# The violent rhetoric of the antivaccine movement, "I didn't really mean it" edition

It’s always nice when I learn that a target of my—shall we say?—Insolence takes note of what I’ve written. Well, maybe not always nice. Sometimes that notice takes the form of attacks, such as those by our good quack buddy Mike Adams, who’s been writing mean and nasty things about me for over three months now, although I do note that he’s become painfully, tediously repetitive. It’s as though he’s not even trying any more. Sometimes, however, it’s someone less ludicrous and more potentially dangerous. I’m referring in this case to Del Bigtree and Polly Tommey, the producers of Andrew Wakefield’s antivaccine “documentary” VAXXED that’s making the rounds in theaters across the country. To publicize the movie and its antivaccine message, the combination of (usually) Bigtree and Polley have been doing Q&As after screenings all over the country. During those Q&As, Bigtree and Tommey have been saying some pretty outrageous things. Tommey, for instance, said that she won’t judge parents who kill their autistic children, while Bigtree has frequently compared school vaccine mandates to the Holocaust, slavery, and apartheid and, most recently, was noted by Matt Carey and myself to have said something that could reasonably be construed as urging antivaccinationists to take up arms to resist “forced vaccination.”

Well, they’ve responded on Facebook. Before I get to their response, though, let me just remind you what they said. First, here’s Polley Tommey regarding judging parents who murder their autistic children:

Excerpt: Parents are taking the lives of their children already because they won’t leave their children in the world as it is today, and I for one will never judge them for what they did. I discussed the full context of the quote in my treatment of her despicable statements and included a link to the Facebook page with the full video.

Now here’s what Del Bigtree said:

…but now we’re watching the most powerful lobby in the country and in the world poisoning our children. And our government is helping them. What are we going to do about it? We have the power. But we have got to stop being afraid to talk about it. If you’re afraid to talk about it, your Twitters, your Facebooks, I don’t want to bring it up at my PTA meeting, I don’t want to at lunch or at Thanksgiving dinner, then I can imagine those same conversations were happening in Nazi Germany among the Jewish people. Let’s not talk about it. I don’t want to bring it into my reality. It’s still 20 miles away. I’m still allowed in this theater, not that one. All I have to get is this little star. All I have to do is to sign this little thing saying that I’m not going to vaccinate because I think they’re dangerous—and they are dangerous. I’m just going to sign this paper. I’m going to let them put me in a log. At some point, they have gone too far.

Do you think it’s a good idea to let the government own your baby’s body and right behind it your body? That is the end for me. Anyone who believes in the right to bear arms. To stand up against your government. I don’t know what you were saving that gun for then. I don’t know when you planned on using it if they were going to take control of your own body away.

It’s now. Now’s the time.

I don’t know how else that can be interpreted as a vague incitement to violence. Sure, as a pedant pointed out yesterday, it doesn’t rise to the Brandenburg v. Ohio standards of an imminent threat of lawless action to a specific person or persons, but it’s still pretty bad. Bigtree is basically asking all those antivaccinationists with guns what they’re waiting for if they believe that one purpose of the Second Amendment is to assure the ability of the people to resist the government if it ever descends into tyranny (which he considers "forced vaccination" to be). Whether Bigtree realizes it or not, it’s the same sort of coded appeal to violence that radical antiabortion activists use to inspire acts of violence against doctors who perform abortions.

Clearly, both Bigtree and Tommey—especially Bigtree—were stung by the criticism of their irresponsible statements. Clearly, at some level, Bigtree, at least, seems to realize that he crossed the line and went too far. But, as Matt Carey notes, he just can’t quite force himself to do the right thing and just apologize and take back what he said. Instead, he bobs and weaves and then digs himself in even deeper by trotting out even more ridiculous Holocaust analogies. I tell ya, I was so tempted to resurrect a certain undead Fuhrer to feast on his brain, but clearly there would have been nothing there for the Hitler Zombie to consume. So here, in its full context, is Bigtree and Tommey’s response:

I emphasize full context, because the first things Bigtree says, after some annoying banter about the “VAXXED bus,” that he and Tommey will be using to tour the US in support of their documentary when it is done, consist of:

• Whining about being “taken out of context” (Bigtree) or having their videos “edited” (Tommey). Whatever.
• “Trolls” who are “watching everything we say and trying to cut out anything they can use against us,” which he relates to politics as a behavior that forces politicians to stick to safe sound bites that “can’t be taken out of context.” Whatever.
• Bragging about how they “shoot from the hip.”

He then claims that his words about guns were taken out of context but does concede that it wasn’t “exactly the best constructed statement ever.” He then goes on to disingenuously deny that he meant in any way that antivaccine parents should pick up their gun and start fighting. As I surmised, although he doesn’t admit it, he was just blowing a lot of hot air. He admits that he doesn’t own a gun, that he’s never owned a gun, and that he didn’t grow up around guns. He even went on about how he cared so little about guns that he didn’t really care when people expressed fear that the government was trying to restrict their right to own a gun because, well, such issues didn’t really concern him given that he didn’t own any guns and didn’t want to. Then he says:

But the truth is, then you get to a law that I care about, that I don’t want the medical industry enforcing their policies, their ideas, or their drugs onto my children or me, and I see that as a constitutional right. And then suddenly I start looking at gun laws again, you know, I didn’t stand up for those people fighting for their constitutional right to own a gun, to be able to hunt in a country that was designed to be free, and so all of a sudden I have an issue that I want people to take seriously. Maybe they’re like “I don’t care about vaccines.” And it reminded me of this poem that heard. I just want to read it real quick. Most of you have probably heard it, but ti comes out of Nazi Germany, I believe it was a pastor that wrote this. I think it’s really profound. What he wrote was:

First they came for the Communists, and I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist.

Then they came for the Socialists, and I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Socialist.

When they came for the Unionists, I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Unionist.

When they came for the Jews, I did not speak out—
Because I was not a Jew.

Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.

So what was Bigtree’s excuse? He claims he was standing up for the Second Amendment because he doesn’t think that people pay enough attention to each other’s concerns. What it sounded more like to me may not be what he meant, but one could also say that this was yet another of Bigtree’s not-so-well constructed lines of thinking. Basically, it sounded as though he claiming that he stood up for gun rights because he was hoping that gun owners would care about vaccines too. He hastens to add that he doesn’t think violence is the way to solve anything and that peaceful protest can bring about change, which he might actually believe. His statement still comes across as disingenuous given that his full statement in context was hard to interpret any other way but a call for armed resistance couched in a manner sufficiently vague that it falls just this side of Brandenburg v. Ohio.

Hilariously, Tommey at one point in chimes in about the “trolls” who, apparently, take their words out of context and edit them deceptively. Even more hilariously, she urges her audience to “come to us” for an explanation. It was at this point that irony meters everywhere spontaneously burst into flames and melted into a pile of plastic and copper goo, the only remnants of their cases and wires, given how the first trailer for VAXXED featured the dishonest editing of snippets of dialogue from different phone conversations to give the impression that this was one conversation. No, both Matt and I made sure to link to the entire video. I pointed out the approximate time in the video where the relevant conversations were. Both of us encourage you to watch the both videos in their entirety that we discussed, because, believe me, Polley’s justifying murder and Bigtree’s vague call for armed resistance were only the two worst things in those videos. There was so much more.

She also seems to think that she was being accused of actually advocating killing autistic children. It’s a lovely straw man, a straw man so massive that, were it to catch fire, likely it could be seen from the International Space Station. No one ever accused her of that. What we did accuse her of was saying she wouldn’t condemn parents who murder their autistic children. She still won’t. She bobs and weaves and ducks and dodges, but in the end she doesn’t say anything new, although she does talk about building respite homes for the parents of autistic children. All of this leads into a prolonged rant against—what else?—big pharma, particularly drugs used for ADHD, like Adderall, which they seem to view as the height of evil. Apparently, they view vaccines as a “gateway drug” to Aderall and psychotropic drugs. Clearly, Tommey and Bigtree seem to think that ther are currently jackbooted soldiers like the ones below waiting to burst into their houses and forcibly vaccinate their children at gunpoint and that pediatricians will soon be doing the same with psychotropic medications, because references to Nazis are sprinkled liberally throughout the video.

They're coming to vaccinate your children!! they're coming to vaccinate your children! At least, that's what Del Bigtree wants you to think.

Particularly irritating is Tommey and Bigtree’s rants about anxiety, how you have to “work through” your anxiety, and how you shouldn’t be “drugged” for it. I know people with anxiety. For clinical anxiety, you can’t just “work through it.” People with anxiety seeking medication have already tried to “work through it.” They can’t. That’s the problem. Medications are a last resort, not a first resort. They both recommend finding a “wholistic” doctor for anxiety and depression. Such advice will lead to someone who might have been saved killing himself.

The part that made me laugh the hardest was when Bigtree became quite incensed about VAXXED being characterized as a “propaganda film.” I rather suspect that bit of complaint was aimed at me, because I’m the one who has so consistently referred to VAXXED as a propaganda film. (Thanks, Del.) He argues that VAXXED can’t be propaganda because it espouses the “minority view” and propaganda is defined as supporting the system, the majority view. Uh, no, Del. There’s no such limitation on the definition of what constitutes propaganda. Propaganda is biased communication designed to influence people to its viewpoint, often using deceptive techniques, such as the misleading presentation of information, lying by omission, using loaded imagery and language, and even outright lying. VAXXED does all these things; it is antivaccine propaganda. It’s propaganda so blatant that it would make Leni Reifenstahl, were she still alive, blush.

The problem with Bigtree and Tommey is that they can make a fairly slick documentary, where they can shoot and edit things again and again to make the crazy less apparent. When they’re up on stage in a theater in front of an audience and have to speak off the cuff, their true beliefs come through. That was the problem for them; so they blame it on “trolls.” Well, I have a message for both of them: Fact-based criticism, evne harsh, sarcastic criticism, is not “trolling.” Calling it “trolling” is simply a transparent way to try to dismiss it without answering it.

Tags
Categories

### More like this

##### The annals of “I’m not antivaccine,” part 19: Del Bigtree and Polly Tommey edition
It’s been a while since I paid attention to the movie, but the publicity among the antivaccine movement for Andrew Wakefield’s and Del Bigtree’s movie VAXXED: From Cover-Up to Catastrophe continues apace. Sadly, I missed my opportunity to see Bigtree himself doing a Q&A for the movie when it…
##### The violent rhetoric of the antivaccine movement, VAXXED edition
Back in December, I wrote about a phenomenon that I had observed from the very beginning of my sparring with those who promote antivaccine pseudoscience and thoroughly debunked idea that vaccines cause autism. It was a phenomenon that seemed to get a lot worse last year, almost certainly due to the…
##### The annals of “I’m not antivaccine,” part 20: "There is no safe vaccine" and excusing the murder of autistic children
One of the most insidious and oft-repeated myths of the antivaccine movement is that vaccines cause autism. Certainly, it is true that there was an antivaccine movement long before anyone thought of linking vaccines to autism. For example, in the the 1980s the DPT (diptheria-whole cell pertussis-…
##### Nobody promotes antivaccine nonsense in my state…without receiving some Insolence (2016 election edition)
Remember the scene in The Blues Brothers where Jake and Elwood are sitting in the Bluesmobile and come across a Nazi rally taking place on a bridge? Jake says with utter disgust, “I hate Illinois Nazis,” before driving over the bridge, forcing the Nazis to flee and jump into the river below. That’s…

After the way they use bullies, astroturf, and shills, you expect them to get trolls right?

By Dorit Reiss (not verified) on 19 Jul 2016 #permalink

[Tommey] does talk about building respite homes for the parents of autistic children.

Respite homes for the parents of autistic children, but not the children themselves?
If anyone wanted proof of just how they view autistics, that is solid.

By Julian Frost (not verified) on 19 Jul 2016 #permalink

I was very careful when creating my short video playlist of Bigtree and Tommey claims that context was retained. I knew they would claim to be misrepresented. Their claims are there for all to see. And where possible I think I linked back to the full, original Facebook videos.

By Reasonable Hank (not verified) on 19 Jul 2016 #permalink

It is truly sad that they refuse to see that their words could incite violence - against both autistic children, and against medical professionals.
They have followers who are so desperate to have someone, something to blame for their child's challenges, that they play on that emotion.
They are no better than fake faith healers and snake oil purveyors, and infinitely more dangerous.
Sadly, they keep escalating their comments, and only they will be surprised when one of their followers takes their words and turns them into action.

Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.

I didn't find that quote very applicable since vaccines are mandated for everyone, not for specific minorities.

I think the pharmaceutical companies will be pressured to change adjuvants in response to social pressure. LPS and calcium phosphate seem like safe choices and elicit a favorable immune response. With a proper reformulation, I would think that there would be much less opposition.

Some would continue to argue over personal sovereignty of course, but that could possibly be overcome by introducing tax breaks for the inoculated.

By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 19 Jul 2016 #permalink

Am I the only one who thinks that the imagery of Nazis forcibly vaccinating children is actually making it look as a point in favor of Nazis rather than a one against vaccines? As in, it is something that could be brought up in the vein of "at least they made trains run on time" if one was trying to whitewash Nazism. (I am aware they did not forcibly vaccinate, I only mean the imagery evoked by Antivax crowd).

By The Smith of Lie (not verified) on 19 Jul 2016 #permalink

@Fendlesworth

Which country has "vaccines mandated for everyone"?

Certainly not USA, Canada, UK, Australia, Germany, New Zealand, Japan...

# 5. It's always surprised us in England that, with our socialised medicine, no vaccines are compulsory, and we still get higher coverage than the US.

Nor do we have a pediatric primary care service, which, you would think, might be more effective at communicating messages relating to child health.

You might also say that, broadly, we don't allow advertising for prescription medicines, but vaccine policy people I've spoken to aren't at all approving of mandatory vaccination.

By Brian Deer (not verified) on 19 Jul 2016 #permalink

The word documentary implies at least some basis in fact. Vaxxed is a different form of film: the crockumentary.

A crockumentary is a film which purports to be factual but is in fact a complete crock of shit. The canonical example of course ios the Burzynski movie.

By Guy Chapman (not verified) on 19 Jul 2016 #permalink

@Fendlesworth:

I think the pharmaceutical companies will be pressured to change adjuvants in response to social pressure. LPS and calcium phosphate seem like safe choices and elicit a favorable immune response. With a proper reformulation, I would think that there would be much less opposition.

I'm afraid that's an antivaccine talking point. Change the formulation and there'll be less complaining. Experience doesn't bear that out. Antivaxxers had a tantrum over a preservative, thimerosal. It was taken out. They still complained.
Changing the formulation will not stop the complaining.

By Julian Frost (not verified) on 19 Jul 2016 #permalink

He argues that VAXXED can’t be propaganda because it espouses the “minority view” and propaganda is defined as supporting the system

He is really trolling for the "Most Godwin points" achievement, isn't he?
Nazi propaganda started in far-right wing newspapers, tabloids, and heck, in the form of a self-aggrandizing autobiography (which very recently was back in the News' front pages, if people could kindly remember), all of that published before the Nazis became famous. Well, certainly before they became the "system".

Propaganda could be defined as any piece supporting the views of the one producing it.
Frank Herbert, in Dune, extended the definition to include all forms of public relationship actions, even the ones based on the truth.

I believe it was a pastor that wrote this.

That's Pastor Martin Niemöller for you, Bigtree. And remove your hat when quoting him, you little man.

OK, he was on live, and I shall confess I needed the powerful internet to get the Pastor's name right.
Still, that's a very self-centered take on the poem.

The poem, or various versions thereof, is easily found on the internet, or engraved in at least three public places in the US.
It's not just about "we should hang together or we will hang separately". It's also about guilt, about "we let bad things happen to other people", as in, to people which are not part of our social tribe, quite the opposite, actually.

Gun owners don't fit the "opposite social tribe" definition. There are big philosophical overlaps between vaccine freedom and gun freedom.
More importantly, either group also don't fit the "bad things happened", certainly not in contrast to what happened in Nazi Germany.
So, as Orac said, that's a very disingenuous quote.

If Bigtree was aiming to show his superior culture, let me say I'm not impressed. This poem is very good, but also very-well known.

French saying (variously attributed to Pierre Desproges, Jean Delacour and Françoise Sagan*):

Culture is like fruit jam on a toast. The less you have, the more you spread it.

* OK, I cheated, I went and checked the source for this. But that's one of my points: I do try to check the sources for my beliefs and use them to refine my culture. I'm willing to learn. Some people are just willing to misled.

tl;dr: Bigtree is bullshitting us.

By Helianthus (not verified) on 19 Jul 2016 #permalink

@ Fendlesworth/Stuartg

Which country has “vaccines mandated for everyone”?

We do have mandatory vaccination in France. All children should get DT and Polio vaccines.
However, medical exemptions are accepted.

The great Wiki (in the French version) tells me that Italy, Belgium and Portugal also have some mandatory vaccines (about the same ones as France), although Italy may be more like the US - vaccination is a prerequisite for school admission.

By Helianthus (not verified) on 19 Jul 2016 #permalink

Julian Frost@2: To be fair [to both carers and carees], full-time carers really do need regular time-outs if they're not to burn out themselves. I often wonder how much Cult of St Andrew recruitment is fed by disordered and delusional thinking triggered by prolonged high stress in turn caused by a lack of high quality state and/or private respite care, not to mention certain personality types' inclination to make martyrs of themselves instead of ask for help while they can.

Which, of course, makes it even more sickening to watch the Wakefield circus of psychopathic Pied Pipers lead them all even further into hell for personal power and profit. And the harm this does to the forgotten autistics now right at the bottom of that festering pile… Me, I'm just hella glad I don't live anywhere that semi-automatics are easier to get than anti-psychotics, because people have died and more will be murdered before these puppetmasters are through.

Fendlesworth@3:

Some would continue to argue over personal sovereignty of course, but that could possibly be overcome by introducing tax breaks for the inoculated.

Why? You don't think protecting your own and others' kids against crippling diseases is reward enough? Hell, why not ask for a pony and a blowjob while you're at it? Spoiled infantile first-world millennials already think that's the very least they deserve in return for gracing the rest of us with their wonderous presence. Pray tell us, who's going to pay for this lovely new tax break of yours? 'Cos last time I checked money did not just fall out of heaven.

Now here's a counter-suggestion: Anyone who chooses not to vaccinate for any non-medical reason, which is their personal right, is required to pay a VPD Healthcare Tax in return. Those taxes go directly into a long-term fund which in turn is used to cover all costs to anyone else who is affected by a VPD, including time-off-work pay, acute hospitalization expenses, long-term disability care, and funeral costs.

People who vaccinate already pay their dues to our society by accepting the one-in-a-million risk of a serious reaction, which includes built-in compensation for those that do suffer genuine vaccine injury. So let's see the antivaxxers put their money where their big mouths are for once and pay their share too.

Furthermore, an antivax-tax has the added benefit of ultimately making anti-vax a self-limiting movement, because the more people they recruit through their lies and manipulation, the more frequent and serious VPD outbreaks become, and the more that tax has to be raised in order to cover the increased costs of their success. Let's see how loud they still are once taking personal responsibility for thousands of deaths and injuries a year.

They want it, they pay for it. I seem to recall that's how things used to work, back in the hard old days before this modern entitlement culture. So let's have more of that.

Am I the only one who thinks that the imagery of Nazis forcibly vaccinating children is actually making it look as a point in favor of Nazis rather than a one against vaccines?

I'm not sure I'd go that far, but I understand the sentiment. As Walter Sobchak said: "Say what you want about the tenets of National Socialism, Dude, at least it's an ethos."

By Eric Lund (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink

@Helianthus: There's also the yellow fever vaccine, compulsory for people who stay in French Guyane for 12 months or more. Damn mosquitoes.

By Irène Delse (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink

Fiona O'Leary has a petition up at changeDOTorg about Vaxxed addressed to the Attorney General of Texas.

This is very admirable but underscores (I think) what Brian Deer notes that the US pediatric primary care service does not do a good job at all communicating on vaccines--especially with respect to directly refuting anti-vaccinationist groups by name. I also agree with you, Brian, about advertising--go to the AAP web sites (AAP.org and healthchildren.org) and they are rife with drug company ads. This infuriates me because you would think this organization charges its 60,000 member pediatricians ~ $600 a year--which brings in 36 million a year in revenue. Bigtree and Tommey will play their cat and mouse game with us (and you can bet Wakefield is glad he gets to sit above it all like some sort of guru), but they wouldn't get to play cat and mouse like this if the bigger players in American healthcare called out these dangerous anti-vaccinationists (and anti-autists) for what they really are. By Chris Hickie (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink I’m afraid that’s an antivaccine talking point. Change the formulation and there’ll be less complaining. Experience doesn’t bear that out. Antivaxxers had a tantrum over a preservative, thimerosal. It was taken out. They still complained. Changing the formulation will not stop the complaining. Yep. Remove one "offensive" ingredient, and antivaxers will just move on to another. Del and Polly have, unbeknownst to them, become Wakefield's fall guys. They're the ones putting themselves out there and not knowing when they ought to just stop talking, thus drawing criticism to them. Meanwhile, as Dr. Hickie notes, Wakefield gets to sit back and not dirty his own hands at all. Polly and Del? You should probably just put the shovel down. To be fair [to both carers and carees], full-time carers really do need regular time-outs if they’re not to burn out themselves. I often wonder how much Cult of St Andrew recruitment is fed by disordered and delusional thinking triggered by prolonged high stress in turn caused by a lack of high quality state and/or private respite care, not to mention certain personality types’ inclination to make martyrs of themselves instead of ask for help while they can. Yes, all caregivers, be they caregivers for autistic or other special needs children, caregivers for elderly parents with dementia, or caregivers for anyone with a chronic condition, need a respite from time to time. I had no problem with Polly Tommey offering respite care to parents with autistic children, if she is in fact actually doing that (which I doubt). If that were all she were doing, it would be a valuable service. Unfortunately, she's also peddling antivaccine pseudoscience and quack "autism biomed" treatments. @has, my issue is not with Tommey's comments about giving support to caregivers, it's with the fact that she omitted the autistics from the equation. By Julian Frost (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink There are some other dangers in their rant against anti-anxiety and anti-depression treatments. First, their advice to just "work through" the anxiety/depression will more likely drive those who suffer into further anxiety/depression as the person tries and fails to work through it. Whatever they do doesn't work, which in turn causes more anxiety or depression. The other risk is not to the suffering individual themselves. As Orac notes, they may reach the point of killing themselves, but where they have a child with developmental delays or disabilities, they also may (and some have) kill the child. By urging their followers to forgo real treatment, they're setting up more and more situations where autistic children will be harmed. (But don't judge those parents. Nope. As Polly tells us, we can't judge them for doing something so unforgivable as hurting their own children.) Julian Frost "Respite homes for the parents of autistic children, but not the children themselves? If anyone wanted proof of just how they view autistics, that is solid." The "respite homes" idea was an outgrowth of their work with Alex Spordalakis. They basically promise to start this project in the faux documentary they made about him "who killed Alex Spourdalakis" Yes, the people who so failed Alex want to franchise their methods for other parents Boggles the mind. By Matt Carey (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Orac@21: I had no problem with Polly Tommey offering respite care to parents with autistic children, if she is in fact actually doing that (which I doubt). Oopsie! [blushes] Color me childishly naïve for living in a country where full-time carers are only abjectly neglected, not full-time preyed upon too, or I'd have caveated myself a lot sooner. But yeah, I have absolutely zero doubt that the Cult of St Andrew's own unique definition of "respite care" means anything but. Think more like a weekend's retreat at Jonestown, where you don't get out again until you've willingly purchased your lifetime's supply of Kool Aid in full. And if that sounds bad, just imagine what they're doing to the left-behind kids in the meantime – 'cos fuxxing Andrew Wakefield could openly bugger eight-year-old autistics upon the steps of Thoughtful House and his slime-filled psychophants would only declare it the greatest treatment since the Lupron Protocol. As a person on medication for anxiety, those comment make me angry. "Work through" my anxiety? How? I can't think my way through altering my genetics. Therapy helps teach coping skills, but it doesn't change that my body's "resting" state is much higher state of stress ana anxious arousal than the average person. But, it's consitent with their anti-vax, ant-autism views -- if you're not neuro-typical, there's some crazy alt. biomed method that will "fix" you. Is Thug Health really a 'movement'? I pegged it as one crank with an FB page, clearly doing 'thug' like white suburban teen rap fans do 'thug' – that is, not so much crackpot fantasies about a real armed resistance, but a form of figurative play-acting. I still have a t-shirt from a 90's computer show with this image: http://ep.yimg.com/ay/redlightrunner/publish-or-perish-lithograph-2.gif (CU cartoon image of a woman's face, smoking gun in her hand held high, American flag in the BG, caption "You can take my Mac when you pry my cold dead fingers off the mouse!") As Todd noted, the Thug Health author is just putting antivax smack-talk on stock photos of women-with-guns. Just a variation on the ubiquitous expression-by-hyerbolic/cheeky-photo-meme. And, well, the whole concept of Gun-Thug Health is such an obvious oxymoron, you'd only have to tweak one term in the slogans here or there to put these in The Onion... Yesterday, Orac asked: "How is Bigtree’s rhetoric any different from these memes?" It is different: i's an order of magnitude MORE extreme because it's not kitschy figurative theater. True, Del is 'acting', and spewing out hyperbole for show. But it's coded as 'real' (as opposed to the meme's use of obviously posed professional models on 'fashion' shoots.) He's talking, in person, to other people who can read his vocal tone and facial expressions, and he appears sincere, serious, emotionally invested, without any possibility of winking ironic distance. The low-fi Periscope video only adds to the gritty authenticity. This is Bigtree showing his Tabloid TV roots (as it were, sorry), by staging his own one man Nancy Grace / Geraldo conflict carnival. He's not just the pump-priming producer, but the prodding, provoking host and the enraged to extremism guest, all-in-one. While he (and us) probably takes it as 'just a show', his audience here isn't bored daytime TV viewers tuning in for vicarious pleasures of gawking at a freak show, but would be participants in the drama. We know that such folks can be riled into rash actions from the history of tabloid TV: vicious fights erupting on set; suicides and murders in the wake of tapings or airings. Honestly. I doubt anti-vaxers fit the profile for potential violence against others. Frankly, the notion that pharma employees in Santa Rosa County have to worry about gun-toting anti-vaxers strikes me as comedy. A cadre of warrior moms might kidnap a pharma guy and force feed him mass quantities of GMOs or something. But it's not West Virginia, and AVs aren't anywhere near the psychology of radical 'pro-lifers' who hunt down abortionists. Of course, "it only takes one", but I'd guess the odds of actual AV gun violence is down there with other terrorism as way WAY near the bottom of anyone's probable-harm totem pole. Which absolves Bigtree of nothing. He's still inciting violence, being utterly irresponsible, courting danger. Even if no one follows through with an attack, that's still not at all OK. More importantly, I think we'll miss the more significant danger of this rhetoric if we take it too literally. It IS metaphor in the end, and the audience is likely to act metaphorically, even if processing it literally cognitively. Sort of, "Well, I won't pick up a gun and shoot someone, but I'll do _____ instead." Which is to say, the AV true-believers already think of themselves as warriors, and Bigtree's stoking them to harden that stance. It doesn't have to mean literal war to be trouble. If any AVs take to his message for more than one night of fever dreams, they'll likely just give us more and more aggressive acts of 'war' of the sort they already do. Words mostly... Words may not hurt flesh and bone, but there are more to people than their bodies, and word-harm can be grievous in it's own way. What concerns me the most is that Del's gun talk will harden the negative attitudes some parents have regarding autism. We won't get an AV version of Shelley Shannon, but we'll wind up with more Polly Tommeys. That's more than bad enough. has@14: Why? You don’t think protecting your own and others’ kids against crippling diseases is reward enough? Hell, why not ask for a pony and a blowjob while you’re at it? Spoiled infantile first-world millennials already think that’s the very least they deserve in return for gracing the rest of us with their wonderous presence. Pray tell us, who’s going to pay for this lovely new tax break of yours? ‘Cos last time I checked money did not just fall out of heaven. I fail to see why you had to drag millennials into this. Anyway, Fendlesworth brings up a good point. Not with tax breaks specifically, but if insurance companies don't offer incentives for the coverage of fully vaccinated children, they ought to. I'm pretty sure my employer's medical plan covers the costs of vaccinations 100% (no copay or deductible), and that's the least they should be doing. Am I the only one who thinks that the imagery of Nazis forcibly vaccinating children is actually making it look as a point in favor of Nazis. Probably not. Which is too bad. Vaccination and Nazi Germany have no relevance to each other, either way. There was nothing unique in 'The Nazis supported vaccination!' It would have been remarkable for any industrialized country NOT to. The Nazis also supported all manner of routine policies for modern nations. "You know who also supported the government picking up garbage! The NAZIS!!" Vaccination isn't even on the Nazis very short list of arguably 'positive' innovations: freeways; affordable/economical/reliable small cars; banning tobacco advertising and smoking in restaurants; protecting endangered species... Is Thug Health really a ‘movement’? I pegged it as one crank with an FB page It is that, too. It was just convenient as a source of images. I included a couple images from other sources in my first post on this topic: http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2015/12/03/the-violent-rhetoric-of-th… Of course, the violent rhetoric goes beyond guns. For example, antivaccine activists like to compare school vaccine mandates to rape: https://publichealthwatch.wordpress.com/2015/04/26/a-new-low-anti-vacci… http://scienceblogs.com/insolence/2014/09/30/anti-vaccine-not-pro-safe-… I wonder if Tommey would get it if her statement was changed to refer to another group of people who may be difficult to care for. 'Children are taking the lives of their parents with dementia already because they won’t leave their parent in the world as it is today, and I for one will never judge them for what they did.' Her audience might be less willing to let that pass without protest. By Verna Lang (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Helianthus @ 12 - Does France permit homeschooling? By shay simmons (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Verna@31: Of course the audience would push back against it. After all, even bad men love their mamas (warning: TVTropes link). But the rhetoric we hear from certain anti-vaxers as well as the autism woo crowd suggest that many in those groups don't consider people on the autism spectrum--including their own children!--to be fully human. By Eric Lund (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Probably not. Which is too bad. Vaccination and Nazi Germany have no relevance to each other, either way. There was nothing unique in ‘The Nazis supported vaccination!’ It would have been remarkable for any industrialized country NOT to. The Nazis also supported all manner of routine policies for modern nations. Actually, if you want an area where Nazi Germany was ahead of its time, it was in cancer research and control. The Nazis were the first to link smoking with lung cancer, finding the epidemiological link well over a decade before the British reported it, and they acted on that knowledge, setting up all sorts of cancer prevention programs and smoking cessation programs. Robert Proctor's The Nazi War on Cancer was an illuminating read for me. They talk about a tour aboard a bus ( probably shrink wrap 'painted' with VAXXED! logos and images) HOWEVER I looked over the VAXXED! website and it seems that some theatrical runs have been cancelled or postponed. ( I seem to recall reading that Bigtree had a personal axe to grind against vaccines: can anyone fill me in?) By Denice Walter (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Eric, The good old unter mensch ploy. It is so much easier to perform vile acts against unter mensch than to an actual person. @sturartg Which country has “vaccines mandated for everyone”? Certainly not USA, Canada, UK, Australia, Germany, New Zealand, Japan I was talking about the USA. Did I use the term to loosely? http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-33333788 I am not a lawyer, but I do read newspapers. By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink @ Guy Chapman: I also like *schlockumentary*. By Denice Walter (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Apologies for the OT, but I'm not sure which thread to put this in, and it's a news item likely to be of some interest to Orac and/or his regular readers. Among the scheduled speakers at the Republican National Convention tonight (20 July) is allegedly successful small businesswoman Michelle Van Etten. Talking Points Memo has some background on Ms. Van Etten: The RNC schedule doesn't name Van Ettern's business, but she is an independent contract employee with Youngevity, a company that sells thousands of products that claim to boost overall health and wellbeing. The company also makes far more dubious claims, like that its products combat cancer, rebuild bone mass and help with weight loss. On Youngevity’s website, Van Etten is listed as a “senior vice chairman marketing director," a position also promoted on her Facebook page. Apparently Alex Jones (yes, that Alex Jones) is a fan, and Britt Hermes is a critic. I'm mildly curious how a "senior vice chairman marketing director" could be an "independent contract employee". Since the company in question is a multi-level marketing scheme, I suspect there's some fraud going on (Ms. Hermes says it appears to be a pyramid scam). By Eric Lund (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink @ Eric Lund: Are cranks selling outrageously over-priced woo whilst courting conservative voters ( or anyone else for that matter) ever TRULY OT @ RI? By Denice Walter (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink @Julain Frost Changing the formulation will not stop the complaining. It would certainly stop some, but not all, people from complaining. Here is an article from my favourite journal on the topic of adjuvants. http://www.nature.com/icb/journal/v82/n5/full/icb200475a.html Does anyone know why aluminium salts are the most commonly used adjuvant? By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink I agree that changing ingredients would not change anything. Instead just like with thimerosal they would say that they were right about aluminum salts and if they were dangerous and used for so long why would they trust vaccines now. Removing thimerosal actually made things worse. Another problem is that removing thimerosal did not change the actual formulations of vaccines so they did not have to go through new testing. New adjuvants would mean at least a decade of testing. Although there is nothing wrong with looking at new ones. Pharmaceutical companies have a good reason not to though. By Sullivanthepoop (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink I agree that changing ingredients would not change anything. Instead just like with thimerosal.... Indeed, the Dachelbot is now carping about increasing autism diagnoses in California, despite the facts that they were the first state to legislate on the subject and that Jake had invoked California to claim that he had "won" some sort of bet-like proposition over our host. (Not to mention Blaxill's older comment that I'm too weak to look up at the moment.) @Fendlesworth: the vaccines aren't mandatory. What is being required is that you get the vaccines IF you wish to attend the public schools. You may still have medical exemptions, you may homeschool or send to a private institution that does not have a vaccine requirement. A fraudumentary producer named Del urged violence in a bid to compel, ...But with nazi tropes galore ...that his audience could only abhor, His AV cohort gained entry to hell. @Fendlesworth: the vaccines aren’t mandatory. I took the original comment, viz., "I didn’t find that quote very applicable since vaccines are mandated for everyone, not for specific minorities," in the sense that the relevant laws are of general applicability. This is why the reverse proposition – being in a "recognized" church for an exemption – doesn't work, either. I wasn't being very careful with my language apparently. I think it is safe to say that most public schools have vaccine requirements (with exemptions); and that most children attend public schools. New adjuvants would mean at least a decade of testing Would the substitution of CaOH for AlOH as an adjuvant require further testing? CaOH is GRAS by the FDA. By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Helianthus, Irene Delete, Many thanks. I have to admit surprise. Are any other childhood vaccines mandatory (apart from medical exclusions) in those countries? (Irene, sorry about your name, there's a limited keyboard on this tablet) @ Stuartg We have a number of recommended vaccines (almost as many as in the US), but no compulsory vaccines other than the D, T and Polio. Plus yellow fever in Guyane, As Irène pointed out. Health professionals may have the HepB vaccine mandatory, but I'm not sure how much it's enforced. It was very strongly recommended for students scheduled to work on human blood when I started university in the 90's. By Helianthus (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Fendlesworth @5: LPS would not be my first choice of adjuvant. I've used it in the lab and it works incredibly well, if you're not the mouse. If you're the mouse it sucks. Separately, not all adjuvants will work with all vaccines. Some Toll-like receptor based adjuvants actually block the action of DNA vaccines. (I wish someone had told me that *before* I spent 6 months on that project.) By JustaTech (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink CaOH is GRAS by the FDA. "GRAS" applies to food, not biologics. Polly is looking for someone to blame - there is autism in her family and she desperately wants a culprit... sadly she is condemning children to suffer for her selfish needs "if their children aren't autistic I will ensure they have other potentially devastating diseases." or am I being too kind to the woman? As can be said about AlOH injections in rats The addition of Shaw and the Journal of Inorganic Biochemistry on top of the "GRAS" trope is not promising. In the past, I've looked quite a bit for info on aluminum adjuvants, and found remarkably little that reveals anything instructive. Pretty much everything just hand waves along the lines of "provokes better response". Many aluminum compounds, including aluminum hydroxide, have very low solubility in water (freshly made aluminum hydroxide is a floc). Some aluminum compounds (notably oxide, see "activated alumina", - not sure about hydroxide) are quite powerful adsorbers. My suspicion is that aluminum adjuvants adsorb antigens on the surface of microscopic insoluble particles, causing both to remain at the injection site for much longer than antigens alone would, thereby prolonging the time that the antigens can provoke specific immune response. Again, this is my suspicion, not anything for which I can cite specific support. @ shay simmons Does France permit homeschooling? I was thinking not, but it turns that, yes, this is possible. About 25,000 children out of 12 millions, in 2014, apparently, according to this article in Le Monde (in French, sorry) Schooling is mandatory in my country (since 1882), but there are private schools for those wishing a better/different education for their children, and their entry requirements may be different from public schools (maybe not openly, like the Waldorf schools in Québec, which were exposed as antivvax, after the Disney measles outbreak went all the way due North). I think the French mandatory vaccination is not linked to school attendance. For practical reasons, and because the French state is big on centralization, there is a medical visit each year at public schools for each children, during which the vaccination status is controlled (at my time, we also had the anti-tuberculosis BCG as a mandatory vaccination - lovely memories, my inoculations never showed the proper red welt). But even if French parents homeschool or send their children to a private school, I think they are expected to vaccinate their children. There have been a few parents on trial for being vaccine refusers, in the recent years. The charges were akin to failing to provide proper care. By Helianthus (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink GRAS or generally recognized as safe is not determined by FDA but by the user. This has come under fire and is FDA slowly changing how GRAS is determined and how it is defined. ^ Yup, it's Gulf War–anthrax–squalene bingo (see reference 8). GRAS or generally recognized as safe is not determined by FDA but by the user. That depends on which bit of the CFR one is looking at. In any event, it still doesn't apply to biologics. Ah. So Bigtree wasn't asking gun owners to rise up against the government when he asked them why they didn't do just that. He was pandering to them in hopes of acquiring support from a group whose cause he really doesn't give the slightest damn about, because only his cause is actually important. Which of course means he only cares what they can do for him, not what they can do together, which of course is completely consistent with his opinion on vaccines. Well, I do believe one thing he said, and that's that he shoots from the hip. He obviously puts absolutely no thought whatsoever into what he says, since what he's said here is frankly insulting to Second Amendment afficianados. As for Tommey -- well. Her message is much more consistent. "Poor me." It's so hard and terrible to be the mother of an autistic child. So hard she has to find someone to blame for it, even as she refuses effective treatments and leaves her child vulnerable to disease, becuase the only jackbooted thug allowed around her kid is obviously herself -- the child has no rights in her mind, and is at this point little more than a prop. As far as working through anxiety, I wonder if they've ever told their children to just "walk it off" after getting a blow to the head or twisting a joint? Working through it only works to a point. And you'd really think Tommey would know that, seeing as how she has such a horrible burden in caring for an autistic child.... Becuase really, which is it? That you can just work through psychiatric disorders, or that they can be legitimately crippling? I don't think she can decide that, though. Not without first acknowledinge her son's humanity. And of course the ultimate expression of that is in how she refuses to condemn the murder of autistic children. If she saw them as people, she'd condemn it. But she doesn't. I don't think she even sees the murderers as people. Like her own son, they are merely props that she can hold up to say "look how awful autism is! look what it drove these people to!" By Calli Arcale (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Narad, I should have said in the food products world. I should have been more precise. It is troubling when the maker decides what is safe. Of course isn't that what the naturopathic, homeopathic and supplement industries do? @ Denice I also like *schlockumentary*. OT There is a webcomic called Schlock Mercenary, and I am a fan. The epoymous character is a carbosilicate amorph alien creature. The "amorph" part should tell you what he looks like. I have a bit of cognitive dissonance right now. For the fan, a schlockumentary sounds awesome. OTOH, thanks to reading this webcomic, I have a very precise idea of what "schlock" looks like... (for those curious about the webcomic - imagine Star Trek, but with a bunch of greedy ditzy mercs instead of explorers; start with books 10 or 11, or later, and beware archive binges; the author, Howard Tayler, is very prolific) By Helianthus (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink I should have said in the food products world. Right, right, and I don't know bupkis about how this works in the real world of the food industry, but what I was pointing to is that GRAS is often deployed (along with "proprietary formulations") to state that vaccine labeling allows secret additions. You know, like peanut oil (which is really ground zero of this particular clusterfυck). Helianthus @62: I LOVE Schlock Mercenary! I've been reading it for ... wow, 15 years. So yeah, major archive binges possible. By JustaTech (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink @Doug Some aluminum compounds (notably oxide, see “activated alumina”, – not sure about hydroxide) are quite powerful adsorbers. My suspicion is that aluminum adjuvants adsorb antigens on the surface of microscopic insoluble particles Yes, think I you are correct If you analyze the word "adjuvant", you you realize that it simply means "accompanying" or "concomitant" and does not necessarily mean that it is immunostimulatory in itself. Here is an ariticle of CaPO4 vs Alum as as adjuvant. In Europe, CaPO4 is used in diptheria and tenatus vaccines. By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Apparently, the antigens are mixed with NaPO4 and CaCl and the pH raised to 7 to form a CaPO4 precipitate in which the antigens are embedded in the matrix. This makes for a slow-release antigen depot. By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Sadmar@27, Ever heard of John Best? Al To expand more on "Sir" Best, He drank the psilocybin enriched battery acid version of the kool-aid and IIRC, I think I remember him being banned from AoA, not sure (as in flipping a coin probability wise). Usually hang on Master Crosby's blog. Google John Best hating autism for hours of entertainment... Fendlesworth, the whole hand wringing that Wakefield and Bigtree's "documentary" is about the present MMR vaccine. Do us a favor and tell us what adjuvant is used in that vaccine. Alain: No. And the words 'John' and 'Best' are too common for Google to clue me in w/o more info. Can I get a hint? :-) First, _they_ came to arrest and try idiots who allowed their child to die a painful death while they fiddled with imaginary cures, and I said nothing - because as bad as child murderers are, a fair trial is still deserved. Then _they_ came to tell me that Andrew Wakefield's followers are a cult, and I carefully investigated, and found, hilariously, that the dupes do call their corrupt guru a figure comparable to Nelson Mandela and Jesus Christ. Then, I watched _them_ come to criticize people who can't bear to bring themselves to criticize parents who directly murder their children, and I did nothing - because no one has the right to be free from criticism. Then, I watched as _they_ dared to investigate cancer quacks, and I did nothing, because I like having a free society where anyone who has the time and talent can expose a crook, even if they are a teenager, or a woman. Finally, I decided that _they_ weren't doing such a bad job after all, and I'd be better off worrying about their opponents - the anti-children activities who wish to kill for their right to give diseases to children, and who fantasize about show trials for teenagers who dare tell the truth - because that seems like a better use for my limited time. Keep up the good work, saving lives and promoting truth, Orac - the more your opponents squeal in outrage, the more you know you've hit your mark. Hard as it is to believe, John Best used to comment here way back in the day, c.2005. @Chris Do us a favor and tell us what adjuvant is used in that vaccine. The MMR appears to be adjuvant free, according to the usual definition of "adjuvant". By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Thank you. In the past, I’ve looked quite a bit for info on aluminum adjuvants, and found remarkably little that reveals anything instructive. You might want to review Krebiozen's comments on the subject. JF:my issue is not with Tommey’s comments about giving support to caregivers, it’s with the fact that she omitted the autistics from the equation. I don't think we want Tomney taking care of autistic kids, or vetting professional caregivers. She'd make Kevorkian look humane. Heck, I'm still puzzled as to why her son is still in her custody, given that she doesn't seem to do much (if any) caregiving, her husband seems to be a non-entity and the fact that she's persistently publicly demonstrating her stupidity and lack of judgement. By Politcalguineapig (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink This makes for a slow-release antigen depot. BTW, my patience is wearing thin, given all the stalely conjured yet new pseudonyms floating around lately. Cough up the kinetics or stuff it. "Usual definition of 'adjuvant'," my ass. @ Fendlesworth Aluminium adjuvants are known to induce by themselves pro-inflamatory cytokines, which are required for good antibody responses. By Daniel Corcos (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Speaking of Krebiozen, the last time he commented here was February 28. Does anyone have any information about him? I'm getting really worried. I miss his incisive, knowledgeable commentary. By Julian Frost (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink Thomas (#73) Indeed.... First Andy Wakefield idolized murder-suicide, and I watched them applaud and say "he was a symbol of the fight for the best lives possible for their kids". Then they came for their children, with poison and knives, smothering bags and terrible falls, And I watched Polly Tommey do nothing. Andy do nothing. Them, do nothing. Then they came for the move Vaxxed, And I watched Del Bigtree urge them to pick up guns. With apologies to Mr. Niemöller. Seems like I can't even type my name right today... (previous comment in moderation, thanks to my new sockpuppet friend "gait"). Thomas (#73) Indeed…. First Andy Wakefield idolized murder-suicide, and I watched them applaud and say “he was a symbol of the fight for the best lives possible for their kids”. Then they came for their children, with poison and knives, smothering bags and terrible falls, And I watched Polly Tommey do nothing. Andy do nothing. Them, do nothing. Then they came for the move Vaxxed, And I watched Del Bigtree urge them to pick up guns. With apologies to Mr. Niemöller. With apologies to Mr. Niemöller. You took the extra time to install an umlaut. You must really mean that. By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 20 Jul 2016 #permalink The violent rhetoric could backfire on them, especially as they are changing their story continually... Please correct me if I'm wrong, but as I see it: first it was MMR, then Mercury, then Aluminium, then too many too soon; all causing Autism. Now it's gently moving to genetic susceptibility, activation and "Autism like" symptoms or lately just ""Autism"". It's almost like they are aware that Autism starts in the womb and are delicately altering their story to match. I reckon their fear is that some of the parents who were with them on the "giving my son a vaccine gave him Autism" ride, will react violently to too greater deviation from that. Being that they are based in Texas, that could involve guns or maybe even tar and feathers lol. @Jay, if anything, you skipped a few things, like the Measles part of the MMR. But yes, what they say they believe is the reason why vaccines cause autism keeps changing. It’s almost like they are aware that Autism starts in the womb and are delicately altering their story to match. I agree. I think that deep down they do realise the truth but their antivaccine beliefs are just too ingrained. It's cognitive dissonance through and through. By Julian Frost (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink With apologies to Mr. Niemöller. You took the extra time to install an umlaut. You must really mean that. Oh snap! I knew I forgot something! Why oh why do I keep pronouncing names correctly, online and off. Why! Oh the humanity! And in more serious news, Fendlesworth will now explain to the class how "I for one will never judge them, for [killing their own child]" relates to "and I did not speak out of pastor F. G. E. M. Niemöller's famous poem. Also, if it takes that much effort for you to type an umlaut, there are better keyboards available. In mine, it takes as much effort as typing a single capital letter. Ummmmm....gaist: I don't know how to do an umlaut on my keyboard, though I assume it's a group of keystrokes. I actually thought Fendlesworth was complimenting you for including it. I usually do it through HTML entities, although I'm not sure if it works here: ö Å etc. By Rebecca Fisher (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink Thanks, Rebecca. Bookmarked for future use! @Julian, cheers mate, I think I missed "leaky gut syndrome" as well. Worth a read regarding the anti vax change of tone: "You don’t have bad genes" by Quackenboss. It blames everything bad on Epigenetics and environmental toxins, including of course vaccines. Don't think Wakefield would be too happy, about her deviation from the script. Check this: "Why is the autism rate in military families double of the rest of us? It’s the over-vaccinated dads." It couldn't possibly be the lead, or any of the umpty-dozen things people get exposed to in war zones..*eye roll* Also I'd need statistics on that, as Quakenboss is not a reliable source on anything. By Politicalguineapig (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink Wait. No one quoted the Princess Bride? Come on Orac minions. They keep using that word Nazis. I don't think it means what they think it means. There are probably better ones. By Skeptical Raptor (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink @Daniell Aluminium adjuvants are known to induce by themselves pro-inflamatory cytokines, which are required for good antibody responses. True. But there are adjuvants that do the the same thing without aluminium. So far I have yet to find a good explanation why aluminum phosphate is used instead of calcium phosphate. By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink @Gayst Also, if it takes that much effort for you to type an umlaut, there are better keyboards available. In mine, it takes as much effort as typing a single capital letter. Did I quantify how much effort it takes me to type an umläut? I just had never seen anyone make the effort on a blog before. That is great that you have a special keyboardm now you can talk to your nazi friends without offending them. You have just exposed yourself. By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink Well, Fendlesworth, I guess gaist was right and I was wrong. Many people on this blog try to use correct spellings and punctuation, including foreign letters as applicable. There was no need to call gaist a nazi sympathizer. I thought you might be OK. Instead, you are a creep. Also, was the misspelling of gaist on purpose because you are also a homophobe? @Politicalguineapig There's every chance that she just made it up. @MI Dawn ..was the misspelling of gayst on purpose...[?]" If you look again, you will find that I had spelled it correctly. By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink @ Fendlesworth Maybe hydroxyapatite particles bind to another NOD-like receptor. By Daniel Corcos (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink Umlauts indeed involve a huge degree of difficulty. Here, by extreme effort is...Motörhead! And all I did was cut and paste. For my encore, here are Blue Öyster Cult, Queensrÿche, The Accüsed, Mötley Crüe and (drumroll) Spın̈al Tap. By Dangerous Bacon (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink @helianthus - s'ok. Je lis francais. By shay simmons (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink "They keep using that word plagiarism. I don’t think it means what they think." –– Melania Trump Smiling at the mentions of the Crüe and Motörhead on RI. Didn't the 'autism epidemic' begin around the time Heavy Metals began to proliferate? I do beieve the drumroll for the Tap needs to end with a sound effect appropriate to spontaneous combustion, though. 'Pöüfff!' Fendlesworth: So correctly spelling the name of an anti-Nazi writer makes some one a Nazi. Interesting. Or was it that someone spelling any word correctly made you feel stupid, so you used the word antivaxxers always use when they feel stupid? Jay: See 'not a reliable source on anything'. :p I do kinda wonder if people who experience or are around combat (like civilians stuck in a warzone) subsequently give birth to or father a higher rate of autistic children than the general population. Although, to me, it's kind of odd that the Somali population in my area seems to have a higher rate of autism than the Hmong or Karen population. By Politicalguineapig (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink @Thomas No Thomas. The umlaut thing started started out as a compliment, and I got sh¡t thrown at me for it and it hasn't stopped since. I am not an anti-inoculation, I am anti-aluminum. By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink @ Fendlesworth If you look again, you will find that I had spelled it correctly. I believe MI Dawn and Thomas were talking about #98. By Helianthus (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink Well Fendlesworth @110, you'd best hope on the next rocket out of here, 'cause the whole freaking planet is made of aluminum. PGP@109: There's been a bunch of research on prenatal famine exposure and late-in-life adverse outcomes (obesity, CVD) in Eurpoeans after WWII, and some on poor paternal nutrition and congenital abnormalities in mice, so it is possible that there could be some impact. Possibly even through nutrition. But it would be hard to separate out the biological from the pyscho-social impacts of war on people and their parenting style. By JustaTech (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink JustaTech, Fendlesworth will have to be careful on what rocket fuel he uses. There is one that literally burns aluminum. I really tire of the Aluminati like Fendlesworth who try to hijack a thread with fear of the most abundant metal element on the crust of this planet. He did not even get the hint of why I asked him about the MMR vaccine. See Figure 1 and Table 1 .... You should probably lower his/her dosage. Yup, I just plain misread the comment. Sorry about that. @Chris of the most abundant metal element on the crust of this planet. Going for the Naturalistic Fallacy Chris? Aluminium's abundance does absolutely nothing to mitigate it's toxicity. By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink Aluminium’s abundance does absolutely nothing to mitigate it’s toxicity. This one I did not misread, however. Aluminum toxicity is well known from exposure to parenteral nutrition. (These are the kinetics I was thinking of.) The abundance of the element has everything to do with normal serum levels. Oh, no! It is the Aluminati! Fostering fear and loathing for absolutely no reason! Oh, no! It is the Aluminati! Fostering fear and loathing for absolutely no reason! I really should have just deployed the killfile immediately. Yep. There truly is no reasoning with the Aluminati. Not one of them have told me where they get aluminum free soil to grow their veggies. Justatech: There’s been a bunch of research on prenatal famine exposure and late-in-life adverse outcomes (obesity, CVD) in Eurpoeans after WWII, and some on poor paternal nutrition and congenital abnormalities in mice, so it is possible that there could be some impact. Possibly even through nutrition. But it would be hard to separate out the biological from the pyscho-social impacts of war on people and their parenting style. I think I've actually heard of that study, somewhere. But it still seems kinda odd that one group of refugees seems to produce more autistic children. Admittedly, the circumstances are different for each group, and the Hmong aren't fleeing an active war zone. (Dunno about the Karen, but I don't think it's quite a shooting war in Myanmar yet.) It's possible that the Somalis were exposed to something the other two groups weren't, and it's very possible that some cultural mores (like eye-contact being considered rude among Asian cultures) might be making practitioners unable to distinguish an autistic child from a n.t. child, if the child exhibits no other symptoms of autism. By Politicalguineapig (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink Particularly irritating is Tommey and Bigtree’s rants about anxiety, how you have to “work through” your anxiety, and how you shouldn’t be “drugged” for it. I know people with anxiety. For clinical anxiety, you can’t just “work through it.” People with anxiety seeking medication have already tried to “work through it.” They can’t. That’s the problem. Medications are a last resort, not a first resort. They both recommend finding a “wholistic” doctor for anxiety and depression. Such advice will lead to someone who might have been saved killing himself. It would have been Robin Williams' 65th birthday yesterday. By Julian Frost (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink @Chris, It's the other way around. ALCOA is the Aluminati and I don't work for them. By Fendlesworth (not verified) on 21 Jul 2016 #permalink Didn’t the ‘autism epidemic’ begin around the time Heavy Metals began to proliferate? I for one regret the absence of rock styles with names like "light metalloid" or "alkaline earth metal". By herr doktor bimler (not verified) on 22 Jul 2016 #permalink This may help Mr./Ms. F with some of the questions they have. Although I'm sure they'll come up with some reason as to why the information there is wrong or why there is still cause for fear, uncertainty, and doubt. To add to what JustaTech wrote: Schizophrenia has also been associated with prenatal exposure to famine, war, etc. ( schizophrenia.com/ causes) By Denice Walter (not verified) on 22 Jul 2016 #permalink Good article, Todd. By squirrelelite (not verified) on 22 Jul 2016 #permalink ♬[Trumpets]♬ @article , like Adderall, which they seem to view as the height of evil. Well, they obviously have never freebased Adderall. By Lord Windemere (not verified) on 22 Jul 2016 #permalink Ahh, yah. No. 1: Fendlesworth July 22, 2016 @Chris, It’s the other way around. ALCOA is the Aluminati and I don’t work for them. No. 2: Lord Windemere July 22, 2016 ♬[Trumpets]♬ @article , like Adderall, which they seem to view as the height of evil. Well, they obviously have never freebased Adderall. Bugger off, Gilberttimmitzeh. Fendlesworth July 21, 2016 @Thomas No Thomas. The umlaut thing started started out as a compliment, and I got sh¡t thrown at me for it and it hasn’t stopped since. Can you link to the comment which "didn't stop" throwing "sh¡t", as you so succinctly put it. You know, between me snapping at you at #89 and you calling my friends nazis in #98. If you look again, you will find that I had spelled it correctly. I think your spelling for "most jolly" was missing an e. :) Yeah, noticed it after clicking submit. If it weren't for psychiatric meds I'd be dead. If it weren't for ADHD meds, I'd be homeless. So often, being able to live a normal life is taken for granted. By Darthhellokitty (not verified) on 23 Jul 2016 #permalink Picking up a couple of stray points: Umlauts are easy. You need to get the freeware called GermanAssistant from Visual Fantasy. It puts a little bar at the top of the screen. Clicking on a letter puts it on your clipboard so it can be pasted in any text box or document. They also have FrenchAssistant. I have emailed them asking for them to do Spanish and Scandinavian ones, but no joy so far. The classic natural experiment on effects of malnutrition on children was the Hunger Winter of 1944-45. About half of Holland had been liberated by the Allies, while the rest stayed under tight Nazi control and had the bulk of their food supplies "requisitioned" (read "stolen"). After the war it became the subject of a longitudinal study. Darthhellokitty, I have to second you. I am medicated for anxiety, cyclothymia, and ADHD, all on top of Asperger's Syndrome. I came within an ace of winding up living in a furnished room on public assistance. I don't live a normal life, Some days it takes all I've got just to appear to be whatever normal seems to be. I have no idea what "normal" feels like, but it's got to be better than what I feel like every day. By Old Rockin' Dave (not verified) on 24 Jul 2016 #permalink I just realized that Rebecca Robbins reported on the premiere for STAT way back in April: Producer Bigtree told STAT in an interview following the screening that the film is not anti-vaccine. He said the filmmakers simply oppose the widely administered combination vaccine against measles, mumps, and rubella (known as MMR). They advocate for separate vaccines against each disease. “We don’t want to see measles not vaccinated,” Bigtree said. “I don’t think that’s an anti-vaccine message, I’d say that’s a very pro-vaccine message.” I am a fan of the heavy metal umlaut. By M̈ep̈ḧis̈top̈ḧ… (not verified) on 24 Jul 2016 #permalink I am a fan of the heavy metal umlaut. Just separating 'p' and 'h' puts you in the land of the dieresis. Just separating ‘p’ and ‘h’ puts you in the land of the dieresis. My bathroom issues are not germane to this conversation. By M̈ep̈ḧis̈top̈ḧ… (not verified) on 24 Jul 2016 #permalink M̈ep̈ḧis̈top̈ḧeles̈ O'B̈rien̈ I thought you'd broken out with measles. Prove measles is caused by a virus and I will give you €100K. Shouldn't "violent rhetoric that could incite acts of violence" be absolutely illegal in the United States? WTF is AlOH? Just in case anyone thinks that Fendlesworth’s attempt to use chemical formulas instead of names (or even the abbreviations used by the authors of linked articles, some of which include correct formulas) indicates actual knowledge: the only chemical formula Fendlesworth has typed correctly is NaCl, and that’s only because table salt has a 1:1 ratio of the two ionized elements. It’s driving me nuts - see the first four letters of my screen name. Even if you can’t figure out the html correctly for subscripts (and I’ll admit I haven’t tried), how hard is it to type out Al(OH)3? I'll try to make a subscript work here. Al(OH)₃ Even if you can’t figure out the html correctly for subscripts (and I’ll admit I haven’t tried) The thing is that Wordpress does indeed support <sub>, but it's just not switched on here. Those Unicode glyphs are freaking ghastly &nash; 0, 1, and 2 are different from the rest, and the minus is practically unreadable. Hell, WP even supports LaTeX after a fashion, which I discovered at Jason Rosenhouse's joint. It's now working at Ethan's, as well, but I don't know whether that's because I asked or because of a global change. Let's see:$latex x_2$. Oh, kewl. It figures the baseline incorrectly, as can be seen. I guess the obvious question is then if that works now, whether HTML sup and sub do: x2. Nope. Go figure. Pheobe C @142 Please share. OK, last one, trying to use a box lowered by 2 points: Al(OH)$latex \raisebox{-2pt}{{}_3}$. @Lanka - what level of proof will you accept? Is the CDC or WHO sufficient authority, or do you demand original research? By Mephistopheles… (not verified) on 24 Jul 2016 #permalink WTF is AlOH? Silly-speak for alumanol? alumyl alcohol? I am, of course, also mocking reference to ethanol as E-T-O-H. Someone please tell me real MDs don't call it that - lie, if necessary. @Lanka – what level of proof will you accept? Did you fail to note the suddenness of Lanka's appearance after the nuking of Fendlesworth/Sir Windemere? WTF is AlOH? I think that "hydroxide" [OH⁻] is used for ionic bonds, and the "-ol" suffix for molecular bonds. IUPAC nomenclature has different rules for molecular and ionic moieties. I have seen etOH in print, but it is important to put the "et" in lowercase to avoid confusion. Did you fail to note the suddenness of Lanka’s appearance after the nuking of Fendlesworth/Sir Windemere? I think if it was the same person, he would have come back styled as "His Royal Highness Earl of Newcastle Sir Everett Watts PhD". Or something of that sort. I think that “hydroxide” [OH⁻] I told you that superscript minus is unreadable. There's limited help from <code>: [OH⁻], but it falls apart fast if combined. One more LaTeX try, without the 's' flag: OH$latex {}^-$. ^ Oh, that was freaking dandy. Maybe OH$latex \rule{0pt}{2ex}^-$. OK, I will try a crude \overset: OH$latex \overset{-}{\,}$. Melissa: Shouldn’t “violent rhetoric that could incite acts of violence” be absolutely illegal in the United States? It should. But then we wouldn't be able to have political conventions.Or elections. ORD: I have no idea what “normal” feels like, but it’s got to be better than what I feel like every day. Yup. Been there. Darthhellokitty: Do you live in the states? If so, how do you get insurance to pay for the meds? I've been on and off ADD meds and SSRIs. but I haven't taken a pill since I graduated from college. And I'm thinking that maybe I should go back on the ADD meds at least, since the Stratera sort-of worked, and sort-of worked is the best I can hope for.' The SSRis didn't work at all, and I'm sort of hoping I can meet someone who will kill me, since suicide isn't an option. But I''m not sure if insurance will cover meds, and I'm actually scared of using it. (As in, almost didn't get stitches scared of it. Did I mention I lacerated my thumb recently? Unintentionally.) By Politicalguineapig (not verified) on 24 Jul 2016 #permalink Next, \bar: OH$latex \bar{\ }\$.

? = 卍

@doug: sorry to burst your bubble, but most medical clinicians do use "ETOH" as an abbreviation for alcohol when writing note. "ETOH denied", "ETOH - socially" are very common.

@ Mephistopheles O'Brien 150 / Narad 152

Our multi-personality friend was being facetious. Or whoring for attention.

Lanka is the name of a German "virus skeptic" who, in 2011, made a public bet of being proven wrong about his beliefs that the measles virus doesn't exist and was condemned in spring 2015 to pay it to a doctor who sent him appropriate articles and pictures.

(so, a biologist failing virology 101, and a sore loser)

By Helianthus (not verified) on 25 Jul 2016 #permalink

Yes. Lanka had a dose of GNM®. You can hear him talking about it in an interview.

Everyone knows the poliovirus doesn't exist, but measles? Come one. Measles comes in clusters and is infections.

Measles is the model virus. How the hell can a Doctor of Virology question measles?

Has anyone actually heard Lanka's anti-measles arguments?

@ Dawn but most medical clinicians do use “ETOH” as an abbreviation for alcohol

That may me so, but would be inappropriate. It is imperative to leave the letter "T" lowercase as in EtOH or etOH.

Another good way is C₂H₅OH. This leaves the functional group intact at the expense of listing H twice, but I think that is better than writing C₂H₆O.

The best is to write it this way: 🍸.

But anything is better than the prolix and archaic "ethyl alcohol".

PGP @158: In the US the law (pre ACA, I think) says insurance has to cover mental health to the same level that it covers physical health. So you meds should be covered (mine are).

Your insurance might insist on the cheapest generic, but if you have prescription coverage (and doctor coverage) then it should be covered just like antibiotics or heart meds.
Good luck!

By JustaTech (not verified) on 25 Jul 2016 #permalink

Well, we'll see. I don't really have a regular doctor, and the insurance situation, is like I said, precarious. And after my last few go-rounds with SSRIs, I'm not eager to go that route again. The side-effects are worse than the depression. The Strattera might be worth exploring. Alternatively, I could up my caffeine consumption but I'm not sure how I could do that safely.

By Politicalguineapig (not verified) on 25 Jul 2016 #permalink

Also, I'm not really sure that the ACA will survive beyond next January, so that's a factor too. If I go easy on the insurance, maybe no one will notice and I'll get to keep it. I also already used it once this year- I'm pretty sure you only get one big medical thing annually.

By Politicalguineapig (not verified) on 25 Jul 2016 #permalink

PGP @167: How much you get to use your insurance totally depends on your insurance. A meeting with a doc to re-start an ADHD med should be pretty quick and easy (cheap), but again, you know your insurance better than me.

I've never had SSRIs or Strattera (is that more like Adderal or Concerta?), but you're right that there's only so much caffeine a body can take.

By JustaTech (not verified) on 25 Jul 2016 #permalink

Also, I’m not really sure that the ACA will survive beyond next January, so that’s a factor too. If I go easy on the insurance, maybe no one will notice and I’ll get to keep it. I also already used it once this year- I’m pretty sure you only get one big medical thing annually.

Medicaid? My buddy Vlad (shortly starting a position in Austin, the lucky duck) used it extensively during the year after grad school when he was scraping by working at a coffee shop. No problems there.

Justatech: Strattera's unbranded name is atomoxitine, if that means anything to you. I think that means it's less of a stimulant than Concerta or Adderall are. I don't know why I was given a prescription for it, since it occasionally makes depression worse. Since I was in college at that time, it might have been so my roommates didn't rip me off or so I didn't try to sell my meds on campus. I've cut down a bit from the caffeine since graduating: I'm now down to 2 cups of coffee and one cup of tea per day.

I don't really know what my insurance covers nor do I understand the system. I'm lucky it covered my stitches.

I'm just really paranoid about health insurance, as most of the companies seem to be run by Lex Luthor clones, who deny coverage for any reason or no reason at all. As far as I'm concerned, it makes about as much sense as Kafka.

JP: Medicaid only works if you have paid into the system. Since most of my jobs are cash-or-check deals, I'm not sure that is an option.(I do a lot of petsitting, writing, some elder care, and lawn mowing.)

By Politicalguineapig (not verified) on 25 Jul 2016 #permalink

IN RESPONSE TO:

Julian Frost
Gauteng East Rand
July 20, 2016

@Fendlesworth:

" I think the pharmaceutical companies will be pressured to change adjuvants in response to social pressure. LPS and calcium phosphate seem like safe choices and elicit a favorable immune response. With a proper reformulation, I would think that there would be much less opposition.

I’m afraid that’s an antivaccine talking point. Change the formulation and there’ll be less complaining. Experience doesn’t bear that out. Antivaxxers had a tantrum over a preservative, thimerosal. It was taken out. They still complained.
Changing the formulation will not stop the complaining."

Please stop spreading more falsehoods. Mercury is STILL used in the manufacturing process of many vaccines. The levels are at a point that they are not mandated to list it on the label. At the same time that they reduced the levels of mercury, they increased the levels of aluminum. How much longer are you people going to be in denial? Its becoming a sad joke.

Mercury is STILL used in the manufacturing process of many vaccines.

Wrong. Elemental mercury has never been used in vaccine manufacture. A compound that contains mercury, C9H9HgNaO2S, is used in the manufacturing process of some vaccines as an antimicrobial -- for example, to flush manufacturing lines. In any case, no routine pediatric vaccine now on the market contains even a trace amount of mercury, defined as less than 1 micrograms/dose. A microgram is one millionth of a gram. The sole routine pediatric vaccine that had "a trace" was Tripedia (DTaP); it was discontinued in 2011. One flu vaccine, Novartis's Fluvirin, contains a trace amount of mercury; <1ug Hg/0.5mL dose. Thimerosal-free preparations of flu vaccines are available.

At the same time that they reduced the levels of mercury, they increased the levels of aluminum.

You are revealing your profound ignorance here. The use of thimerosal and aluminum gels or salts in vaccines are unrelated. The former is an anti-microbial, the latter serves as an adjuvant, increasing the body's response to to the vaccine.

Your claim that the levels of aluminum in vaccines has increased over time seems to be unfounded as well. Further, in 2011 Mitkus et al reported:

the body burden of aluminum from vaccines and diet throughout an infant's first year of life is significantly less than the corresponding safe body burden of aluminum modeled using the regulatory MRL. We conclude that episodic exposures to vaccines that contain aluminum adjuvant continue to be extremely low risk to infants and that the benefits of using vaccines containing aluminum adjuvant outweigh any theoretical concerns.

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22001122

Actually, the inability of anti-vaccine proponents to accept reality is the sad joke.

Mercury is STILL used in the manufacturing process of many vaccines. The levels are at a point that they are not mandated to list it on the label.

But Cypher knows about this secret use anyway, because special sources of information. I am intrigued and would like to know more. The leprechauns told him / her?

By herr doktor bimler (not verified) on 31 Jul 2016 #permalink

@ Pheobe C

Has anyone actually heard Lanka’s anti-measles arguments?

I only read a few excerpts from the interview he gave. He lost me with his argument that biology and medicine prove that measles virus - or any virus, if I followed him correctly - cannot do that it's supposed to do.
We must not have attended the same biology courses.

@ Kevin Stacy

the newly found element Autisium. [...] It’s symbol is Au

Is this an example of comedy gold?

By Helianthus (not verified) on 01 Aug 2016 #permalink