Dembski vs. D'Souza

Billy Dembski complains about Dinesh D’Souza's handling of ID, then adds:

I encourage anyone who has personal contact with him to provide him with better information. A point of leverage is that D’Souza presumably wants Christians, many of whom support ID, to buy his book.

To be clear, then, Dembski's position is that D'Souza ought to abandon a carefully considered intellectual position in order to boost his book sales. (Note that I no more endorse the notion that D'Souza's position is carefully considered than I endorse the idea that it is intellectual.)

To rephrase, Dembski thinks that conservative authors ought to lie in order to sell more books.

Is it possible he's projecting?

More like this

I typically don't pay attention to Dinesh D'Souza. As far as I can tell he is little more than a pundit, someone who manages to write books so full of various orders of fallacies that my head would probably explode if I tried to read any of his titles cover-to-cover (in fact, such a tragedy nearly…
James Walcott has received the galley proofs for Dinesh D'Souza's new book, wherein he blames the "cultural left" for 9/11 because our horrible decadence makes the whackos so very angry. I think Walcott's reaction is about right: It isn't rare that I take instant animus against a book like this.…
Minuscule, even. Flea-sized. How else am I to interpret Dinesh D'Souza's challenge that he should pick on someone his own size, meaning D'Souza? I've heard D'Souza. He's a babbling pipsqueak. But now he thinks he is a worthy opponent to confront Hitchens, because all the pastors that Hitchens…
James Wolcott has another post on Dinesh D'Souza's appalling argument that we should become more like the Taliban in order to make them hate us less. He includes a few quotes from the book that are so stupid they leave your mouth agape as you read them. For instance: "The left doesn't blame America…

Even though the full article by D'Souza contains some pretty egregious howlers, the portion that Dembski quoted was pretty much on the money. And true to form, Dembski shrieks and gnashes his teeth, handwaving away such criticisms as being "propaganda".

Dembski has become such an irrelevant fool that it's just pathetic.

Not projecting, just framing!

Why do you bother to give either one of these fools notice? Shouldn't they both just be ignored until they grow up? Oh, I know, there is a certain segment of the population that pays attention to them, but WE don't need to add to their fame, do we.

By Elizabeth (not verified) on 06 Apr 2008 #permalink