Smarthistory: art history as conversation


i-f9b4bdb590cc42cdf2cb0e1f1119bac3-Picture 7.png

Smarthistory is a wonderfully simple concept: landmark artworks presented with conversational narration (sometimes audio, sometimes video) by Beth Harris and Steven Zucker. Sometimes they focus on a single work, as a professor would in a lecture; in other tracks, they stand in a murmur-filled gallery and comment on the hubbub around them. I have friends who sound just like Zucker and Harris when you get them talking about art - relishing the give and take of ideas; happily tossing out half-formed hypotheses about intent and context; gently mocking art cliches, curation cliches, and the (also often cliche) people passing through the gallery. And just as I would with my friends, I wanted to jump indignantly into the conversation, particularly when they started ripping on a museum-goer who was taking photos of both the paintings and the curation plaques (I do that too - it makes it easier to annotate paintings later), and questioning the general practice of photographing works that cost "only 45 cents" in the museum gift shop. First off, don't all art museums charge more than 45 cents for postcards these days? And who has space to store hundreds of postcards anyway? Whatever! (You can see they had me completely engaged).

I wish Smarthistory had existed when I lived hours from the nearest museum - it's like an emergency supplement of art appreciation for people who can't get to a real gallery. Kudos to Harris and Zucker.

More like this

Let's suppose you're the proprietor of a European tourist attraction. We're not talking about a Louvre or Uffizi here, or even a Leaning Tower of Pisa. No, you're in charge of a hidden gem: the scenic Church of the Saint No One Has Ever Heard Of, or the lovely little Museum of the Famous Artist…
The onion, as always, nails it: Oh, No! It's Making Well-Reasoned Arguments Backed With Facts! Run! I...I think it's finally over. Our reactionary emotional response seems to have stopped it dead in its tracks. If I'm right, all we have to do now is smugly reiterate our half-formed thesis and--oh,…
StoryCorps is declaring November 28, 2008 the first annual National Day of Listening: This holiday season, ask the people around you about their lives -- it could be your grandmother, a teacher, or someone from the neighborhood. By listening to their stories, you will be telling them that they…
Cajal's Revenge, 2007 Katherine Sherwood It's been a while since I've been able to focus on my Art vs. Science series of posts, so I understand if you've forgotten Part One and Part Two. A quick recap: in Part One, I asked, I think that lay audiences approach scientific art differently - perhaps…

Hey Jessica, thanks for the kind words about Smarthistory! This was one of the loveliest reviews we've gotten. We will soon have commenting functionality on the site - so in the future you CAN jump in to the conversation!

Beth

Thanks for sharing this! I was just thinking I should read up on some art history before I go to Paris and Italy next month. I'm sure this will be helpful.