Reasoning versus Imagination?

Jack Hassard wishes us well (and tasks us with being as provocative as we can) in his blog named after his book, The Art of Teaching Science (Oxford, 2004). Summarizing his own approach to science education, he credits Jacob Bronowski as his main inspiration, especially his belief that reasoning and imagination work closely together. Hassard quotes Bronowski at perhaps his most provocative: "You may have been told, you may still have the feeling that E=mc2 is not an imaginative statement. If so, you are mistaken."

Georgia Tech's Mark Guzdial, in his Computing Education blog, takes exception to this: reasoning, he says is not the same cognitive activity as imagining: "reasoning involves a critical component, a requirement to apply discipline, that imagining does not."

The legendary Alan Kay responding to the post, short-circuits the one-to-one relationship that Guzdial sees: "Bronowski does not equate the two," insists Kay. Kay worked with Bronowski in the 1970s and both regard science, says Kay, as not about "facts and dogma" but rather "about imagination supported by both reason and investigation." Science is different from reasoning and storytelling but depends on both. Science for Kay is essentially about trying to relate what goes on in our head (reasoning and imagination) with what goes on out in the universe. Both need each other for the magic to happen.

Categories

More like this

A while ago, I defined Compulsive Centrist Disorder: Complusive Centrist Disorder has always bothered me because a certain policy or view will mysteriously be labelled 'centrist' regardless of where it actually falls on the political spectrum, and suddenly it will be far more respectable than other…
Last night at the Cheltenham Science Festival, I attended a Q&A between Robin Ince and Alan Moore; Robin had stumbled onto the easiest job in the universe, because all you have to do is tickle Moore a little bit and deep rumbly and heavily accented weirdness comes pouring out. Much of the talk…
I want to share this amusing video with all of you, particularly with one very special reader, Joe [surname elided to protect him from his stupidity], who was so moved by this piece that I wrote that he has been emailing repeatedly to let me know that I am a poorly-educated liar. In fact, Joe was…
The LA Times has a horribly shallow article with the headline "Chrisitans sue for right not to tolerate policies". The article discusses a suit against Georgia Tech's hate speech code and then lumps in a vast range of policies, some private and some public, from hate speech codes to anti-…

Darwinian evolution equals imagination while science equals reasoning. Facts are things that can be proven. Pretty drawings and fancy guesswork are products of a great imagination.

A lot of people miss this. You need imagination to draw, from the same things everyone else is looking at, a novel hypothesis that can be tested. You need reasoning to figure out what else would be true if that hypothesis was true. You need imagination to come up with a good experiment to test those ideas... A really inspired experiment requires a great deal of imagination.