Well, that debate is over now

Confirmed: God is dead.

Dawkins' and Harris' book sales are going to plummet.

More like this

Why is it that one of the top critics of religion should be a biologist? Could it be that a deep understanding of biological evolution through natural selection really does lead one inexorably to atheism? If so, creationists might actually have reason to fear the inclusion of evolution in school…
We must keep this from the serfs, lest they gain literacy and threaten the landed gentry!! Worried that some of us would start thinking Christians have a monopoly on teh stupid, Muslims in Indonesia have bravely stepped up to defend their faith against Evil Atheists like Richard Dawkins... By not…
Reviews of Hitchens' book are already appearing. Here's one from Bruce DeSilva of the Associated Press. I found two items of interest. The first is an amusing instance of an error in word choice. DeSilva writes: Hitchens is the reincarnation of H.L. Mencken, the penultimate social critic of the…
It's been confirmed: members of the Oklahoma legislature are investigating the suspicious circumstances of Richard Dawkins' lecture. After all, what possible excuse could UO have for inviting a known rabblerouser who doesn't happen to believe in gods? Other than his reputation as a world-famous…

Black & white video, eh? That must have been many years ago. (Funny, I never knew that Nietzsche had ever been videotaped.)

Main point: If God has really been dead all these years, then who the hell has George W been talking to every night?

Main point: If God has really been dead all these years, then who the hell has George W been talking to every night?

Presumably, Henry Kissinger was hiding under the bed each night when
W. prayed ...

Zeno said:
"Main point: If God has really been dead all these years, then who the hell has George W been talking to every night?"

A bed, wall, or chair, of course. ;-)

Zeno:

Black & white video, eh? That must have been many years ago. (Funny, I never knew that Nietzsche had ever been videotaped.)

Actually, it's only about 5 or 6 years old. They filmed it in B&W for a "retro" look...

Main point: If God has really been dead all these years, then who the hell has George W been talking to every night?

Why, the same person that everyone else who thinks they talk to God actually talks to, of course: himself!

Actually, it's only about 5 or 6 years old.

IIRC, that was a "Kid's in the Hall" sketch, which means it would have been done in the late 80s/early 90's, yes?

I love the anti-spam feature now at UTI, requiring the user to type in an answer to a trivial math problem in order to comment.

Maybe this could be adapted as an anti-troll feature with a little bit of tweaking...?

"Please type in the definite integral of 3x^3 + 4x^2 in the range 0 to 14.3"

I'm sure you can think of some more suitable questions ;-)

By Millimeter Wave (not verified) on 08 Nov 2006 #permalink

Trouble is, gods are far too fragile for us (this goes along with the fact that he turned out to be tiny). They can't bear to have primates saying bad things about them, scientific theories threaten them, and just leaving them alone is something that upsets their existence.

It's like Nietzsche said, we killed god. Evolved apes are too powerful for him. Evolved apes are his agents to teach ID/creationism in the schools, for he had neither the evidence nor the power to get his ideas to humans.

So it's kind of sad, sure, but we knew he was going to die eventually as he was never robust enough to live in the same universe as humans (some gods are aloof enough to survive humans, of course, however they can't manage to do both that and too affect the universe in time periods which can be studied).

Glen D
http://tinyurl.com/b8ykm

I don't remember this one. But it is classic KitH. Someone should pull out the Season 1 story of the crucifiction as told by Dr. Seuss.

Not just dead, though...dead AND small.
Why, he hardly weighed nothin'.

Here is a good one for you. David Icke explains the history of the world. A reptilian species actually controls the world!

http://gods4suckers.net/

I think it was Greg Bear who wrote a (surprisingly good) short story along these lines, set forty years after the death of God, narrated from the POV of a `son of stone and flesh' (the statues came to life when God died, you see, and, um, reproduced with people in a bacchanalian orgy...)

I must say I'm *glad* I don't live in that universe: there's lots of power in being able to change natural law by a mere act of will, but if you ever slip up, oops, was that a solar system there? I must have let the strong force slip. Sorry. Tired. You know how it is...

There's a science fiction book I read once where they discover God (in the form a giant human-looking guy), floating face up in the middle of the ocean, dead. The religious people end up trying to cover the whole thing up. It's really hilarious, but I can't remember the name or author.

Has anyone ever heard of this book? I remember the same author wrote a book about the Messiah returning in modern times except that she is a girl and the virgin impregnated is a man. Also a very entertaining book.

Stand --

The book was Towing Jehovah by James Morrow, who also wrote Only Begotten Daughter -- the other book you were thinking of.

I'm teaching Nietzsche's "God is dead" in two weeks. Maybe I can assign KitH for extra-credit?

By Carl Sachs (not verified) on 08 Nov 2006 #permalink

Yes! Thanks, Carl.

All this talk reminds me of the one book by Phillip K. Dick, where god's corpse is found floating in space. The only real reaction is to start making toys in His image.

Thank you kindly for all of the explanations, folks. Yes, it's a Kids in the Hall segment that was filmed in B&W for a retro look. I did recognize the comedians in the skit.

That was Bruce McCulloch doing the Nietzsche bit with Mark McKinney as his severe-looking fellow thinker. Kevin McDonald and Scott Thompson wore the fright wigs and exclaimed that their minds were blown, and Dave Foley wore the priest's collar as he explained how short God was. Their shows ran on the Canadian CBC network from 1989 to 1994, so the clip is at least a dozen years old.

I guess my main point about George's imaginary friend remains unaffected, though.

I miss KitH. They made some feature-length movies after the series ended, but their sketch style doesn't translate well.