The future of philosophical discourse.

Seen in a comment on A Philosophy Job Market Blog:

... instead of writing "QED" at the end of proofs, I think we should all start writing "pwned." I want this change to be my legacy to philosophy.

More like this

Last week, while I was occupied with Tangled Bank, a reader left me this comment: I was just wondering, how did you change from chemistry to philosophy? What little career steps were involved -- if you don't mind my asking. - From an academic considering a career change. Below the fold, my secret…
Where we left off in part 1: In my fifth (and last) year of funding in my philosophy Ph.D. program, staring down 30, trying to finish a dissertation, and bracing myself for the rigors of the academic job market, I said to myself, "How could having a baby make things noticably more difficult?" Then…
In Tuesday's post I started discussing this essay (PDF format), by mathematician Doron Zeilberger. I wholeheartedly seconded the sentiments from the first part of the essay, in which he lamented the generally poor state of mathematical communication. But I'm a little skeptical of this part: The…
Steven Weinberg reviews The God Delusion. It's almost entirely positive—one exception is that he takes Dawkins to task for being too even-handed and well-intentioned towards Islam. I particularly enjoyed his criticisms of the critics. Here's a familiar argument: The reviews of The God Delusion in…

Seen in a comment on A Philosophy Job Market Blog:

... instead of writing "QED" at the end of proofs, I think we should all start writing "pwned." I want this change to be my legacy to philosophy.

Interesting. I'd always associated this sort of "in-group jargon" with early teenagers trying to baffle their parents, but I think I'm noticing increasing use among bloggers.

This isn't intended to be some sort of insult, by the way, just an observation.

By Scott Belyea (not verified) on 22 Feb 2008 #permalink

O RLY? As web-based social entertainments become a more pervasive part of popular culture it is to be expected that the shorthand forms and novel constructs of those environments (even if they make for nearly impenetrable in-game conversation) will disseminate. Even the folk history of MMOs has penetrated beyond web parlance and into the larger culture (i.e. Leeroy Jenkins). "Pwned", if anyone ever figures out just how to pronounce it, might become a part of standard everyday English someday, not just the parlance of the l33t.

Scott, you don't think that "QED" is also a form of in-group jargon? (How many of us regularly speak or write in Latin, for example?)

By philosoraptor (not verified) on 22 Feb 2008 #permalink

Interesting. I'd always associated this sort of "in-group jargon" with early teenagers trying to baffle their parents, but I think I'm noticing increasing use among bloggers.

It's from gaming. The kiddies picked it up from them. Most of these things are "AOLisms", but that one isn't.

See also: "Camping"

But "AOLisms" don't even originate in "trying to confuse the 'rents", either... it has more to do with saving time, lack of spelling ability, and typos. The fact that it annoys the hell out of your parents is an extra benefit, and increases propagation.

I heartily endorse this idea.

To avoid obscurisms like QED or pwned, just write "So there!"

I've been doing that since high school. (The teacher liked when I did it and it became the class norm.) My students certainly have had no trouble remembering what it means.

I have been known to grade papers with incredulous 'LOLs' written in the margin. I think the kids appreciate it.

It's official, I'm finishing my thesis with "kthxbai".