A federal judge in Wisconsin ruled the National Day of Prayer unconstitutional Thursday, saying the day amounts to a call for religious action.
U.S. District Judge Barbara Crabb wrote that the government can no more enact laws supporting a day of prayer than it can encourage citizens to fast during Ramadan, attend a synagogue or practice magic.
"In fact, it is because the nature of prayer is so personal and can have such a powerful effect on a community that the government may not use its authority to try to influence an individual's decision whether and when to pray," Crabb wrote.
- Log in to post comments
More like this
Jordan Lorence, the ADF attorney who wrote the post on judicial activism that I replied to the other day has responded. He doesn't link to the response or mention me at all, but I assume it's my post he's responding to because my post was titled "ADF's Double Talk on Judicial Activism" and his…
According to a recent CNN article, a federal judge recently stuck down the Bush administration's request that the laws surrounding pesticide use be relaxed. Yes, they want MORE pesticides and more liberal use of them. I usually stop myself short when I'm tempted to say that the Bush admin hurts…
In a major ruling with enormous implications, a federal judge has ruled that the government has 45 days to charge Jose Padilla with a crime, prove that he is a material witness and must be held, or release him. Padilla, a US citizen, has been held for over two and a half years in a military prison…
One of the most frightening trends of the last few years is the alarming increase in anti-judicial rhetoric from the right. The courts, of course, are a convenient whipping boy for politicians who have to manipulate the populace to get elected to office. The courts are often in the position of…
And this has no effect on the National Day of Reason.
Cue a howling Tea Party protest in 5... 4...
In thanks for this victory, we bow our heads and pray...
oh wait, lets par-tay and munch babies instead!
Although a combined "day of prayer, fasting, going to shul, practicing magic or not doing anything spiritual at all" might be allowable.
It will be interesting to see whether the Justice Department is going to appeal the ruling - seems (according to the linked article) that all the conservative legal groups have come up with in opposition is just: "but it's a tradition!", which probably amounts to diddly/squat in legal terms.
And apparently the White House doesn't care, they are planning on celebrating it anyway.
Obama is such a mixed bag, it gets really frustrating.
Between this story, Obama letting gay spouses into hospital rooms, and an increased budget for NASA, let this Canadian say I like some of the directions the U.S. is headed in again.
Remember: It is not as though Obama was heading away from gay rights and is now heading back in the right direction. He was giving the liberals the old hand-clam and telling us to quieten down a bit while he does this one thing, giving conservatives the steady unblinking evil eye and holding his cards in close on several issues, while kicking along the proverbial can (health care) until it got done.
Jimmy carter, southern cracker white guy, was able to sign an executive order to provide amnesty to all the long haired hippie commie freak draft dodgers hiding in lumberjack shacks up in Canaidahoovia as his very first act seconds after walking off the podium for his inauguration. Big scary black guy socialist Obama has to do the outrageous thing with a different strategy.
As many of us have been saying all along. Just sayin'. Still.
(I hope.)