Medicinal mavericks

Consensus is a dirty word when it comes to climate change experts, but put in just about any other context, expert consensus is what we all would want. This Marc Roberts cartoon casts that issue in the best light:

i-68a23a6f226610b65bf6e4234047e323-Maverickcartoon2082-thumb-500x371-58511.jpg

Just imagine getting medical assistance from Lord Cristopher Monckton... Oh look! We don't have to imagine.

I began to think that Viscount Monckton might be a formidable opponent during the debate. Then he told me that he has discovered a new drug that is a complete cure for two-thirds of known diseases - and that he expects it to go into clinical trials soon. I asked him whether his miracle cure was chiefly effective against viruses or bacterial diseases? "Both", he said, "and prions". At this point I felt a little more relaxed about the forthcoming debate.

Categories

More like this

When last we heard from Christopher Monckton he was too gravely ill to answers questions about how someone claiming to be him and using his ISP had altered his own wikipedia entry and added on obvious fabrication, to wit, The Guardian "is reported to have paid Monckton £50,000 in damages.".…
Lincoln Chafee, Hillary Clinton, Martin O'Malley, Bernie Sanders, and Jim Webb faced off in the Facebook-CNN sponsored debate. Who won? The individual who "won" is the individual whose poll numbers went up the most, and we don't know that yet. But there are other ways to win, and other ways to…
Eating your enemies is a time honored method for winning. It is rarely used by American politicians or their supporters. Here is how you eat your enemy. I'll use a generalized example based on several events during the GOP debates. Moderator: Mr. Trump, you've said 'bla bla bla bla'. Alternate…
"One of my favorite philosophical tenets is that people will agree with you only if they already agree with you. You do not change people's minds." -Frank Zappa One of the most difficult things to talk about, for any self-respecting scientist, is politics. Like all of you, I have my preferences, my…

I'm no fan of Monckton, but fairness requires me to add what is given at the close of the Financial Times blog report you linked to Coby ("A night at the Oxford Union"):

"Late update - Added on November 9th. Viscount Monckton felt that I had unfairly misrepresented our conversation. I am happy to print a response and clarification from him, which appears below:
Lord Monckton has pointed out an inadvertent inaccuracy and unfairness in my account of the medical invention on which he is working. Though there is a substantial body of theoretical and empirical evidence that his invention may prove efficacious against multiple infectious and auto-immune diseases, he did not and does not make any claim that the invention will prove efficacious. That is precisely why, as he told me when we met at Oxford, a series of appropriately sceptical clinical trials will commence shortly in the United States."

Of course, many of Monckton's other pronouncements stated in theage.com article Coby linked to do show him to be somewhat flaky!

By GGMcGready (not verified) on 29 Nov 2010 #permalink

Quoted from Moncton's response:

Lord Monckton has pointed out an inadvertent inaccuracy and unfairness in my account of the medical invention on which he is working. Though there is a substantial body of theoretical and empirical evidence that his invention may prove efficacious against multiple infectious and auto-immune diseases, he did not and does not make any claim that the invention will prove efficacious.

Quoted from Monckton's CV from UK Independence Party:

2008-present: RESURREXI Pharmaceutical: Director responsible for invention and development of a broad-spectrum cure for infectious diseases. Patents have now been filed. Patients have been cured of various infectious diseases, including Gravesâ Disease, multiple sclerosis, influenza, and herpes simplex VI. Our first HIV patient had his viral titre reduced by 38% in five days, with no side-effects. Tests continue.

Why are AGW deniers also pathological liars (see also the lies told by an AGW denier in the thread with over 400 posts).?

By Ian Forrester (not verified) on 29 Nov 2010 #permalink

Uranus is not part of the human body. It's a planet in our solar system.Or is astrology park of the humor? Hospitals don't permit visitors to perform procedures.
Jokes that mimmick reality are funny. Made up non-sense, especially on a so-called scienceblog, usually goes over like a lead balloon.

By laursaurus (not verified) on 06 Dec 2010 #permalink

Uranus is not part of the human body.

Ha ha ha! Coby, laursaurus has unintentionally raised an excellent point, which is that unintentional comedy is also very funny.

More funny, laursaurus! More!

Uranus is not part of the human body. It's a planet in our solar system.Or is astrology park of the humor? Hospitals don't permit visitors to perform procedures.
Jokes that mimick reality are funny. Made up non-sense, especially on a so-called scienceblog, is not.

By laursaurus (not verified) on 07 Dec 2010 #permalink