Law of Large Numbers: $$$ edition

In my field, mean success rates for grant proposals range from a surprisingly generous 30% or so for a rare few opportunities, to a more typical 6-10%

As the number of proposals submitted go to infinity, most all researchers must have near average success rate.

I was prodded by this in noting that I was on a fair number of Hubble proposals, and my hit rate was exactly the average.

In the limit of random funding, this is of course exactly what happens, the average researcher will have a long term success rate for funding which approaches the mean success rate as the number of proposals goes to infinity.

Now, I don't think the distribution of research success is actually gaussian, clearly there is is a power law tail, with a larger than expected number of "overly successful" researchers, who have consistent above average success rate (at least for a finite number of proposals submitted); conversely there are also clearly researchers with consistently lower than mean success rate.

But, necessarily, for most researchers the long term grant success rate must approach the mean for the field (I guess I am arguing that the mode is not and cannot be significantly offset from the mean).

So don't think you're special just because you got a grant!
In the long run you will have to submit 2-15 grants that fail to make up for it... (depending on what panels you're submitting to, and assuming no secular trend leading to monotonically increasing success rates)

So there.

Tags

More like this

Writing this blog, I get lots of email. One of the things that I get over and over again is a particular kind of cluelessness about the idea of infinity. I get the same basic kind of stupid flames in a lot of different forms: arguments about Cantor's diagonalization; arguments about calculus (…
A few weeks ago, I blogged a self-assessment of my progress towards tenure. It seemed like an apt time to reflect in the hours before my annual review meeting with the department chair(s) and in the months before my packet for reappointment is submitted. Reappointment is the first and only…
I hate it when I fall behind in my journal reading. Of course, it happens all the time, as you might expect, with my time sandwiched between running my lab, writing grants, seeing patients, and operating. Sometimes, though, I get a chance to try to catch up a bit. Such was the case the other day,…
It was NASA proposal season last month, meant to comment on it, but was so exhausted and pissed off about the whole thing that I needed some space. A typical proposals is 15 pages of main text; including biblio, bios, associated documents and blurbs the final (electronic) package is typically 40-55…