Ludicrous legislation proposal on manatee status


As alerted by other ScienceBloggers, I have recently learned that the US Fish & Wildlife Service is proposing to the White House that Florida's manatee be removed from the "endangered" list, downgrading the marine mammal to merely "threatened." The result would be a relaxation of boating speed and access rules that have allowed the manatee population to recover over the last 15 years.

Like Shelley of Retrospectacle and Kevin Beck of Dr. Joan Bushwell's Chimpanzee Refuge, I spent a few years of my prime years in Florida (evidence of my support of manatee preservation above). I continue to be amazed that the natural features that attract people to Florida are the very same things being attacked by developers and selectively-minded outdoors "enthusiasts." As most know, boat propellers are the number one threat to the slow-moving sea cows, leading Kevin to comment on a Carl Hiassen column from last summer:

It is equally obvious that it's not just manatees at risk. Hiaasen in his column noted that out of 396 manatee deaths in 2005, 315 -- close to 80% -- were the result of causes other than natural ones. The more people who speed along the coasts on Jetskis and in motorboats, the more seacows they'll hit and the more severe the accidents will be for all involved. I don't give a shit how many martini-powered half-wits in rented watercraft fly overboard, never to be seen again, but you'd think the many voices of state tourism and local chambers of commerce might.

Shelley used to study manatees while in Florida and notes that the population is not exactly exploding, a mere fraction of the tens of thousands believed to live in the state's waters a hundred years ago. The first manatee census in 1991, funded partly by the sale of license plates, counted 1,267 animals with last year's rising to 3,116. This year's count, however, has them back down to 2,812, possibly already reflecting a result from last summer's first discussion of the reclassification move.

To learn more about Florida's famous sea mammal, visit the official site of the Save The Manatee Club.


More like this

The month to maim marine mammal legislation... A symposium at the United Nations in New York last Friday opened discussions about whether the Japanese should resume whaling of humpback whales that travel off the coast of Australia. Daniel Pauly was at the meeting and refuted the Japanese argument…
In response to the news that the US Fish and Wildlife Service is even thinking about downlisting the Florida manatee from "endangered" to "threatened," I make this modest proposal: boycott Florida. Trichechus manatus is considered vulnerable on habitat-wide level by the IUCN - World Conservation…
This is really upsetting, especially to someone who used to study manatees: Florida has been toying with the idea of down-grading manatees' "endangered" status and relaxing the amount of protection they receive. Protective laws include (and consist mostly of) laws which force boaters to slow down…
A little bit of housecleaning here at Shifting Baselines. First, Sea Shepherd, the anti-whalers preparing for their campaign against Japanese whalers right now in Australia, have named one of their two boats after Steve Irwin, the deceased Crocodile Hunter. Over at Grist, Erik Hoffner has a nice…

Thanks for blogging this, Abel! Those manatee license plates are pretty cool and some of the money goes into a protection fund for the manatees. Good incentive to get one.