Where are the Trapped Miners??: Urgent Need for Tracking System

Join an on-line chat at 1:00 pm today (8/16) on technology to locate trapped miners.

On day 11, the rescue efforts continue for the six trapped miners at a Utah coal mine.  A third borehole (2") punctured the mine workings yesterday afternoon to allow a camera to be lowered into the mine to scan for any sign of the miners.  With each borehole drilled and each camera-search, the questions being repeated across the nation are "where are the miners?" and "why don't we know more precisely where they are in the mine?" 

After the Sago disaster, family members, worker advocates and coal miners themselves agreed unanimously that miners should be equipped with some sort of device so that their location underground is known at all times.  That way, if an explosion, roof fall or other emergency occurs which impedes miners from evacuating from underground, the rescue teams will have key data on where to find them.

In the days and weeks following Sago, we heard from dozens of small manufacturers, professional designers, and back-yard tinkerers with all kinds of ideas to improve communication and tracking of underground miners.*  We invited all of them to present their ideas and display their technology at a symposium held in April 2006 in Wheeling, WV.   It was really inspiring to see all these interesting inventors and entrepreneurs gathered at small booths, so very eager to talk about the potential of their products and ideas to assist trapped miners.  What I recall most about the entire event was that nearly every one of these exhibitors talked about watching the Sago rescue efforts play out on national TV, and becoming anxious, frustrated or invigorated knowing that they had an existing technology that might be applied in the mining environment.  For much of the exhibit period, Amber Helms (whose father Terry Helms died in Sago) engaged in dynamic discussions about the possibilities of the technologies on display.  Many of the exhibitors just wanted a shot, an opportunity, that is, to try out their inventions in a real underground mine.  Many asked, "can you get me into a mine so we can try out our device?"      

Sadly, the need for tracking equipment seems to have fallen to the back burner, perhaps because the MINER Act 2006 doesn't require such equipment until at least June 2009.  But now, with the uncertain fate of the six trapped miners in Utah, the urgency of tracking devices has emerged again.

Yesterday, a couple of dozen individuals participated in an on-line chat about the current status of tracking devices.  The chatroom, hosted by Wheeling Jesuit University's National Technology Transfer Center, will resume again today from 1:00 pm until 5:00 pm.  Some of these inventors and entrepreneurs we first met in Wheeling last year participated in that chat yesterday, including representatives from InSeT Systems, Matric Systems, emenu, Inc., Active Control, Workhorse Technologies, and Mine Site Technologies.  Thanks to them for not giving up on their technologies for the good of mine workers.   I for one was feeling the need to try to contribute in some way to improve our capabilities to rescue trapped miners. It felt good to have an avenue to reconnect with some of these creative individuals and pick their brains about how their equipment may (or may not) have performed in the Utah disaster, based on what we currently know about the rockburst.

All are welcome to join in today's on-line chat.

*Celeste Monforton, MPH was part of Davitt McAteer's team that investigated the Sago and Aracoma Alma coal mine disasters, on behalf of West Virginia Governor Joe Manchin.  As part of our work, we received boxes of letters from individuals who had ideas for all sorts of mine rescue and safety equipment.

More like this

Several months ago, I tried to get a simple question answered by NIOSH about part of its process for awarding mine safety research grants.  The technical staff with whom I spoke probably knew the answer to my question, but they weren't sure whether the information could be disclosed or not.  Fair…
As I stay tuned for news on the fate of the six coal miners trapped at the Crandall Canyon mine in Emery County, Utah I've heard numerous tv and radio reporters say "hundreds of mine rescuers" have converged near the worksite to assist with the rescue operation.  Who are these "mine rescuers"?…
Early Sunday morning (May 10), I read a news brief from WSAZ reporting that seven workers had been rescued from a flooded underground coal mine in Gilbert, WV, after being trapped for 32+ hours.  As I combed the web for further details, I was struck by the news accounts and audio recordings…
A fair number of people have "Ah-ha!" moments, but how many actually take those nuggets of brilliance and pursue them?  One man --an inventor of sorts who I came to know because of the Sago disaster---has done just that.  While watching the rescue efforts at the WV Sago mine unfold on…

i think tracking is a good idea,
generally-speaking.

that said, in this case, speaking as
a former hard rock miner (not a coal
miner) -- knowing where they are
is less a problem, than getting to them
.

my understanding is that in the crandall
canyon seam, the six missing miners are
still thought to be some 1,000 feet below/be-
yond where the deepest continuous mining
machine has yet uncovered -- all as a result
of the sheer size of the massive pillar-collapse
that buried these miners.

in such a situation, there is effectively one, and
only one, straight line path to reach the collapsed
area, and any pockets of air beyond it -- and that
requires mining THROUGH the collapsed seam
material -- which, as we saw last night, is
very often a lethally-dangerous task. . .

i still think we -- the people of america, brown and
white, documented worker or un-, uniion miner, or
non-, owe it to these mens' families, to go recover
them. no matter how long it takes, or how much it
costs -- very very slowly, if need be -- bringing in
three inch thick, steel plates, with steel-strutted
box-type, cross-supported sections, and setting them,
even five feet at a time, one after another, five feet of
slow but steady progress, maybe ten feet per shift,
to go get these men. . .

your mileage may vary. in fact, it probably does.

keep a good thought for the six -- and those
looking for them. . .

p e a c e

I hope that someone from MSHA is reading this blog to read your idea, and for them to be astute enough to pass it along to the command center, just in case those leading the rescue haven't thought about it. I have been wondering over the last few days whether some of the mine rescue teams and experienced miners from MNM (metal and nonmetal mines) might be able to offer some additional ideas on how to approach this rescue.

I am keeping hope alive for the six trapped men. Who would have thought that Randal McCloy from the Sago disaster would have survived and is recently a new father. Miracles are possible.