The GOP Faux Populism Con

If a Democrat said something as half as derogatory about someone's background, he or she would be pilloried non-stop as an 'out-of-touch, liberal elitist.' But if John Kasich, former Republican Congressman who is running for governor of Ohio, is any guide, IOKIYAR is still operative:

The first line of Ohio Gov. Ted Strickland's campaign biography boasts the Democratic governor is "the son of a steelworker" who "never imagined he'd be able to go to college."

Indeed, Strickland's humble upbringing is just the type campaigns love to highlight, and never more so during an economic climate that still hasn't shown signs for recovery for many Ohioans.

But the campaign of Strickland's Republican opponent -- former U.S. Rep. John Kasich -- is causing a stir for attacking the same simple origins Strickland celebrates.

Kasich spokesman Rob Nichols said in a statement Tuesday Strickland is a poor manager of Ohio's cities because the Democrat was raised "in a chicken shack on Duck Run."

Apparently, Kasich's campaign has made this claim more than once--this was not a 'gaffe.' Of course, it would be uncivil to note that Kasich, after leaving Congress, worked on Wall Street for Lehman Brothers.

Because that's the typical experience of 'real America.'

Kasich was forced to apologize, but, again, if a Democrat had said something like this, it would have been on the cable networks non-stop.

More like this

Under the fold: Ex-Cheney aide: Bush won't hit Iran: US President George W. Bush will not attack Iran to halt its nuclear weapons program before his term ends in January, David Wurmser, a key national security adviser to Vice President Dick Cheney up until last year, has told The Jerusalem Post.…
Yesterday, Pulitzer-winning author and Obama advisor Samantha Power told reporters: "We f***** up in Ohio," she admitted. "In Ohio, they are obsessed and Hillary is going to town on it, because she knows Ohio's the only place they can win. "She is a monster, too -- that is off the record -- she is…
Note to GOP - ACORN Was Defrauded and You Know It: 1. The GOP during the 70's, 80's and 90's employed a number of methods to register voters to insure the people they were registering were indeed Republican. One method was to go through a neighborhood and register everyone who wasn't registered.…
Maybe if the Obama administration and the Blue Dog (corporate) Democrats fought for an economic policy that made the middle-class' lives better, we wouldn't be faced with the looming political failure to deal with environmental problems. From Politico: Most House Republicans envision killing Nancy…

If you read the quote in context, he didn't say that it was *because* of where he was raised that he would be a poor manager. In fact from what I can see he didn't really give a reason.

I'm not saying this was an especially smart thing to do, I'm saying that the blog you quoted from attributed causation where none really was given.

One of my department chair colleagues was a steelworkers son, and union member. He worked in the mills all the way through his PhD. When asked about his source of support, he would tell people he had a US Steel scholarship. Me, I was raised on a little 2x4 ranch in Texas with no indoor plumbing. I do think your raising informs you in a way people raised differently are not informed.

By Jim Thomerson (not verified) on 26 Jun 2010 #permalink