This Week in the Journal of Previously Solved Problems

Over at the Scholarly Kitchen, Kent Anderson complains about the uselessness of comments on journals:

Comments in online scientific journals have been notoriously poor -- either too much material of uneven quality or too little discussion to amount to a hill of beans. All too often, commenting has to be shut down because internecine and tiresome debates break out, creating more noise than signal. The best comments are scholarly, and borrow extensively from the form of letters to the editor.

After more than a decade and millions of blogs, it seems one main lesson practitioners are learning -- myself included -- is that dreams of what we would call "post-publication peer-review" need to be reimagined. Not only is commenting failing overall, but communicators striving for a high standard are reinventing the wheel of invited experts to help improve materials."

Two days earlier, Jam Macdonald reduces this to a previously solved problem:

The solution is Strong, Human, Moderation. Instead of this guy [Nick Denton], who clearly doesn't know what he's doing, they should have gotten Miss Teresa [Nielsen Hayden], the inventor of disemvoweling.

One might also point to very successful online scientific comment sections, such as Terry Tao's blog or this exceptional example from the n-Category Cafe, and I'm sure there are others. Regardless, the point is: Q. E. Frickin' D., as they say.

More like this

It seems that Brock University in St. Catherine's, Ontario really likes me. Two years ago, the Library kindly invited me to speak during their Open Access Week festivities. And this year the Physics Department has also very kindly invited me to be part of their Seminar Series, also to talk about…
Why are so many scientists reluctant to make full use of Web 2.0 applications, social networking sites, blogs, wikis, and commenting capabilities on some online journals? Michael Nielsen wrote a very thoughtful essay exploring this question which I hope you read carefully and post comments. Michael…
Quantum Loonies Alán Aspuru-Guzik Brissie to Brizzle Cohærence* Complementary Slackness David Deutsch's Blog not exactly in focus Physics and cake Quantized Thoughts Quantum Algorithms Quantum Moxie Quantum Quandries rdv live from Tokyo rose.blog Shtetl-Optimized we don't need no "sticking" room…
It seems that the American Association for the Advancement of Science has just announced the new publisher of it's flagship family of Science journals: AAAS CEO Alan I. Leshner today announced the appointment of Kent Anderson, a past president of the Society for Scholarly Publishing (SPP), to serve…

Yep. Here's a depressing exercise:

1) Go to the "news" section of Nature or Science Magazine
2) Search for articles containing "LHC"
3) Count the comments by crackpots saying "they'll never find the Higgs, I proved its nonexistence on my Web page, also Einstein was wrong" or the equivalent.

Jam MacDonald?

By Jasper Janssen (not verified) on 06 Apr 2012 #permalink