"Save the planet" vs "Look at the beautiful lights." Which mindset should win, or is the middle ground the best option.

This post over at the Terry website is nice, and poses an interesting question.

Tonight, as I walked home past the hospital and the lights and the young teenage couple standing under the walkway and the older couple sitting on the bench, I thought to myself, "I wonder how much energy is required to light these every season? How much carbon is being used up just to light this display?"

I stopped in stride. "How could I ask myself such a ridiculous questions - who cares, its beautiful!" I thought, "Look how many people are enjoying it, this symbol of bliss and happiness that has marked a dozen of your childhood winter seasons!" I took a picture with my camera, and walked home.

And I guess I wonder which view folks should take.

One can argue that, obviously, some sort of middle ground that meets both agendas is best, but I wonder if the most important facet of this query is whether the agressively "go green"mentality is hurting the cause more than it is promoting it.

Anyway, check out the post if you get a chance.

More like this

The Bottleneck Years by H.E. Taylor Chapter 31 Table of Contents Chapter 33 Chapter 32 One Thing After Another, December 14, 2055 The next few days were just one damned thing after another. On Monday, when I walked into Ecology 550, a spontaneous wave of applause broke out. I held up my…
Another day, another DonorsChoose incentive claimed. I'm actually late in responding to this one-- I missed my self-imposed 24-hour deadline because we're visiting Kate's parents outside of Boston, but I'll try to make up for it with the answer. Anyway, Helen asks: How did Emmy become part of your…
The Bottleneck Years by H.E. Taylor Chapter 45 Table of Contents Chapter 47 Chapter 46 Boo-Boo, August 26, 2056 I found myself becoming quite anthropological watching Anna learn to walk and talk over the summer. She is a curious and rambunctious child who is always getting into things we…
The Bottleneck Years by H.E. Taylor Chapter 60 Table of Contents Chapter 62 Chapter 61 Crystal Jellies, March 19, 2058 The first time I saw a telescopic view of the L1 sunshades, I remembered standing in an aquarium watching crystal jellyfish. These tiny, delicate creatures were so beautiful…

How about a compromise? LED bulbs use 1/30th the energy for the equivalent light output.
Other advantages:
Less fire hazard because they don't heat up.
No spending hours trying to find that one burned-out bulb that has disabled the entire string of lights
Disadvantage:
Initial cost

By T. Bruce McNeely (not verified) on 20 Nov 2007 #permalink

Let's take it a step farther shall we? Not just LED lights but solar LED light displays...that should shut those tree huggers up.

I hear people argue incessantly over 'framing' in science. I understand the squeamishness about putting any sort of gloss on science, and I prefer we not.

But, when it comes to policy, unless a Tree-Huggin' Stalin comes to power, it will be important to not alienate others, since we'll depend on their votes to get and/or keep environmental legislation in place.

By Dave Eaton (not verified) on 20 Nov 2007 #permalink

it would seem my attempt at humor is not appreciated...