Natural Selection

Every time I put this video up, You Tube eliminates it. So look quick before it goes away again.

More like this

Nonmedical people always seem to have a conception of surgery as being a particularly glamorous profession. So did I to some extent before I entered medical school, although my surgical rotations quickly disabused me of that impression. Somehow, working from 5 AM to 11 PM every day and several…
I'm still feeling pretty lethargic, but I hope that will improve when I get to lecture about the EPR paradox in Quantum Optics today (it's going to be kind of a short lecture, unless I can ad-lib an introduction to Bell's Theorem at the end of the class, but then I've been holding them late for…
Sometimes I get asked to do some demos for kids. I like this, it is fun. This week, I was asked to do just such a demo. Kind of as a historical record, I am going to document what I did. The audience It is always important to think about who you are talking to. Is this a group of high school…
As I mentioned, I was on the road over the weekend. Unfortunately, that means I didn't manage to come up with a new post for this morning. That's OK, though. Off to the archives we go. This post originally appeared on February 7, 2006. Holy crap! That's over two years ago! Enjoy (I hope). Fear not…

"...Strongest, smartest, fastest..." Frankly, the creationists don't need this kind of help building strawmen. And I can't say I'm thrilled with the offensive stereotypes.

Yes, I know it is intended to be funny.

It's true - I DO live in a sea of idiots!

Let me try commenting a second time, and maybe this one will get through.

The video does not present an accurate view of the Theory of Evolution, to begin with--it claims that natural selection insures that "the strongest, the smartest, the fastest" will out-reproduce others. This, of course, is simply not true, and it is a strawman that anti-evolutionists have latched onto to claim eugenic motives behind those godless Darwinists. Reproductive fitness is not [necessarily] about strength, intelligence, or speed--just ask bacteria. So from that perspective, this is not a helpful video for anyone concerned about teaching Evolution.

Secondly, of course, its use of offensive stereotypes does not do us any favors. Yes, of course, it was meant to be funny. But making fun of lower-IQ individuals does not exactly win friends and influence people. My question would not be "why do they keep taking it down?", but rather, "why have you been posting it?"

I hope that my first comment was merely lost in your junk bin, and that you did not actively choose to suppress it.

They probably take it down b/c it's from a movie, Idiocracy. Copyright rules and all that jazz...

By koffeekat (not verified) on 18 Jan 2008 #permalink