Zinc supplements for severe childhood pneumonia

Frequent readers of ERV, or SciBlogs in general, are used to vitamin/mineral woo. "Megadoses of Vitamin C cures EVERYTHING!" "Vitamin D is better at preventing the flu than the VACCINE!" "Zinc cures the COMMON COLD!"

What we are used to dealing with, is snake-oil salesmen looking to sell their particular bottled garbage to people with medical anxieties/paranoia (but are otherwise healthy individuals) with disposable income.

But the world is not full of rich Westerners paranoid about The Big C.

There are lots of people on this planet who struggle to get themselves and their children adequate nutrition. When you are literally starving, vitamin and mineral deficiencies can and do have an impact on overall health, and your ability to respond appropriately to pathogens. This might be one of those stories:

Zinc adjunct therapy reduces case fatality in severe childhood pneumonia: a randomized double blind placebo-controlled trial

This paper is a good example of how scientists might go into a study with a set of expectations, but the data leads them in an unexpected direction. In this case, they collected a group of 352 children with severe pneumonia. Half got zinc supplementation with their pneumonia treatment, half got placebo.

They were expecting to see either a) differences in the two groups time to normal temperature, breath rate, and oxygen levels or b) no differences because zinc didnt do anything.

Well, they found b.

When you looked at the kids stats as they were getting better, there was no difference between the zinc and the placebo group. So zinc supplementation was a bust?

Not quite-- When they looked at the expected parameters, there was no difference. But when they looked at the number of kids who *died* in the groups of kids, things got interesting.

  • 7 of 176 kids in the zinc group died.
  • 21 of 176 kids in the placebo group died.

This difference becomes even more stark when you focus on the HIV+ kids in the group--

  • 0 of 28 HIV+ kids in the zinc group died.
  • 7 of 27 HIV+ kids in the placebo group died.

How is this phenomenon occurring? Well, we dunno. But the authors have some guesses:

... zinc supplementation might increase phagocytosis [17] and zinc deficiency predisposes to apoptosis of T lymphocytes in HIV-infected patients [18]. In fact, it has now been established that zinc deficiency compromises immunity through a number of mechanisms, such as T cell dysfunction and dysregulation of intracellular killing [19].

Does this mean that everyone should go out and chug megadoses of zinc and we will never ever EVER get a bacterial infection again because our immune systems are, like, SUPER BOOSTED?

Of course not.

Zinc supplementation could 'work' in these kids because they were all zinc deficient. The authors even stated that the kids zinc levels were lower than the 'low' that they expected to see-- about 4.4-4.8 umol/L.

Normal is ~20 umol/L.

Kids with chronic malabsorption syndrome are at about 8.6 umol/L.

Kids who physiologically cant absorb nutrients well have twice as much zinc in their serum as the malnurished kids in this study.

These scientists crunched the numbers-- it will take $4 to supplement 13 kids with severe pneumonia, to save 1 life.

Im sure folks like Gary wont mind donating to the cause.

More like this

At least when it comes to killing young children in the developing world. A recent Lancet article describes the devastation pneumonia causes among children: Pneumonia kills more children than any other illness, more than AIDS, malaria, and measles combined... More than 2 million children under 5…
An outcome some of you might expect, but for reasons you probably dont expect-- Let me tell you the punchline first: Effect of High-Dose vs Standard-Dose Multivitamin Supplementation at the Initiation of HAART on HIV Disease Progression and Mortality in Tanzania, A Randomized Controlled Trial…
I get all sorts of mail. I get mail from whining Scientologists, suffering patients, angry quacks---and I get lots of promotional material. I get letters from publishers wanting me to review books, letters from pseudo-bloggers wanting me to plug their advertiblog---really, just about anything you…
Statins for influenza are in the news again, this time because of a paper given at the Annual Meeting of the Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA). We'll get to it in a moment, but first a little background. Statins are cholesterol lowering drugs that are taken by tens of millions of people…

One question...and not a quibble. Where were the children from? Was it a country where we *expect* to see large numbers of malnourished children, or in a supposed first world country. And if so, does that raise more warning bells about malnutrition in "the kids next door"?

By Tamara Griesel (not verified) on 08 Feb 2012 #permalink

They were in Uganda.

Ah. But how much will it cost if you buy your zinc supplements in homeopathic form?

There's Zicam Oral Mist (legally dispensed as homeopathic, if not in the spirit of the thing) which is 0.1% Zinc Acetate and 10% Zinc Gluconate. That's about 7000 μmol per 1 oz bottle @ $3-$12.

Real homeopathic zinc is astronomically more expensive.

Run of the mill supplements offer 76000 μmol of elemental zinc ( 100 50 mg tablets) for under $2, which places the Zicam product 15 times more expensive than it needs to be.

It's really, realy cool that they found a simple, relatively cheap supplimental treatment for severe pneumonia in children. (I imagine that it might have a similar impact in adults.)

It also reinforces my idea that the people who need supplements generally can't afford them, and the people who take them generally don't need them. (Generally. there are plent of people who have healthy diets who need supplements. *chough* Seattle, vitamin D *cough*)

By JustaTech (not verified) on 08 Feb 2012 #permalink

The World Health Organization has found similar results with Vit A and measles:

All children in developing countries diagnosed with measles should receive two doses of vitamin A supplements, given 24 hours apart. This can help prevent eye damage and blindness. Vitamin A supplements have been shown to reduce the number of deaths from measles by 50%.

From WHO fact sheet 286 on measles.

By Navigator (not verified) on 08 Feb 2012 #permalink

Okay, wtf. A notification about this entry did NOT appear in my inbox. I'm glad I decided to randomly check over the front page of your blag. I'm OUTraged(tiny exclamation point)