James Grimmelmann observes the Best. Comment. Ever. to a recipe at Epicurious:
I served these at my health club's solstice gathering and everyone found them quite delicious. I omitted cilantro, however, because it's arbitrary aura makes the herb quite unstable and thus unsuitable to combine with any food.
Yet more support for the I Hate Cilantro movement.
- Log in to post comments
More like this
Editor's note: If you are offended by cholesterol, or are a health and nutrition blogger, or an obesity blogger, avert your eyes. Don't say I didn't warn you.
Earlier today, dear friend of the blog AV Flox conducted an experiment. It went something like this:
Observation: Everyone says the KFC…
My calculus students had a test yesterday. Having now graded them I understand, like never before, the meaning of the word “futility.” Their logic is not like our Earth logic.
My future elementary school teachers had their test today. About forty minutes in to a fifty minute period, as I was…
If you think that political or religious debates can get nasty, you haven't seen anything until you go online as see how much hate exists between people who love cilantro and those who hate cilantro. What horrible words they use to describe each other!!!!
Last weekend, I asked why is this and…
Lately, friday's have just been too busy for me to get around to posting a recipe. So
I decided to switch my recipe posts to saturday. I'll try to be reliable about posting a
recipe every saturday.
I tried making homemade salsa for the first time about about two
months ago. Once I'd made a batch…
The admittedly odd taste of freah cilantro is an acquired one, like those for coffee and garlic.
The first time I grew the herb and tasted it I was repulsed. Skunky and gasoline-like were my first impressions. Tasting it as used in good Mexican restaurant dishes, as well as trying a friend's cilantro-laced salsa, gradually brought me around and now I love the stuff.
It's just not part of European-based American cuisine; most Americans didn't grow up eating it.
I've never found a good use for dried cilantro, though.
I'm pretty well convinced that there is a genetic component in how the taste of fresh cilantro is perceived. Most people in my own family bloodline and in several other families I know perceive fresh cilantro as tasting almost exactly like Ivory soap. Cooking, or use of the dried seed (coriander), obviate the nastiness.
Cilantro has a strong taste, but by no means is it that vile. As a professional purveyor of ecomonically important plants, I've tried just about everything, and I would rank cilantro no worse than a 4 on a scale of 10 for strong tasting condiments. Asafoetida (Ferula assa-foetida), a relative of fennel, is the source of a truly vile smelling resin used in some cooking (and vet medicine). I give it a 9; the specific epithet is a tip off. In terms of odor, durian (an aril) smells like an open sewer, but in taste, it's sort of cheesy, and not nearly as bad (maybe a 5.5). So get some perspective people.
Yes, many things are more revolting. But cilantro still tastes like soap to me.
Just smile, say, "It's not cilantro, it's leaf corriander."
I'm a cilantro hater, too. It wouldn't surprise me if it is genetic, although the other members of my family don't have the hate-cilantro phenotype. Perhaps I ended up with some weird mutation....
IHateCilantro.com has at least a little bit of scientific data that there is a genetic component to cilantro-hatred.