Classic News: The Ivy League Nude Posture Photo Scandal

One fall afternoon ... I was summoned to... a windowless room on an upper floor, where men dressed in crisp white garments instructed me to remove all of my clothes. ... four-inch metal pins were affixed... to my vertebrae at regular intervals from my neck down. I was positioned against a wall; a floodlight illuminated my pin-spiked profile and a camera captured it. ... I'd been told that this "posture photo" was ... routine... Those whose pins described ... erratic postural curve were required to attend remedial posture classes.

1995 New York Times by Ron Rosenbaum.

More like this

Have any of you started a project that you thought would take ten minutes to complete, only to find that the project has morphed into a huge and tangled event that has taken over your entire life? I am trapped in the middle of such a project right now. [Image source: Half the deck]. This project…
Blame it on Abel, who blogged his vasectomy, and Janet, who blogged her mammogram. Also blame Drugmonkey and Physioprof, who along with Abel, Janet, and others encouraged me to Blog My D&C. Yep. So here goes. It all started innocently enough back in May with my annual exam. First…
The title of the Nature paper is "Fetal load and the evolution of lumbar lordosis in bipedal hominins" (Nature 450, 1075-1078 (13 December 2007) | doi:10.1038/nature06342) and the Editor's comment is given the slightly snappier title, "The mother load." (Nature (DOI:10.1038/nature06342). But I like…
Long-time blog readers will know that I am atrocious at keeping promises. And I will confess that part of the reason for titling an article 'Goodbye Tetrapod Zoology' was to cause a burst of panic, a rash of visitors (the strategy didn't really work: look at the counter... no spike on the graph).…

This is not a surprise. I knew someone from Smith college who did her work study in the archives, and periodically came across, and was instructed to destroy them.

They were common knowledge, though the thought that semi-nude photos of Barbara Bush and Nancy Reagan were at one point on file, gave cause for pause.

Greg this is just another one of a long sad string of fads that educationists have come up with. I am old enough to remember the school nurse, in junior high, coming around periodically to lecture about posture. She even had dolls with good and bad posture, right alongside her giant teeth to show how to brush.

After all notice how poor children and bored children slouch. Must be the bad posture causing the bad behavior and failure to learn.

My bet would be that in fifty years people will be laughing just as hard at affirmative action and diversity, the current fad (but being replaced these days by sustainability), as they do about posture these days.

Henry

By henry harpending (not verified) on 03 Jun 2009 #permalink

I remember reading about this back in '95. What surprises me is that it seems all the students sheepishly went along with it. Did no student simply refuse? Would the authorities of the school really have kicked a student out for refusing to take part in this?

We might think of this as a Milgram experiment. How much humiliation will teens--and as teens tend to be quite uncomfortable about their bodies, this was a terrible humiliation--undergo if they perceive it is required by arbitrary authority?

The men involved didn't care much, but the women, generally, did. The men, had they cared, might or might not have resisted. The women certainly cared, but manifestly didn't resist.

What does it mean that the only visible resistance arose at the University of Washington?

By Nathan Myers (not verified) on 03 Jun 2009 #permalink