Finally

A year into the administration, after the teabagging parties and record numbers of filibusters, senior Obama advisor Axelrod finally used the magic words:

The American people ... all they want is an up or down vote.

"Up or down vote" is the framing used by Republicans to break the last filibuster crisis, a fight over judicial nominations shortly before Republicans lost control of the Senate. Most Americans don't know what a filibuster is, or why some Senate votes take 60 yeas and some require a simple majority. Traditionally, the filibuster was used to bide for time, and as a show of intense feeling about legislation. In recent years (largely under Republican Senates), it has been used to change the Senate from a majoritarian body to one requiring a supermajority to act at all.

Talking about an "up or down vote" makes it clear what's at stake. A senator can vote to end debate on a bill or nomination without wanting the bill to pass. Agree that the debate has run its course, then let the votes fall where they may in a simple up or down vote. And let Republicans choke on their own words.

More like this

I can't be the only one who is sick and tired of hearing the right blather on about the "unprecedented" filibusters over a handful of Bush's judicial nominees. Bill Frist claims that the Democrats "radically broke with tradition and precedent and launched the first-ever filibuster of a judicial…
see more Lolcats and funny pictures A couple of weeks ago, I wrote a letter (and I encourage others to do the same) calling for a strong public option in whatever healthcare legislation is passed. In the letter, I described the frustration that many rank-and-file Democrats have towards their…
â¦And rightly so. He wrote, after a vote to allow debate on repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell failed to clear a 60 vote plurality: DADT didn't fail. The Senate did: The bill repealing Don't Ask Don't Tell didn't fail: The Senate did. The bill got 57 votes, not 49. As Dylan Matthews pointed out, a…
Sandy Levinson makes a good case that Wednesday is the acid test for the Obama administration's commitment to "Change We Can Believe In." On Wednesday, the President of the Senate, Vice-President Joe Biden, will be asked to rule that the Senate is a non-continuing body, which he will do if he has…

Entirely OT, but this morning I got an email "Steve Fuller is now following you on Twitter!"

False alarm, though, this Steve Fuller does some generic golfing twitter thing.

By Marion Delgado (not verified) on 26 Feb 2010 #permalink