there is always one...

why is there always One that hatesdoesn't click with you...

The Female Science Professor got her student evaluations...

As she notes, there is always one student who really does not like the class, the professor, the material, the method, anything...
Always.
One.
At least one...

Now, she has some interesting conjecture about her particular One, which I am sorry to say could not possibly explain my One(s).

Our student evaluations score us on a strange numerical scale - high score is good.
Personally I just think that there is always one student who inverts the scale and things a "1" is good.
That's it.

Now, if I could only similarly rationalise the comments.
I know, it is modern teen slang - you know, like in the old days when "bad" really meant "really good".

I'm soooooo Bad.

Tags

More like this

I wrote this on March 03, 2005 on Science And Politics and reposted it on December 10, 2005 on The Magic School Bus. The title says it all... I guess it is the time of year when college professors get their student evaluations back and, of course, some of those who blog have written about their…
Dr. Tyson: (I find the faux-familiar thing people do with "open letters" really grating, so I'm not going to presume to call you "Neil" through the following...) First of all, I should probably say "Thanks," because I'm using some of your material in my class this term-- I had them read Stick in…
Physics is a notoriously difficult and unpopular subject, which is probably why there is a large and active Physics Education Research community within physics departments in the US. This normally generates a lot of material in the Physical Review Special Topics journal, but last week, a PER paper…
So, this post is almost ten days old, but I just now found some time to actually read the 35 comments on it as well as what others wrote about it on their blogs. I guess it is time to continue that conversation now. First, let me be clear about the origin of that rant: I've been teaching for quite…

I found, for whatever it is worth, the anonymous comment at 11:12 AM on 6/17 to be really interesting.

By Brad Holden (not verified) on 17 Jun 2008 #permalink

My teaching evaluations became very monotonous years ago. Most students like me and my class, some don't. Now of course they aren't asked what they like, or don't like, but that's what gets evaluated instead of what they learned.

The same thing goes with my annual institutional evaluation. I did some things they liked and some things they didn't like, or not enough, or something. They never just said, "you did a good job and more than earned your salary".

So although I don't advise my young colleagues to follow my example, I stopped reading them, and have been happier for it. Why worry about the fact that you can't please all the people all the time? So if those evaluations disturb your wa, I can only suggest abstinance.

Lending credence to the idea some students mark down the wrong numbers, a few years ago I had one student evaluation where the student wrote down that they really enjoyed the class (and perhaps even the instructor), and then proceeded to give the worst grades on the numerical scale.

By Pat Durrell (not verified) on 18 Jun 2008 #permalink