Pirates and academics

Some people find the connection evades their understanding, but Ian has found it.

More like this

Bloody Pope. In a major speech reported all over the UK and probably around the world, the Pope whinged about religion being silenced [1]. Quite why he can't see the obvious problem in that is a mystery. Maybe self-awareness isn't his strong point. For extra fun, Ian Paisley denounces the Pope is…
Michael Nielsen wrote another long thought-provoking essay (for his book, I guess): ............Two clarifications are in order. First, when I say that these are examples of scientific facts beyond individual understanding, I'm not saying a single person can't understand the meaning of the facts.…
Elaine Howard Ecklund has a new paper out, building on her survey of scientists' views on religion, research she reported in a book last year, and in a series of papers over the last few years. In this paper (press release for those of you who haven't got access to the journal), she looks…
Everything is connected to everything else. Sometimes, the connections are non-trivial. Often they are fundamental, sometimes exploitable, and now and then very potent sources of debate and discussion. I've come to think that a measure of sanity is the degree to which one limits a sense of…

Now I really want to become a professor. Now I have to choose between Art and Physics...

Ynd dow naught forgete alsow ye sodome, anowther connekshun. Ynd I speke as ye sodomite.

Captain B. Dagger Lee

By bdaggerlee (not verified) on 19 Oct 2006 #permalink

Pirates and academics are also akin because they speak an argot incomprehensible to outsiders. The explanation for the similarity in their use of language is that both scientists and pirates are polyglot comglomeration thrown together in cramped quarters, a paper in SCIENCE or the Jolly Rogers as the case may be. If your crew consists of Swedes, Dutch, Portuguese, French, Indians, Arabs, Caribs, and Lascars or, in the alternative, Hungarian matematicians, German-Jewish physicists, and Taiwanese statisticians, it's no wonder that you have to resort to hand waving and obsenitites to keep your desperate crews in line. People just won't admit how much Henry Morgan there was in J. Robert Oppenheimer.

I thought Lascars are (east) Indians - or are you referring to North American indians ? But were there any pirates among those ? Strikes me as unlikely.

The Lascars are mentioned in an early 19th century narrative by a guy named Trelawny (Adventures of Young Son). I actually shortened his list of nationalities: he mentions Mussulmans, Daccamen, and Cooleys ("samples of almost all the seafaring natives of India"). I found the quote in Louis-Jean Calvet's book Towards an Ecology of World Languages. Calvet has a section on the linguistics of the pirate life.