If "alternative" medicine is okay, why not "alternative" cleaning?

With all the woo infiltrating hospitals these days, as I've lamented about in constructing my Academic Woo Aggregator, it was only a matter of time until these ways of thinking started to infiltrate other lines of work.

Why not "alternative janitorial services" as well? After reading about it, I wonder how long before it spreads any further. How about "alternative" auto repair? Or even "alternative" plumbing? The possibilities are endless.

More like this

David Colquhoun, eminent scientist and maintainer of the excellent blog DC's Improbable Science, has recently returned home to the U.K. after a trip across the pond to the U.S. and Canada, where, among other things, he gave a lecture at the University of Toronto, as well as the Riker Memorial…
Yesterday, I expressed my dismay at learning that what used to be a bastion of science-based medicine, the Cleveland Clinic Foundation, is now peddling the quackery known as acupuncture to children, or, as I put it, "integrating" nonsense with science. Sadly, as I've written about all too often…
I've been writing about a phenomenon that I like to refer to as "quackademic medicine," defined as the infiltration into academic medical centers and medical school of unscientific and pseudoscientific treatment modalities that are unproven or disproven. I didn't coin the term. To the best of my…
The infiltration of quackademic medicine continues apace, except that it's not just quackademic medicine. Now, it goes way, way beyond that to encompass not just academic medical centers but community hospitals, hospitals of all sizes, large private hospitals, and health care institutions of all…

That was seriously funny.

Maybe next we'll see alternative alternative medicine. Ya know, where a patient, energetically harmed by a homeopathic remedy is successfully treated at a Reiki Rehabilitation Clinic.

They tried alternative cleaning methods in the NHS when domestic services were put out to tender and won by the lowest bidder. The alternative method tried was not cleaning, or least cleaning without anyone doing any supervision and no one actually taking any responsibility for how clean the wards were.

It killed people. It still is killing people.

By Matt Penfold (not verified) on 27 Jan 2008 #permalink

Don't tell me you've never read this.

They've *got* to be kidding - homeopathic ammonia???

It's Sunday and instead of battling with my daughter to clean up her stuff, I could use a little healing energy to resolve the cluttering fields around my house.

That Novella piece was great. I honestly didn't see it before writing about alternative janitorial services. I was responding to the fluff piece written recently on the use of irregular medicine in academic hospitals.

A few years ago, Scientific American suggested that what we really need are Alternative Illnesses. For example- feldspar deficiency or leaky karma. Past-life bursitis is quite challenging to diagnose.

Janitorial Alternate Methods (JAM) are of course being integrated with traditional Western forms of cleaning. Bleach and water is simply being supplemented by re-balancing the energy fields. There is no need to choose one method over the other, both have their uses.

The unified, complementary form of disinfection is usually referred to as TOtal Janitorial Alternative Method (or TO-JAM.)

My favorite part of the whole article:
'Back at Children's Memorial, Timmy is sleeping soundly and Clancy Simmons is going about his work of providing a clean and comfortable environment for children and their families to heal. "I wait until nobody's in the room and the kid is asleep, then I just clean up real fast. Some people will believe anything."'

Haha. Basically they do the woo cleaning and when everyone's gone, do the real cleaning. It figures.

Homeopathic ammonia my butt. I bet this is how many hospitals utilizing this nonsense is doing it--pandering the the woo-meisters, and then covering their back ends with real cleaning services.

It's a sham on both ends.

Homeopathic Cleaning ?
you throw a little bit of dirt in a big, big bottle of water, and use that for a cleaning fluid ?

I can just see alternative driving. Would be a boon to quadruple amputees.

Cop: Mister, why are you naked, and how did you drive this car?

Driver: Why do you think I'm naked?

The tire shop up the street uses accupuncture and accupressure!! They are great! My transmission has been vastly improved by the new feng shui radials they sold me last month!!!

I noticed the contrast to "evidence-based cleaning techniques." Has there ever been a randomized double-blind test comparing different cleaning techniques?

Alternative Janitorial Services are becoming popular because they clean the entire building, not just the visible surfaces.

How about alternative restaurants? They fawn over you from the minute you walk in the door, seat you in alignment with feng shui, serve you a homeopathic cocktail (1 mcg gin in a wineglass of distilled spring water), feed you a line of crap, and charge you $300 for the pleasure.

Alternative plumbing already exists ... dowsing.

By Patrick Caldon (not verified) on 28 Jan 2008 #permalink

The piece on alternative engineering made me think of the Monty Python skit about apartment buildings put up by hypnosis. Residents have to believe in them, or the buildings instantly collapse.

By Calli Arcale (not verified) on 29 Jan 2008 #permalink

The piece on alternative engineering made me think of the Monty Python skit about apartment buildings put up by hypnosis. Residents have to believe in them, or the buildings instantly collapse.

By Calli Arcale (not verified) on 29 Jan 2008 #permalink