academic relevance

in a more innocent time, at the beginning of the week, the Female Science Professor pondered the implications of Ignatieff's assertions of political science

In academic life, false ideas are merely false and useless ones can be fun to play with.

She left her train of thought unfinished, but made the point that most physical scientists really can not and do not think this way, well except when some cosmologists stray off the reservation, and even then there is always some hard nosed astrophysicist ready to rein them in. In public.

Not always saying they succeed...

But, deLong knows which side economists aspire to, for today is a Great Day in Finance
in theory, anyway

And, of course, in theory there is no difference between theory and practise...

I like this bit: "Whether this will have macroeconomic implications is unclear..."
"... I would be not."

But then he hedges the bet.

Economists are just not there yet.
This is the time you push out your model - make bold, falsifiable predictions, be prepared to go down in flamespost hoc revise your model if the prediction do not hold.

Go! economist doods, stick out necks!

Tags

More like this

Former Iraq War supporter Michael Ignatieff wrote a mea culpa of sorts in the NY Times magazine this Sunday. Since that's more than most former war supporters have done, he should get some credit for that. But two things were really troubling about the article. First, Ignatieff viewed Iraq as…
Apparently, I'm not the only one who thought that Ignatieff's self-analysis was idiotic. Brad DeLong writes that Ignatieff wasn't acting like an academic (italics mine): I think Ignatieff has it wrong when he contrasts realistic politicans with academic visionaries. The academics I know and…
So, you want to be an astrophysicist? You're an undergraduate, doing astronomy or physics (or possibly engineering, mathematics or computer science, or something), should you go to grad school? Another lightly reworked blast from the blog past see also Rob's recent take at Galactic Interactions…
I'm a little cautious about adding this to the basic concepts list, given that my main point here is going to be that things are not as simple as you might guess. You've been warned. We've already taken a look at what it means for a claim to be falsifiable. Often (but not always), when scientists…