Should Antibiotics Be Given a Separate Regulatory Drug Category?

Well, we do it for narcotics. From Yahoo News:

International experts debated whether antibiotics merit a separate regulatory drug category at a World Congress held on December 11 and 12 at the Hyatt Regency Boston Hotel. "We proposed this drastic action because antibiotic resistance is undermining infectious disease treatment worldwide and many large pharmaceutical companies are leaving the antibiotic field," explains Stuart B. Levy, MD, a Tufts Medical School professor and president of APUA, the global public health organization convening the meeting. Pharmaceutical companies spend an estimated $800 million to bring a new antibiotic to market. They face time limits on patent protection before others can manufacture and sell the compound without investing in this expensive research. Also pharmaceutical houses are turning to more profitable lifestyle and chronic disease drugs...

"If antibiotics can be given a special category by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, then unique considerations could be applied to them," says Levy. "By placing antibiotics in a separate regulatory category we could also promote better antibiotic stewardship by patients and doctors and promote responsible industry marketing strategies," according to Kathy Young, executive director of APUA.

Antibiotics are powerful life-saving medicines for use in serious bacterial infections as diagnosed by a physician. However, casual antibiotic use is the norm in many hospitals and community practices in the U.S. As a result, we are experiencing accelerated evolution of resistant bacteria and increased difficulty of treating infections. According to the CDC, half of medically prescribed antibiotics in the U.S. are unnecessary.

Unlike most drugs, how one patient uses antibiotics can alter how well antibiotics will work in another patient. In other words, if you misuse vancomycin, bacteria can evolve resistance to it, but you misuse Lipitor all you want and it won't effect someone else's outcome. We need something, particular since CDC isn't stepping up to the plate by proposing substantial policies like 'search and destroy'.

An aside: The cost to market of an antibiotic is not $800 million. It is $1.2 billion, once things like capitalization are accounted for.

More like this

...or at least, I was mentioned in Cell. Currently, we have very few new antibiotics in the pipeline, particularly for Gram-negative bacteria such as Acinetobacter. One of the things I'm involved with is a project to develop a not-for-profit screening library to find new antibiotics. From Cell:…
A recent article by National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID) staff emphasized that NIAID funds over $800 million annually to study antimicrobial resistance. I've heard this same argument many times, and, every time, people always grumble about how that money includes all…
The adjective extreme has been extremely overused in recent years.  For example, I recently saw a sign in a gas station that advertised an Extreme Meal Deal: a hot dog, chips, and soda for $2.49.   But href="http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?set_id=14&click_id=125&art_id=…
Last month, researchers from China reported in The Lancet Infectious Diseases that they had identified a gene (MCR-1) that confers antibiotic resistance to a last-resort antibiotic (colistin) and then found that gene in E. coli isolates from pigs, meat, and hospital patients. This prompted Danish…

This is why I cannot get antibiotics for an ear infection. This is one that has been driving me nuts for months and it started responding to a ten day course of amoxicillin.

But my damned ENT has had me on Maxxide, Ativan, Medrol, Prednisone, etc. No antibiotics. But I bet the ear infection would clear up.

It isn't my fault doctors passed out antibiotics like candy back in the day. Nor is it my fault that some still do. But when I need the stuff, the so called professionals are aghast to even recommend it.

Makes me crazy.

In hospitals, doctors, nurses, and staffers, at the first sign of respiratory symptoms, get dosed with the latest and greatest antibiotics so that they won't have to take off sick days. Even if the drugs don't stop the infection, they may protect against catching a second infection, and symptomatic treatment will help keep down the sniffles, sneezing, and coughing.

Actually, this is understandable. To recover completely from a cold, figure 10 workdays absence. On average, four colds a year means the budget needs to be 40 sick days a year. That's eight weeks paid time off. Nobody (outside of Congress) can take 40 sick days a year. Thus people who work in hospitals must avoid taking sick time (just like the rest of the working world).

Everybody with any connection to hospitals knows all this. All cops, paramedics, firefighters, and EMTs have their contacts at hospitals to get them the latest and greatest antibiotics.

All these people are walking Petri dishes for nosocomial infections.

If somebody wants to make any headway against resistant infections, they will have to give daily drug testing -- for antibiotics -- for all hospital personnel and all people visiting staffers.

If somebody wants to make any headway against resistant infections, they will have to give daily drug testing -- for antibiotics -- for all hospital personnel and all people visiting staffers.

But the root of the problem, as you describe it, is insufficient time off for illness. If insufficient time off for illness is the cause, drug testing will not fix it. There are too many ways around drug testing.

But the root of the problem, as you describe it, is insufficient time off for illness. - llewelly

Indeed. Even a minor bacterial infection sometimes can resolve itself just fine if the patient has a chance to get proper bed-rest and plenty of fluids, etc. After all, people survive viral illnesses of comparable severity without anti-virals.

But does anybody even know what the myriad federal, state and local regulations allow/require in terms of even unpayed sick leave? I have a friend who works as a gate-guard in that capitol of gated communities, South FL. She has ovarian cysts, and her employer has threatened to fire her if she even misses work for doctors' appointments (and they don't necessarily allow her to schedule time off in the first place).