Perry's Arcana

i-798d56cd5f40afce476bfd32458f5d61-Arcanakoala.png

From 1810-11, architect and amateur naturalist George Perry published The Arcana, a lavishly illustrated, serial natural history magazine. Although Perry intended for the serial issues to be assembled by his subscribers into a book, only thirteen complete copies are known to survive today. More than a third of the known copies are in Australia - perhaps fittingly, as Perry was the first to publish an illustration of the koala (above).

Perry's work is not well known; in researching this post, all I could find online were auction listings and occasional references to a recent facsimile edition edited by Richard Petit. (Be prepared for sticker shock - it's not cheap). Harvard's Ernst Mayr Library has a copy of the facsimile, though, so I walked over yesterday morning to have a look.

Tragically, I discovered that I had to look at the facsimile in a sun-drenched room crammed with old natural history books, looking out over the grassy space in front of the Museum of Comparative Zoology. So sad!

i-a4c0a40fae489e0c806701e092857910-Arcana1.jpg

The first thing that struck me about the Arcana facsimile is that it's quite thick, with very good paper. It's a facsimile, so I can't infer whether the original paper was equally substantial, but I think I'd been thinking "serial = cheap magazine," and this was definitely not that.

The second thing I noticed was the quality of the illustrations. They were hand colored hand-colored in the original; the effect is surprisingly delicate, and combined with the copious use of white space on the pages, very pleasing. This is definitely a book to leave lying casually open in your natural history themed sunroom:

i-5052c47e4ab39936d9209a58788f9093-Arcanaentomology.jpg

To approximate the experience of flipping through it, check out this video of stills from the copy of the Arcana at the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia:

I have to confess that I wasn't tempted to actually read Perry's Arcana - only Petit's introduction, with its historical context. Perry's text was stereotypically flowery and dated. Interspersed with the shells, insects, and animals were passages from (other writers') travelogues to China, Australia, and other parts of the world, and I have never been a fan of 17th-19th century travelogues. Pretty as the artifact was, I knew basically nothing I'd read would be accurate.

Petit's introduction, though, was quite good (though shorter than I'd expected). Petit updates Perry's taxonomy and provides historical context, but leaves original errors and exaggerations in place. For example, Perry mixes the characteristics of the dolphin-fish (a fish) with the dolphin (a mammal). The errors and exaggerations aren't surprising; Perry was a self-taught naturalist (Collections manager Paul Callomon of Philadelphia's Academy of Natural Sciences calls him a "gentleman student" - quite a nice euphemism) who used local specimens and pets as models. The elephant pictured below, for example, resided in a British menagerie. Tragically, it became berserk as the result of an infected tusk and was put down with several hundred musketballs and a spear (information given in Petit's introduction).

i-77eb016b96196dfd9cccfe7903ace60e-Arcanaelephant.jpg

Perry also apparently took a Lamarckian approach to taxonomy, which may have contributed to the neglect of his work. Callomon says Perry's peers portrayed him "as a dilettante who made things up, and who knew little about the higher organization of the natural world." Perhaps so - I certainly wouldn't use a copy of the Arcana as a scientific reference - but there is something rather awesome about a self-taught natural historian publishing his amateur vision of the natural world.

Perry really should have had a blog.

Sources:

Jeff Akst. "Perry's Arcana, 1810-1811." The Scientist, July 2010, p. 76.
Gary Presland. "Perry's Arcana" (Review). Historical Records of Australian Science, 2010, p. 117-18.
Perry's Arcana at Amazon.com

More like this

tags: Birdbooker Report, bird books, natural history books "One cannot have too many good bird books" --Ralph Hoffmann, Birds of the Pacific States (1927). Here's this week's issue of the Birdbooker Report by Ian "Birdbooker" Paulsen, which lists bird and natural history books that are (or will…
Last Sunday, my son, who is home for his rapidly waning semester break, and I met a couple of friends in New York City where we enjoyed breakfast at good enough to eat followed by a visit to the nearby American Museum of Natural History. We dedicated ourselves to the fossil halls on the fourth…
I was sent this story about genes and IQ, and right from the beginning, my alarm bells were ringing. This is crank pseudoscience. Gregory Cochran has always been drawn to puzzles. This one had been gnawing at him for several years: Why are European Jews prone to so many deadly genetic diseases?…
In the "Little House on the Prairie" series, one of the later books describes the family's move to the Dakota's and the long winter they suffered through. In The Long Winter, the prairie is hammered by a rapid series of intense blizzards, from October until April - about two per week, according to…