Interesting Intelligent Design and Evolution Spat Going On

Mike Haubrich, of Tangled Up in Blue Guy blog, has documented a discussion between a biologist, a commenter, and the Discovery Institute (a creationist "think" tank). No apes were harmed during this incident, but one of them may be rather embarrassed. It's quite intresting, have a look: Cornelius Godsplains Science to a Scientist

More like this

Bing, son of blogger and politico Mike Haubrich, has just arrived in Japan where he will spend several months assisting in a linguistic research project in the Greater Tokyo Metro area. And hopefully getting around the country a bit to see some cool stuff. He's got a web site tracking his trip…
This Sunday, August 30th, at 9:00 AM, I'll be on the radio with John Abraham, climate scientist. This will be an edition of Minnesota Atheist Talk Radio hosted by Mike Haubrich. The discussion of climate change will be interesting and important and you should listen live or listen to the podcast…
Social Media and Atheism .... an Atheist Talk Conversation with Mike Haubrich, Stephanie Zvan and Greg Laden. We talk about trolls too. The rug really ties the conversation together. Click Here to see or download the MP4. Embedded version may or may not be below the fold: Here is the first…
Florida Senate Bill S2692 is up for discussion and a decision to pass to the floor by the Senate Judiciary Committee. BELOW YOU WILL FIND LINKS TO EMAIL EACH MEMBER OF THE COMMITTEE (except one, for whom I provide a phone number). I'd say you don't need to be a Florida resident to let them…

Ho hum. Not to reopen an old wound but everyone in that discussion is missing the point. What are the odds that hydrogen and oxygen will combine to make water? What are the odds that hydrogen bonding and Van der Waal's forces will result in ice floating on liquid water, allowing life to survive freezing temperatures? No one can even approach these questions. There are still papers being published concerning the odds of flipping fair coins (e.g. http://comptop.stanford.edu/u/preprints/heads.pdf)!

My take is that life is just as much a property of the universe as is electromagnetic radiation. My response to the Discovery Institute folk would be to produce a probablistic proof that their deity is the one true deity.

--bks

I think it is improbable that an all-male triune god would have created everything to. I am not saying that creation is impossible, just highly improbable.

@bks,
I'd back it up and have the loons produce probabilistic proof that any deity exists.

The sad thing is, it's really not that interesting. It's sad and depressing actually, since Cornelius is serving to reinforce the viewpoints of 40+% of Amurikans.

I gotta agree with Lorax and bks: there's nothing new here, except for the word "Godsplaining." Just another creationist trying to pretend a long-debunked argument is still alive.

I predict that Antyony McCarthy (the LEVELER donchaknow!) will show up here and try to gum up the debate with his own long-debunked arguments, pet peeves and outright lies about how science can't possibly know everything, therefore it can't know anytyhing, and don't call him religious even though it's obvious he is.

FYI, my 'not that interesting' response was directed at the 'conversation' between myself and the wall creationist. It is not directed at Mike's post, which of course is interesting!