Afghanistan: making it back is only half the battle

We're saving lives on the battlefield. Lives that would have been lost in previous wars. That's good. War takes too many lives. But there are ways to take lives that don't involve killing someone. And we're taking a lot of lives that way, many more than before. Here's Liam Clancy with the great song by Australian singer-song writer Eric Bogle:

More like this

I'm getting a lot of questions via email and comments about our experience entering into the foster parenting world, and I did want to talk about this. Some people are critical, and think we're nuts (quite possibly), some people want to watch because they want to try this too (cool), some people…
When Eric and I first wrote a letter to Eric's grandparents, asking them to consider living with us, the response was very mixed. Grandma and Grandpa's generation of friends and family were mostly very pleased and thrilled - given the bad lot of options available to many of them, finding a…
Andrew Jackson was born in March, 1767. Jackson was about 9 years old when the Revolutionary War started. The Revolutionary War and the Civil War were two different wars. There was another war in between called the War of 1812. It was approximately in 1812. Andrew Jackson was a lawyer, a judge…
Life has been proceeding more or less apace, and it feels like a long time since I've sat down and contemplated anything, much less my Anyway Project goals. At the same time, all this business is a series of steps on the way to actually many of the things done. I hope that's true of all of you!…

EMPATHY.
I haven't heard Tommy Makem sing in such a long time. Thank you, Revere. That is a quality so lacking in public discourse nowadays. This melancholy song, sung with such incredible empathy and Irish soul is indeed just overwhelmingly powerful and thought provoking.

It's a great song, for sure, but that is Liam Clancy singing it, not Tommy Makem (who comes out at the end and starts playing the next song with Liam). Liam died on 4 November. It's nice to see him.

I don't mean to distract from your point about the taking of lives. I have no doubt that both Liam and Makem would have agreed. Thanks for the post.

By ecologist (not verified) on 10 Dec 2009 #permalink

Yikes. Of course you are right. I should have realized it. My face is red but the post is now correct. Thank you for pointing out this embarrassing error on my part.

Thanks for this powerful version of one of my all-time favorite songs. I have an old recording of Eric Bogle doing it. I try to play it myself on guitar but can never finish. I don't know how they do it. And I ask myself the same question....