There Are Probably A Lot of Angry Spanish Farmers Right About Now...

...and I can't blame them. The recent and ongoing E. coli outbreak which began in Germany was originally claimed to have been traced to Spanish cucumbers. Erm, not so much:

German agricultural authorities on Sunday identified locally grown bean sprouts as the likely cause of an E. coli outbreak that has killed 22 people and sickened hundreds in Europe.

The Lower Saxony agriculture ministry was sending an alert Sunday warning people to stop eating the sprouts, which are often used in mixed salads, ministry spokesman Gert Hahne told The Associated Press.

"Bean sprouts have been identified as the product that likely caused the outbreak," Hahne said. "Many restaurants that suffered from an E.coli outbreak had those sprouts delivered."

Hahne said the sprouts were grown on a farm in Lower Saxony in northern Germany. He did not elaborate but planned a news conference later Sunday.

Hahne said while official test results have not yet conclusively shown that the Lower Saxony-grown sprouts were to blame, "all indications speak to them being" the cause.

Meanwhile, the quality of care is being questioned:

Nicoletta Pabst, 41, told the AP on Saturday that sanitary conditions at the Hamburg-Eppendorf hospital had been horrendous and its emergency room filled with ailing people.

"All of us had diarrhea and there was only one bathroom each for men and women -- it was a complete mess," she said. "If I hadn't been sick with E. coli by then, I probably would have picked it up over there."

After waiting three hours to be seen, Pabst was told to go home because her blood levels did not indicate that she had kidney failure. When her symptoms deteriorated sharply, she had to return by ambulance the next morning and was treated for a week at a different hospital.

While this might have been a poor diagnosis, containing the diarrhea patients to one bathroom is what hospitals should do--it's easier to prevent it from spreading to other patients.

I'll have more to say about the outbreak tomorrow, but the EU and German public health response to this has been less than stellar at the upper levels.

More like this

My current favorite news story is one by Reuters about an outbreak of e,coli in Germany attributed to organically grown bean sprouts with the ridiculous headline "E. Coli Outbreak Poses Questions for Organic Farming." Now it is absolutely true that there is a nasty outbreak of e.coli in Germany…
After blaming cucumbers, backpedaling on the cucumbers and blaming bean sprouts, then backpedaling on the sprouts, German authorities have now concluded that bean sprouts are, in fact, to blame for the spread of E. coli O104:H4, which has sickened more than 3,000 people and killed 31. Patients with…
Well, Sunday the said we'd have some results on the sprout tests for E. coli O104:H4. Well, so far the results are negative. The 1st tests from a north German farm suspected of being the source of an _E. coli_ [O104:H4] outbreak are negative, officials say. Of 40 samples from the farm being…
Via H5N1, German officials are calling it for sprouts: Germany on Friday blamed sprouts for a bacteria outbreak that has left at least 30 dead and some 3,000 ill, and cost farmers across Europe hundreds of millions in lost sales. "It's the sprouts," Reinhard Burger, the president of the Robert Koch…


Maybe they thought sprout - based STEC / EHEC infections were so....20th century. They wanted to go with something splashier!

By Chromosome Crawl (not verified) on 05 Jun 2011 #permalink

Apparently they did find EHEC on those cucumbers, but it eventually turned out to be a different strain.
I suppose if they had waited for the definitive final diagnosis before warning, they would have been roasted for allowing people to fall ill and die in the meantime, if it had indeed turned out to be that strain. Arguably, that would have been a bigger disaster.
How is EHEC on cucumbers okay anyway?

I do feel sympathy for farmers as a whole who can't sell their crops at the moment. I was given a cucumber for free at a local market (yes, in Germany) recently with a desperate-sounding comment of "this won't hurt you, it's from around here". "Around here" being the southern end of the country.

What am I missing? Sprouts are very difficult, if not impossible, to clean adequately. Cucumbers, not so much (assuming it is on the skin - does e coli get inside the skin of cucumbers?). Why would one not look at sprouts first for food borne e coli outbreaks?

The health authorities stated quite some days ago that the source are probably raw vegetables, which as far as I understand led to quite some decline in the sales. Since cucumber is practically only eaten raw, the Spanish farmers would feel the same consequences even without the public warning, so where exactly is the problem? Especially considering Nina's comment; had the authorities not given out the information they would be criticised as well.

Why would one not look at sprouts first for food borne e coli outbreaks?

Well, stupid coincidences happen - the way it starts to look right now, several of the restaurants that received the EHEC contaminated sprouts also received cucumbers from Spain which were contaminated with a separate, more harmless EHEC strain. The cucumber connection just happened to be discovered first, and before the strain on the cucumber was precisely identified, it seemed like a rather convincing case.

By Phillip IV (not verified) on 06 Jun 2011 #permalink

Well, the problem is that there is NO evidence of EHEC strains in cucumbers, as far as I knoe, only of E. coli isolates. That's pretty poor basis for a health alarm as coliforms are everywhere. And EHEC strains are a much more serious, and diferent, risk than generic coliform contamination.