus NS1s look like in 3-D, we can begin to figure out how they work. NS1 has two subparts separated by a threadlike linker sequence of amino acids. The H5N1 NS1s have a 5 amino acid deletion in the linker thread that may be important for why they are more virulent. But the Bornhold/Prasad paper has much more to it. By examining the 3-D picture they discovered that NS1 might work by lining up in chains that form a tubular structure that encloses the virus's RNA when it is in its double stranded phase during replication so it can't be seen and therefore doesn't trigger the interferon response.

If this novel structure is a feature contributing to virulence (and this is not yet certain), it does not preclude NS1 from having other roles as well. That is still to be determined. By targeting with drugs the essential features of the NS1 structure we might be able to develop a prophylactic or treatment for H5N1. That won't solve the pandemic threat. You can't stop a pandemic with drugs. But drugs can help you treat people who are sick, and that's a good thing.

This is one more example of the elegant but very basic research that must be done if we are to bring influenza under control. We have an awful long way to go.

More like this

Every couple of months a major flu paper appears purporting to reveal why the 1918 H1N1 virus was so horrifically virulent in comparison to the other pandemic viruses of the last century, H2N2 (1957 pandemic) and H3N2 (1968 pandemic). It's not just the H1N1 subtype of the influenza A virus that…
Nature has just published another new paper on the basic biology of influenza virus. Unlike other recent papers it doesn't purport to reveal the secret of why some flu (e.g., H5N1, 1918 H1N1) is so virulent and "normal" seasonal influenza much less so. Instead it involves a process and structures…
We've now had a chance to take a look at a new paper in Nature (advance online publication 27 September 2006 | doi:10.1038/nature05181) on increased host immune and cell death responses in mice infected with the reconstructed 1918 virus compared to other viruses with only some of the 1918 gene…
A couple of days ago Dr. Marion Koopmans, chief of virology in the infectious diseases laboratory of the National Institute of Public Health, The Netherlands, notified the infectious disease community through the website/email list ProMed that two of their swine flu isolates showed a particular…

"...they discovered that NS1 might work by lining up in chains that form a tubular structure that encloses the virus's RNA when it is in its double stranded phase during replication so it can't be seen and therefore doesn't trigger the interferon response."

Very, very interesting stuff, Revere. We (those who regularly posted on the subject, here) speculated on the contributions of the "silent" elements of H5N1's various gene segments, a few years ago; there was also discussion (speculative) about how the virus evaded detection by the innate mechanisms of the fundamental, native (non-acquired) protection mechanisms of the human immune system.

Science.

The most profound, and utterly sublime, expression of human reason.

Typo, second sentence

"H5N11" should be "H5N1", unless I'm mistaken.

> But just knowing the sequence isn't enough. We know the amino acid sequence of NS1.
> But the long chain of amino acids also folds into a complicated three dimensional
> structure which determines its biology

this folding however is determined by the sequence, there is no additional encoding of the folding process

> NS1 might work by lining up in chains that form a tubular structure that encloses the virus's
> RNA when it is in its double stranded phase during replication so it can't be seen and therefore
> doesn't trigger the interferon response.

when is it in the double-stranded phase ?
can someone shortly explain the phases and their duration ?

> You can't stop a pandemic with drugs

huh ? why not ? All the models seem to tell otherwise

is there any other virus, which uses this trick to compromise interferon ?

Charles: Thanks. Yes, typo.

anon: The viral RNA must replicate and is in ds form at that point. Most models that look at this show that trying to snuff out a pandemic with drugs is almost impossible, requiring a speed and coverage which almost no one believes feasible. Yes, there is no more encoding, but the folding is determined by features that go beyond the sequence and we still don't know how to predict it from the sequence.

ds=double stranded ? So, is it ds outside the nucleus ?

speed and coverage with drugs is just a matter of money and will
be done in countries like USA in an emergency.
Much less than the $700B bailout required.

I remember several models (Longini,Ferguson,Los Alamos,etc. 2 from 2008 AFAIR) which
show possible reduction of infections by >90%, almost halting the pandemic by antivirals
plus other methods, but most important antivirals as I remember. e.g.:
http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/121358270/abstract?CRETRY=1&…

> folding is determined by features that go beyond the sequence

which ? I thought in theory it should be possible, and maybe will be done in some decades,
to determine the folding by a computer program which gets the sequence alone.