A Bleg about Egypt and Archaeology

Anyone know of archeologists reading the tea leaves on the implications for Zahi Hawass being made a cabinet minister in Egypt? Hawass is the telegenic spokesman for Egypt's rich trove of antiquities, regularly featuring in TV shows about mummies and pyramids, and undoubtedly helping keep tourists flowing to Egypt (tourism is the major national industry).

In the political shakeup over the weekend, Mubarak used his nominal political power to create a new cabinet position for Hawass: Minister of Antiquities.

On one hand, I'd think archaeologists would be glad to see their field getting such political representation. On the other hand, I don't gather that Hawass is especially popular with academics in the field, and I can't imagine any of Mubarak's cabinet ministers retaining much political influence when the revolution reaches its conclusion. Some may be allowed to stay in the country, but can anyone imagine them keeping their posts?

So the bleg: why would Hawass agree to tie his reputation to Mubarak's, and what implications do people forsee this having for Egyptian archaeology generally and Hawass specifically when a new regime arrives?

More like this

This article was co-authored with Dr. Morad Abou-Sabe', President of the Arab American League of Voters of New Jersey. CNN's Ivan Watson talks to John King from Cairo about his exclusive interview with Egyptian activist Wael Ghonim. {February 9, 2011} The Egyptian revolution of January 25th,…
Despite this entry's title, this isn't an announcement of a new tour for Tutankhamen's remains and relics through high-profile museums around the globe. For those of you astute enough to realize a streak of ribaldry runs through Seed's editorial department, your initial lowbrow impression of this…
A year ago, I was at a conference in Alexandria, Egypt, and then spent a few days in Cairo. I got to experience the Egyptian culture, to see antiquities, and to meet some amazing people. It was my first trip outside the bubble of Western developed democracies, and was an eye-opening experience.…
Breaking news of the potential end to Egypt's President Mubarek's time in office indicates that the "transition" may well become a resolution very soon, perhaps tomorrow, Friday, February 11. Will this date mark a new chapter of Egyptian history? I sincerely hope that this crisis ends quickly…

1) "why would Hawass agree to tie his reputation to Mubarak's"

Hawass is a beneficiary of the old system; he first became a cabinet minister in 2009. He owes his position to Mubarak's patronage. Unsurprisingly, he's sticking close to Mubarak.

2) He has the reputation of being personally rather unlikeable. I have no idea how real that is.

3) It has zero real implications for Egyptian archeology; archeology will continue to be a very important feature of Egyptian economics, and thus of politics.

Hawass himself is a fair bit of a fundamentalist Muslim, and anti-semitic; but his views don't differ all that much from the norm in Egypt.

I'll add to my above comment: I did some checking around, and Hawass seems to have rather an ill reputation indeed -- including among fellow archeologists and Egyptologists. He's seen as overall simply milking antiquities for all they're worth; and on the science front, he's more than dubious, with some rather odd attitudes and dictates that come over as rather unscientific.

why would Hawass agree to tie his reputation to Mubarak's

Hawass' reputation essentially consists of being a glorified tourism official, self-promoting Indiana-Jones-wannabe and opponent of any kind of egyptological research that is not tied to a short list of highly marketable pharaonic names or disagrees with Muslim religious sensitivities. His fate is tied to Mubarak's whether he wants it or not, there is absolutely no way he could hang on to any kind of influential position without political protection.

Few people, save his media friends, would be sad to see him go, even if there's no guarantee a successor would be any better.

By Phillip IV (not verified) on 01 Feb 2011 #permalink

My five-year-old is a big fan of Zahi Hawass; that's all I know.

By Physicalist (not verified) on 01 Feb 2011 #permalink