Shifting Sex Ratios

By josh donlan on April 5, 2008.

In some Asian countries (e.g., India, China, South Korea), it is well documented that male births often far exceed female births. In India the ratio is 1.39:1 and in China it is 2.25:1. Many point to China's one-child policy, high-dowry payments in India, or reliance on children for support as important drivers of the observed sex ratios (the biological norm is 1.05:1). New research to be published in the Proceedings of the US National Academy of Sciences challenges those factors. U.S.-born children of Chinese, Korean, and Asian parents also show a male-biased sex ratio. In 2000, if a couple had no previous sons, their third child was 50% more likely to be a son (1.51:1). The researchers point to the availability of prenatal sex determination and abortion as key factors contributing to the observed sex selection. The use of such medical technology explicitly for sex selection raises as suite of interesting ethical questions that many would rather turn their head than debate.

More like this

Sex Ratio Bias in India

Sometimes boys are worth more, sometimes girls are worth more. In an evolutionary sense. Or, more correctly, the value of a certain sex ... as an offspring ... can be measured in fitness terms. Fisher noted this and hypothesized this was the explanation for the 50-50 sex ratio we usually see.…

The prenatal wages of interracial relationships

Photo credit: Robert Hanashiro, USA TODAY It is the norm today to discuss race as a social construct. Less fashionable is it to explore race as a biological concept. When there's no up or downside and the discussion is abstract I think most people can get away with benign neglect in regards to…

Korean genetic relationships

There's a new paper, The Peopling of Korea Revealed by Analyses of Mitochondrial DNA and Y-Chromosomal Markers: Methodology and Results We analyzed mitochondrial DNA...sequence variation in the hypervariable segments I and II...and haplogroup-specific mutations in coding regions in 445 individuals…

Let's talk about sex...ratios (evolution that is)

Ruchira Paul sent me an email asking me to clarify this exposition of how gene selectionism can explain 50:50 sex ratios. First, I would like to second the author of the original post's injunction to read Richard Dawkins' The Selfish Gene, it is a masterpiece of scientific exposition. For many…

Thanks for blogging this, but I don't see how this research really challenges our understanding of what's happening in the nations you highlight. It seems to me that male children are deemed to be more valuable for whatever reason and people do what they feel they have to to obtain them regardless of which nation they inhabit.

Um, I haven't looked at the PNAS article in question, but I'd say that the US data you mention strengthens rather than challenges the hypothesis that higher male:female birth ratios are due to selective abortions. Some of the countries you mention have PR campaigns and (marginally enforced) laws against pre-natal sex determination. Presumably as people with these sociological impulses move to the US where such measures are absent, they are free to give full rein to their desires for a male child. They are also more likely to do this after being initially "disappointed" with one or more daughters.

Perhaps a comparison of sex ratios of aborted fetuses amongst various populations/cohorts would clarify this issue.

Advertisment

Donate

ScienceBlogs is where scientists communicate directly with the public. We are part of Science 2.0, a science education nonprofit operating under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. Please make a tax-deductible donation if you value independent science communication, collaboration, participation, and open access.

You can also shop using Amazon Smile and though you pay nothing more we get a tiny something.

Science 2.0

Science Codex

EPA Reconsiders Its Biden Ban On Asbestos Everywhere

More by this author

A Lame Duck Screwing The Environment

November 5, 2008

During Clinton's 11th hour, he initiated a number of policies that protected the environment; some of those regulations have remained in force, including the protection of almost 60 million acres of roadless areas. According to an article in Nature this week (and the OMB Watch, a Washington DC-…

Barcelona Blues

October 22, 2008

I just returned from the World Conservation Congress in Barcelona, where 8,000 of conservation's "best and brightest" (along with plenty of the "most important") gathered to discuss, talk, and work toward a more diverse and sustainable world. I wish I had good news to report - but it is mostly…

The "Best Of" Some Good Reading

October 18, 2008

Every year Houghton-Mifflin puts out a edited volume entitled "The Best American Science and Nature Writing". The latest volume looks like some delightful bedtime reading (although I may be biased because I was chosen as one of the authors). It includes works by Freeman Dyson, Edward Hoagland,…

World Conservation Forum

October 1, 2008

I am hastily heading to the World Conservation Forum in Barcelona, which starts next week. Here, more than 8,000 of the world's leading decision makers in sustainable development will convene: from governments, NGOs, business, the UN and academia. Together in one place for 10 days, they will to…

Where The Auroxen Roam

September 26, 2008

In this month's issue of Wired Magazine, Andrew Curry writes about rewilding projects around the world. In particular, he describes the wonderful efforts going on in the Netherlands.