She was a very strange woodpecker

Here's a sadly deceased female Great spotted woodpecker Picoides major I recently photographed in a private collection. She was a very unusual woodpecker. Any ideas why?

i-dd457aa5afa22d55a547171c0f669ad3-GS woodpecker 11-8-2008 cropped resized.jpg

The Great spotted woodpecker has an immense range, extending from western Europe (though Ireland lucks out) all the way to Japan and the Kamchatka Peninsula. It also occurs on the Canary Islands, in north-west Africa, in Turkey and the Causasus, and in eastern China down to Burma and north-east India (Winkler et al. 1995). Great spotted woodpeckers across this range vary in overall size, bill length and robustness, and in the extent of whiteness they possess, and 14 subspecies have been recognised. However, much of this variation is clinal and Zink et al. (2002) found no phylogeographical divisions among these populations except for one that divides the main Palaearctic population from that of Hokkaido, Sakhalin and Primor'e. That 'far eastern' population has generally been regarded as the subspecies P. m. japonicus and it might warrant recognition as a separate species. Garcia-del-Rey et al. (2007) have since found that the Canary Islands populations are also obviously distinct [here's the other side of the individual shown above].

i-1bf29e0e1e697a03fcdfdc3b06ad2018-GS woodpecker 11-8-2008 other side cropped resized.jpg

As a European person, I think of the Great spotted woodpecker as a bird of broadleaf forests, parks and gardens, but it's just at home in high-altitude conifer woodland, tropical rhododendron forest and Mediterranean olive groves. Mostly a canopy bird, it drills for sap and is well known for its habit of using favoured anvils as places where it breaks up arthropods, fruits, nuts, seeds and cones, and it's a generalist, eating assorted plant material as well as arthropods including plant lice, caterpillars, spiders and ants. It is a notorious predator of bird eggs and nestlings and is apparently a key predator of some passerines (like the Penduline tit Remiz pendulinus), even breaking into nest-boxes to get at the nestlings.

Some readers might know the Great spotted woodpecker as Dendrocopos major. Because Dendrocopos (the ladder-backed or pied woodpeckers) is apparently paraphyletic with respect to Picoides (the three-toed woodpeckers) (Weibel & Moore 2002, Rutkowsi et al. 2007), some authors have argued that the two genera should be merged. Picoides Lacépède, 1799 - arguably the less familiar of these two names - is older, and thus has priority over Dendrocopos Koch, 1816. This has been reflected in some general texts on woodpeckers (like Winkler et al.'s Woodpeckers of the World) but not in others (like Del Hoyo et al.'s Handbook of the Birds of the World) and remains the source of debate [male Great spotted woodpecker shown below, from wikipedia].

i-52dec8e93c079869d71d280d616d7012-GS woodpecker wikipedia 11-8-2008.jpg

Veniliornis (the Neotropical bar-bellied woodpeckers), the Okinawa woodpecker Sapheopipo noguchii and Dendropicos (the African grey-green woodpeckers) have also been suggested to be part of the pied woodpecker clade, but some studies find the affinities of these taxa to be elsewhere. It's widely agreed that the phylogenetic history of pied woodpeckers is more complex than used to be thought (see, e.g., Moore et al. 2006), but a taxonomy that accurately reflects the new data has yet to emerge.

Dammit, have written too much again. Was intending just to post those photos. Why was she a very strange woodpecker?

Refs - -

Garcia-del-Rey, E., Delgado, G., Gonzalez, J. & Wink, M. 2007. Canary Island great spotted woodpecker (Dendrocopus major) has distinct mtDNA. Journal of Ornithology 148, 531-536.

Moore, W. S., Weibel, A. C. & Agius, A. 2006. Mitochondrial DNA phylogeny of the woodpecker genus Veniliornis (Picidae, Picinae) and related genera implies convergent evolution of plumage patterns. Zoological Journal of the Linnean Society 87, 611-624.

Rutkowski, R., Jagolkowska, P., Mazgajski, T. D. & Reht, L. 2007. A mitochondrial DNA control region phylogeny of the European woodpeckers Picidae. Genus Supplement 14, 173-176.

Weibel, A. & Moore, W. S. 2002. Molecular phylogeny of a cosmopolitan group of woodpeckers (genus Picoides) based on COI and cyt b mitochondrial gene sequences. Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution 22, 65-75.

Winkler, H., Christie, D. A. & Nurney, D. 1995. Woodpeckers. Pica Press, Mountfield.

Zink, R. M., Drovetski, S. V. & Rohwer, S. 2002. Phylogeographic patterns in the
great spotted woodpecker Dendrocopos major across Eurasia. Journal of Avian Biology 33, 175-178.

More like this

The Great spotted woodpecker shown here yesterday was, I think, an unusual individual, and thanks to everyone who had a go at explaining what it was that made her so odd. Unfortunately no-one got it right. Several of you noted that she appeared to be tridactyl on at least one foot, whereas she…
So, I recently returned from a brief sojourn in Libya. The trip was led by Richard Moody, best known for his work on Cretaceous sea turtles; I was also accompanied by palaeornithologist Gareth Dyke and by a group of people interested in the country's geology. Libya - officially, the Great…
In the previous post we introduced the aetosaurs, a strange and fascinating group of armour-plated quadrupedal Triassic crurotarsans. Equipped with stout limbs, a strange upturned snout and (usually) toothless jaw tips, aetosaurs have been interpreted as omnivores, herbivores, and even as…
Yesterday - the day I posted an article on horned treefrogs - there was a peak on the site stats graph. In view of that I'm thinking that weird anurans are popular, so I'll try the same trick again. This time round we're looking at another group of 'horned' anurans: the Brazilian smooth horned…

Let me guess, three toes?

Well unless the camera lens is distorting the image, one foot looks massive in comparison to the other.

PSA: You've been nominated by another blogger for an award. The actual voting will begin soon, but until that point, if you'd like to check out what you have been nominated for, and maybe even snag a banner to tell everybody, click the links!

If you're not interested in awards then just ignore it, or if you're utterly against them, let me know and I'll remove you from the longlist.


is the bill longer that usual? Seems to be long, and more so when I compare it to my photos of this species. And I seem to rememeber a story earlier this year about a long billed woodpecker

uhhh, she died of braindamage, as a consequence of repeatedly hitting her head to a tree?

I'm with Oruga. Three toes. She should be zygodactyl, right? Only the "formerly known as Picoides" woodpeckers should have three toes.

Not to be a pedantic person but the penduline tit is called Remiz pendulinus and not Remix pendulines.

As for the strangeness, isn't the lower back supposed to be red instead of black? Probably, I'm very wrong here.

Not to be a pedantic person but the penduline tit is called Remiz pendulinus and not Remix pendulines.

Bloody auto-correct (pretty funny though).

She should have two toes pointing forward and two pointing back. Zygodactyl as someone mentioned earlier.

By James Harding-Morris (not verified) on 11 Aug 2008 #permalink

I didn ´t see the comments of Oruga and Aranae at first, but I came to the same conclusion. So what was it, a simple mutation or a (lesser probable) hybrid with a Picoides tridactylus -part?

Hmh. Dendrocopos might be more familiar to you European types, but good old Picoides is plenty familiar to us North Americans!

On second viewing, her right foot looks to be three-toed and larger, whereas her left foot is 4-toed, zygodactyl, and as it should be.

Your correct, the right foot is larger and only 3-toed isn't it. I wasn't sure if there were three or four toes (you can only see two on the right foot, so the others must be hidden).

How very peculiar.