Polio-Free India (almost)

It has officially been one year since India diagnosed a new case of polio.

This week, India will cross the milestone of 12 consecutive months without any case of polio being reported - the onset of paralysis of the last case was on 13 January, 2011 in West Bengal.


India was once recognized as the world's epicentre of polio. As recently as 2009, India had the highest burden of polio cases in the world (741), more than the three other endemic countries combined. Due to extraordinary measures to reach children with vaccine, India has not seen a case since a 2-year-old girl in the state of West Bengal developed paralysis on 13 January 2011.

As wonderful as this is, polio is not yet eradicated, and all of Indias success could go down the drain in an instant.

Polio could reenter India all over again from the other countries where polio is still endemic, Pakistan or Afghanistan (or less likely Nigeria).

And then we have another problem-- The oral polio vaccine itself.

While the oral vaccine, composed of a live, attenuated polio virus was essential to generating a currently polio-free India, it could also ruin everything. That is because there are very few mutations in the attenuated strain vs the pathogenic strain. This means that sometimes, in a person who gets the vaccine, the virus reverts back to its wild-type state. That individual is still protected from polio, but they are shedding pathogenic polio in their feces, which can then go on to infect people who have not gotten the vaccine.

This is no big deal in the US, because everyone gets the vaccine and we have clean drinking water. But it could be a very big deal in India, where the people who need the vaccine the most (the poor, who dont have good drinking water sources regular health-care) do not have easy access to the vaccine.

The alternative is administering the killed vaccine during this almost-eradicated time. Dead virus = protection without the risk of reversion and transmission. But the killed vaccine comes with its own set of difficulties. Money. Again, in the US this was no big deal-- we have needles and trained health care professionals to administer the killed polio vaccine. But sterile needles and health professionals are harder to come by in India.

The predicament India is in right now really highlights, again, the luxury of the anti-vax movement. While Jenny McCarthy is gushing about Nicki Minaj and Lady Gaga performing on New Years Eve and plugging the anti-vaccine Generation Rescue, parents in India would do anything to prevent their child from being the kid who breaks Indias polio-free streak, but cant do anything, because they dont have the money.

Its disgusting.


More like this

Last week, Nigeria met an important milestone: An entire year without a reported case of polio. If the WHO confirms the absence of the virus in samples taken from people in previously affected areas, Nigeria will no longer be on the list of countries where the disease is endemic. Another two years…
I concluded last week with the dismantling one of the more bizarre stories I've seen spun by the merry band of anti-vaccine propagandists over at Age of Autism. As you might recall, Mark "Not a Doctor, Not a Scientist" Blaxill had teamed with Dan "Where are the Autistic Amish?" Olmsted (or, as I…
Last year I wrote about a cool paper, arguing for the creation of a new polio vaccine. Briefly, polio is an RNA virus, thus has an error-prone RNA-RNA polymerase, thus acts like a quasispecies like HIV-1. Now, a live attenuated polio vaccine is the 'best' because you activate lots of branches of…
In the winter of 1999, I stood in an outpatient clinic in a pediatric hospital in New Delhi and listened to a father sobbing over the paralysis of his only son. He was a farmer and lived in Uttar Pradesh; counting walks, minibuses and trains, it had taken him 24 hours to get to the hospital. He had…

Polio could reenter India all over again from the other countries where polio is still endemic, Pakistan or Afghanistan (or less likely Nigeria).

Or China, as there were cases in the area near the India/China border (Hotan prefecture) as late as October of last year. It's not considered endemic there, but it is another route that polio could take.

By Epinephrine (not verified) on 17 Jan 2012 #permalink

Great news! However, I wanted to bring up some additional benefits of the Oral Polio Vaccine (OPV) over the Inactivated Polio Vaccine (IPV):

OPV not only protects the person vaccinated, but it also can give protection for other people who are in close contact with the vaccinated person.

Also, it gives better immune response in the gut.

Both these are advantages in areas where polio virus might still be found in the wild. Money isn't the only consideration.

By RTContracting (not verified) on 17 Jan 2012 #permalink

1. That SFLuxe site is incredibly annoying with the multiple interstitials and the long pause.

2. I don't think McCarthy actually managed to spout any antivax nonsense on TV. Maybe she figured out that, given the state of her career, it'd be best not to risk it. More likely, the broadcast didn't lend itself to that. My impression is that there are a lot of cuts between hosts and band performances and commercials, and the talking head bits are pretty brief without much opportunity for off-topic babbling.

I saw two bits of McCarthy: in one she was talking to the new Bachelor show guy to promote that show.. The other she was sucking face with a cop at midnight.

This is also good news for the fight against polio in general across the world. No longer (at least we hope) India can export poliovirus outside of its borders to the likes of China and Africa :)