A piece in the Star Tribune by my friend John Funk:
Friends and family members were grieving Monday for a 20-year-old Marine from Rochester, Minn., whose death Friday in Afghanistan was called "a horrible loss" by his family pastor....
- Log in to post comments
More like this
Richard Dawkins was interviewed in the Minneapolis Star-Tribune, and whips out some of his standard 'arrogance'.
Q Here are quotes about faith from two thoughtful Twin Cities clergy members. What is your response to each?
The Rev. Greg Boyd, pastor of Woodland Hills Church in Maplewood: "I thirst…
Brought to you by guest blogger LisaJ:
Canada lost two soldiers serving in Afghanistan this week. This marks the 89th
and 90th Canadian soldier to be killed since starting our peacekeeping mission in Afghanistan in 2002. Master Corporal Josh Roberts leaves behind his fiancé in Manitoba, and…
Minnesota and the Upper Midwest, for some reason, is the home of (by US standards, anyway) some of the most extreme (or at least interesting) criminal behavior, and not just in the movies. And today, in Shakopee, Minnesota, a freshly convicted 20 year old was sentenced to life in prison with no…
Even in a snowy winter landscape, I feel as if I'm surrounded by fractals. In order to capture this feeling, I turned to the complex topography of the Mandelbrot set. I added an fBm coloring algorithm, to mimic the soft hues of a winter storm. When the fractal was complete, I decided to superimpose…
who cares.
Oh, anyone with a bit of empathy, really. So, most non-sociopaths.
Come on. A crazy christian dies on crusade? fuck him and his whole family.
Way to stay classy, Nonbeliever, you gonna go join Fred Phelps protesting across the street from funerals too?
I have reason to suspect that non-believer is Dave Mabus pretending to be an atheist.
I can't help thinking about the Afghanis he killed, or helped to kill. About that recent video from wikileaks.
This made the front page of the Rochester Post-Bulletin. He's the second or third person from the area to be killed on active duty. If we weren't in Afganistan, he'd still be alive. War is such a waste.
Paul -
I think it is important to realize that not all soldiers are like that. That is not to say that I support the war in Afghanistan - I never did, any more than I support/ed the war in Iraq. What I do support, with the exception of insane fucking rogues, are the troops we stuck over there. Short of some evidence that he was such a soldier, I will sympathize with his family and accept it was a useless waste - just as I think of the people he may have killed and the waste of their losses.
In all honesty, and I know there are people who would totally disagree with me on this, I do not have the least sympathy for the loss of the folks who are engaging in the sort of slaughter depicted in the video I assume you are talking about. I think that rather than there hypothetical deaths being a waste, I think they themselves are a waste of resources.
But I know people who have spent a great deal of time in Iraq and/or Afghanistan. A couple of people I know are there now. I have a cousin who spent the better part of two and a half years over there, who is now an instructor at a sniper school. I have seen him a couple of times since he went over - he looks like my cousin, with a few more years on him. But that is where any resemblance to the man I knew before he went to war. He is not the only person in my family or among my friends who was taken from us by war while still breathing.
None of these people are bad people. Some are rather misguided, while a couple - including my cousin, were just shooting for a college education and had the misfortune of doing so when war broke out. Like my cousin, a couple of them have taken human lives. I think this is horrifying - and so do they. But they did what they did, because that was their job - a commitment they made.
I guess what I am saying, is that I have a great deal of sympathy for the Afghans and our troops.