#scio10 preparation: Where does civility hit the skids?

Today, on account of the fact that I'm pinned down doing course updating activities, I present you with a poll. In answering the question, go ahead and use whatever is your preferred definition of "civility".

Of course, use the comments to discuss to your heart's content (including where I went wrong in constructing the poll options).

More like this

Two weeks from today, at ScienceOnline '10, Dr. Isis, Sheril Kirshenbaum, and I will be leading a session called "Online Civility and Its (Muppethugging) Discontents". In preparation for this, the three of us had a Skype conference last night, during which it became clear to us that there are many…
I made it to Charlottesville, and am all checked in to the Econo Lodge, which is a little more Econo than I was expecting. It's an old-school motel, with rooms that open right into the parking lot, the sort of place where the towels are tiny and scratchy, the pillows and mattresses are thin, and…
You can't say who really won the debate, because on Friday, news broke, confirming other news from the prior Monday (and general suspicians) indicating that Donald Trump is not fit to be President in Yet Another Way, and his campaign essentially imploded. So, instead, we'll ask, "who won the…
Emmy and I are in Buffalo today, after a long drive last night, made longer by the NY Thruway authorities decidin to randomly sprinkle lane closures along the westbound portion of I-90. They also made the sadistic move of putting on the "tune to this radio station for information" flashers before…

In order of incompatibility with civility, from least to greatest:
the status of funding/jobs for scientific trainees nowadays; string theory; same-sex marriage; the status of underrepresented minorities in science; climate change; any issue where some blogger is using a poll to generate something with the appearance of empirical data; animal research/animal rights; drug laws; health care reform; vaccination; anything to do with religion (including atheism); abortion; anything involving comrade physio prof; rainbows and puppies

I have a suspicion that the nationality of the voter will affect their vote, e.g. in some countries gay marriage is less of an issue, ditto for religion.

Tisk, tisk, you violated one of Dillman's principles for writing survey questions: "Develop response categories that are mutually exclusive."

"Anything to do with religion (including atheism)" intersects with... well, almost everything else on the list, in one way or the other ;)

I voted for vaccination, but wow geez religion is the clear winnah. You now know what to write about Janet. WooooHooooo! I'm rarin' fer a FahYer FaHight!!

One of my favorites isn't on the list. Want to see a breakdown in civility? Go visit the comments section of any NYTimes article on infertility. Yowza.

By kickabout (not verified) on 13 Jan 2010 #permalink

Hehehehhe.... Depends on what crazy guy shows up. The whole canoe stunt almost rivals eating babies.

The places I usually visit, it's nationalism. You haven't seen a flame war until you've seen Bosnians, Albanians, Serbs, and Croats all arguing about which country a certain town belongs to...

By truth is life (not verified) on 14 Jan 2010 #permalink

Gun control debates are way up there. I don't think I've seen a group of people quicker to anger than those who are obsessed with carrying guns.

By Epinephrine (not verified) on 17 Jan 2010 #permalink