logic, religion and tenure

Fascinating post on Scott's shtetl-optimized on logical inference, religion and the parsimony of evolutionary optimised reasoning

Read the whole thing.

There is always a worry that scientific rationalism is a darwinian dead-end, in that it is suboptimal for reproductive fitness, and Scott touches on that. Mathematics, beyond basic arithmetic, may be a peacock feather in the long run. Or not, the fitness landscape changes and memes, not just genes, compete.
We don't just reproduce, we convert...

More important is the cognitive dissonance: Scott thinks prevention of suffering is a good basis for morality and he is applying for tenure track jobs!
Aargh.

No, wait, we agreed not to do that.
Yeah, go for it Scott...

h/t Chad

Tags

More like this

Here is a list of Basic Concept posts in Physics and Astronomy. Recently Added: Phase changes, by Janet Stemwedel at Adventures in Science and Ethics; De Broglie Equation (quantum physics) by Wandering Primate; Understanding Electricity by Scott Aaronson at Shtetl-Optimized; Ohm's Law by Chad…
Hot on the heels of the good news that the deep ocean conveyor doesn't appear to be on the verge of shutting down -- a scenario that would have eliminated many of the world's most important fisheries among other things -- comes the inevitable flipside bad news. The Southern Ocean has stopped…
Shtetl-Optimized » Blog Archive » Eight Signs A Claimed Pâ NP Proof Is Wrong "So, in the future, how can you decide whether a claimed Pâ NP proof is worth reading? I'll now let you in on my magic secrets (which turn out not to be magic or secret at all). The thing not to do is to worry about…
Blog U.: 4 Reasons Why Local Meetings Should Be Conducted with Web Meeting Tools - Technology and Learning - Inside Higher Ed "Adobe Connect, WebEX, GoToMeeting, LiveMeeting, Skype, Elluminate (what am I missing?), these web conferencing tools are not just for meeting at a distance. Here are 4…