I feel all dirty now

So, I popped down to the campus bookstore and browsed C*u*ters latest tome on the "Church of Liberalism"...

A large part of the book is regurgitated crap from the intelligent design moron crowd, which PZ has dissected along with several other netizens.

Most of the rest is the usual incoherent lunatic ravings about sex, crime and war.

So... what about "their own cosmology"?
Well, I was a bit disappointed, it is there in the preamble, but then nada.
Not in the index, couple of contextless asides on how "well at least relativity has experimental evidence", and a rambling listing of "famous scientists who said something about God". No context, and ahistorical.

The only solid comment on cosmology is a discussion of Hoyle and Wickramasinghe's panspermia, with a somewhat disappointing note to the effect that Hoyle may have been an atheist, but at least he knew evolution was wrong.

Sigh. I actually talked to Hoyle about this at lunch at the IoA about 8 or 9 years ago.
Hoyle had some interesting ideas (like his notion that the "junk DNA" codes initial conditions for some structural information - probably wrong, but interesting and testable).
The Steady State was actually anti-theistic cosmology, the Big Bang has philosophical taints of creation for obscure historical reasons; and panspermia may in principle occur (there is some interest right now in whether Martian life polluted the Earth in the Archaean), but it does not disprove anything on evolution - at worst it pushes the origin problem back and stretches the timeline, but a factor of two or so.

So completely wrong headed, not even interestingly wrong.
But then the whole book reeks of slapped together poorly thought out spin and strawman talking points, where it is not spouting outright lies and errors of fact.

Addendum: ok, I shouldn't be cute - messes with the Sb magic indexing.
Coulter, the author's name is Coulter.

Tags

More like this

The Book of Exogenesis: In the beginning was the word, and the word was a meteorite... Earlier this month, a report, based on NASA studies of meteorites found on Earth, suggested that some building blocks of DNA may have been formed in space. As it turns out, DNA components have been found on…
Sounds dirty, don't it? It's always nice to see sites that usually deal with politics discuss science. Or in this case, the opposite, also known as Ann Coulter. Robert Savillo, of Media Matters, demolishes the creationist arguments found in Ann Coulter's latest book Why I Think All Liberals…
Red State Rabble has an account of Ken Miller's talk at the University of Kansas. "Creationists," biologist Ken Miller, told a large, receptive audience at the University of Kansas last night, "are shooting at the wrong target." Showing a slide of the cover art of "The Lie," an anti-evolution…
I received email from one of those astrobiologists, the people behind the Journal of Cosmology, in this case Carl H. Gibson. I was…amused. Dear Professor Meyers: I understand you have some problem with our interpretation of Richard Hoover's article proposed for the Journal of Cosmology. I…