John Aravosis' Christmas Time Snarl at the Poor

John Aravosis, in a burst of rage, demonstrates why I can't stand 'progressives' (italics mine):

I don't claim to be an expert on health care policy, and admit that my eyes gloss over when trying to understand the differences between Hillary's, Obama's, and Edwards' health care plan. But I have a gut feeling that none of those plans are meant to help people like me, people in the middle, people who are neither rich nor poor. Just like the sub-prime bail-out, where our politicians are helping to artificially inflate real estate prices so first-time home buyers like me can pay tens of thousands, if not a hundred thousand, more for my first condo (that's called a "tax"), everything politicians do is meant to help either the rich or the poor at my expense.

Aravosis then goes on to decry various policies that favor the rich...which has nothing to with the poor. I'm all for not screwing the middle to favor the rich--anyone who reads this blog knows this. But helping the poor is not the moral equivalent of helping the rich. Most philosophies, religious or not (except for Ayn Randism), call for helping the poor and needy*. Lashing out at the poor is precisely what conservatives want you to do, rather than having people help the poor.

Bah humbug.

*Granted, how to help is often not agreed upon.

More like this

John Aravosis demonstrates once again why I refuse to call myself a progressive (italics mine): Seriously, any plan to bail these people out had better include a test to prove that they were hoodwinked by their mortgage broker. Otherwise, they gambled and they lost. Lots of people bought homes…
Pundits discuss Democratic candidates The mainstream media has a double standard for Democratic candidates. INCONCEIVABLE! Jameson Foser writes (italics mine): Cavuto suggests it's hypocritical for Edwards, a wealthy man, to want to eradicate poverty. That is essentially what Beck and Cafferty…
The shit is hitting the fan: all those sub-prime mortgages given out so recklessly over the past two years are getting their interest rates re-adjusted. And that, of course, is when the foreclosures begin. By most measures, sub-prime loans are a bad idea. Look, for example, at the popular 2/28 loan…
Well, it's that time again. With the world economy in crisis, and the administration sticking to it's "Everything's gonna be OK" strategy, our candidates are holding a "town hall"-style debate. I live-blogged the last debate, and it wiped me out and pissed off the other people in the room, but…

This is why I don't read AmericaBlog regularly anymore. He does some great investigative and activist work on occasion, but his tendency to fall back on Republican frames to distance himself from political allies, and willingness to throw political allies off the bus is not worth the aggravation for the service his blog provides most of the time. A number of liberal blogs also cover his field of specialization without the same tendencies.

Aravosis has the tendency to be so full of himself at times, that he can't see the forest for the tree. JA stands for more than his name.

By genesgalore (not verified) on 18 Dec 2007 #permalink

the ads have gotten out of control over there.

I still visit but I leave quickly and don't bother reading what he writes.