The Failure of 'He Said/She Said' Journalism

Billmon has a superb post on the failures of journalism due to Compulsive Centrist Disorder:

But no one in the corporate media, to my knowledge, has even come close to putting an accurate lead on the story -- which would look something like this:

Faced with the likely loss of one if not both houses of Congress, the Republican Party has embarked on a massive, last-ditch effort to smear Democratic challengers in competitive districts across the country.

The resulting campaign has completely demolished whatever minor restraints remained on the use of lies and distortions in political attack ads, and has pushed the already debased American political process to a new low.

A "straight" journalist couldn't possibly write a lead like that and expect to get it past his/her editor -- even though the Republicans themselves revealed their intentions quite clearly some weeks ago:

The National Republican Congressional Committee, which this year dispatched a half-dozen operatives to comb through tax, court and other records looking for damaging information on Democratic candidates, plans to spend more than 90 percent of its $50 million-plus advertising budget on what officials described as negative ads.

Opposition research is power," said Rep. Thomas M. Reynolds (N.Y.), the NRCC chairman. "Opposition research is the key to defining untested opponents."

The only fresh "news" is that the resulting ads are even fouler and more despicable than any the Rovian machine has unleashed in the past -- to the point where some of them would probably have made Joseph Goebbels himself blush.

It's bad enough when Compulsive Centrist Disorder inflicts itself on evolutionary biology. It's worse when it pervades the entire journalistic infrastructure.

More like this

By way of AmericaBlog comes this news about the Democrats' fundraising: According to the Washington Post -- and Ken Mehlman -- Democrats are competitive with the Republicans in fundraising this year because of the internet: NC Chairman Ken Mehlman, whose committee has seen a 10 percent fundraising…
The NY Times' Matt Bai writes a predictable article about the Gifford shooting: Within minutes of the first reports Saturday that Representative Gabrielle Giffords, an Arizona Democrat, and a score of people with her had been shot in Tucson, pages began disappearing from the Web. One was Sarah…
People look at Fox News and wonder how the heck it manages to be taken seriously. Most of what is done on that station is not news, and it isn't even commentary by any reasonable journalistic standards. Fox News is much of the time a mouthpiece for the Right Wing and the Republican Party. The…
The National Republican Congressional Committee is pulling its ad support for Michelle Bachmann (italics mine): Five days after Rep. Michele Bachmann went on a McCarthy-esque rant suggesting Barack Obama was unpatriotic and urging the major newspapers of the country to investigate anti-American…

It's hardly news that this is a problem. I gave up on the mainstream US media's "he said/she said" reporting back during the breakup of Yugoslavia: mainly because the comments of people who were promoting genocide were presented with as much credence as the comments of others. All many in the US media did was present the statements of politicians without any investigation into what was going on. "News" is now presented to entertain rather than inform the public, so why spend the money to actually investigate?