1. gregladen
  2. Alan Cassels: Seeking Sickness

Alan Cassels: Seeking Sickness

By gregladen on July 13, 2012.

Alan Cassels wrote Seeking Sickness: Medical Screening and the Misguided Hunt for Disease, which is all:

Why wouldn't you want to be screened to see if you're at risk for cancer, heart disease, or another potentially lethal condition? After all, better safe than sorry. Right?

Not so fast, says Alan Cassels. His Seeking Sickness takes us inside the world of medical screening, where well-meaning practitioners and a profit-motivated industry offer to save our lives by exploiting our fears. He writes that promoters of screening overpromise on its benefits and downplay its harms, which can range from the merely annoying to the life threatening. If you're facing a screening test for breast or prostate cancer, high cholesterol, or low testosterone, someone is about to turn you into a patient. You need to ask yourself one simple question: Am I ready for all the things that could go wrong?

Desiree Schell will interview Alan Cassels before a live internet audience on Skeptically Speaking this Sunday night. Details here.

Tags
Uncategorized

More like this

Rethinking cancer screening?
Here we go again. I see that the kerfuffle over screening for cancer has erupted again to the point where it's found its way out of the rarified air of specialty journals to general medical journals and hence into the mainstream press. This is something that seems to pop up every so often, much to…
No, the New York Times did not "kill your patient."
One of the more depressing things about getting much more interested in the debate over how we should screen for common cancers, particularly breast and prostate cancer, is my increasing realization of just how little physicians themselves understand about the complexities involved in weighing the…
Overdiagnosis of breast cancer due to mammography
Screening for disease, especially cancer, is a real bitch. I was reminded of this by the publication of a study in BMJ the very day of the Science-Based Medicine Conference a week and a half ago. Unfortunately, between The Amaz!ng Meeting and other activities, I was too busy to give this study the…
No, the PSA test probably didn't save Ben Stiller's life
A frequent topic of discussion on this blog is the concept of overdiagnosis. It’s a topic I’ve been writing about regularly since around 2007 or so and is defined as the detection in an asymptomatic person of disease that, if left alone, would never progress to endanger that person’s life or well-…

Yes, I have issues with harms that may be caused by the screenings. First of all, the radiation is not benign, Secondly, it may be a false positive leading to unnecessary surgery, which has a very real risk of complications--up to AND including death. I WILL be listening. I'm sure he has more to add.