Really? This guy is conscious?

You may have heard the recent news about a Belgian man who was diagnosed as being in a persistent vegetative state after an accident, but who now has been miraculously discovered to have actually been conscious for the last 23 years, trapped in a partially paralyzed body. How horrific, and how frightening that the doctors could have made such a ghastly error.

Until you watch this video. How did they figure out that the poor man was actually alert and mentally competent beneath his deeply damaged exterior? They're using facilitated communication: somebody holds his hand and moves it around to tap out messages on a computer. Look at the fellow, sitting there slack and grimacing and drooling, and the staffer deftly and quickly using his finger to peck out lucid and grammatical sentences. How does anyone fall for this?

I'd like to see how well Mr Houben communicates when his 'facilitator' is blindfolded, or when he is asked questions about objects in his line of sight but hidden from hers.

Tags

More like this

Rom Houben, the unfortunate fellow with severe brain damage who doctors claimed to be conscious via facilitated communication, is silent again.
Really, I have many jobs. But in this case, I am talking about my two jobs inside my one job as learning facilitator. I like to call myself a learning facilitator rather than a teacher or a professor because I can't make people learn (that would be teacher).
That's one way to turn French Onion Dip into Frenched Onion Dip. A Clemson University Professor has tested George's Conundrum, also known as the Seinfeld Hypothesis of Germ Theory. You know the story, and in case you don't, watch it here:
The news is finally filtering out to the rest of the world. As I pointed out a few days ago Dr.