God makes DNA replication suspiciously evolutionary, tricks me again

God is so tricky. New research reveals that the structure of a DNA replication molecule is similar across all three domains of life:

In two papers that will be concurrently published in the August edition of the journal Nature Structural and Molecular Biology (now available on-line), the researchers report the identification of a helical substructure within a superfamily of proteins, called AAA+, as the molecular "initiator" of DNA replication in a bacteria, Escherichia coli (E. coli), and in a eukaryote, Drosophila melanogaster, the fruit fly. Taken with earlier research that identified AAA+ proteins at the heart of the DNA replication initiator in archaea organisms, these new findings indicate that DNA replication is an ancient event that evolved millions of years ago, prior to when Archae, Bacteria and Eukarya split into separate domains of life.

...

Biochemist and structural biologist James Berger, a participant in both studies added, "Our findings of evolutionary kinship between the DNA initiators in all three domains make sense because, to paraphrase Francois Jacob, the one thing a cell wants to do is to become two cells. A cell can't do this if it doesn't replicate its DNA in the right place, at the right time, and in the right manner, while simultaneously avoiding over-replication." (Emphasis mine.)

See you would think that he would like me to conclude that the similarities of between three domains of life are because they evolved from a common origin, but actually he planned it that way just to play with me. This joke has been like 3 billion years in the making.

God...you so crazy!

The articles in Nature Structural Biology are here and here.

Tags

More like this

So, archaea are apparently the topic of the week. While I wrote here about the pathogenic potential of some species of these organisms, a new essay in Nature and a new review in Science focus more on their evolution (and the evolution of the other two domains of life) than any health application…
As we are so often reminded by proponents of Intelligent Design creationism, we contain molecular "machines" and "motors". They don't really explain how these motors came to be other than to foist the problem off on some invisible unspecified Designer, which is a poor way to do science—it's more…
There are many complex steps to the dance of DNA replication. And scientists must learn to sway along in order to understand how both healthy and cancerous cells divide. Scientists at Brookhaven National Laboratory have begun to learn how to follow the complex molecular choreography by which…
The latest re-post of my BIO101 lecture notes (this one originally from June 05, 2006). I know I will have to rewrite everything about the Three Domain Hypothesis, but you also tell me if I got other stuff wrong or if this can be in some way improved for the classroom use…

Ah, you misunderestimate your enemy. Don't you see? If the same mechanism is used by multiple branches of the tree of life it makes it that much more improbably that they evolved. After all, how could such a mechanism spontaneously leap into existence? What could have existed before the fully competent machinery? It's too complicated to be understood! Quick, shield your brain!