which came first, the black hole or the galaxy?

The AAS is off to a good start:

Reines et al have found a good supermassive black hole candidate in Henize 2-10 - an irregular bulgeless dwarf galaxy about 10 Mpc away.

A dwarf irregular, with a diameter of only about 1 kpc, Henize 2 is in starburst. It contains a number of
massive, very young super star clusters.
SMBH are seen in almost every galaxy and, in the local universe, are correlated with the galactic bulge mass.
One of the open issues is which came first, the black hole or the galaxy.

Henize is bulgeless, and if it genuinely has a real SMBH, that would strongly hint that the black hole comes first and the
galaxy assembles around it later.



He 2-10

The evidence for the SMBH is indirect, strong radio source near the middle of the galaxy, found at the NRAOs VLA, and
followup observations by Chandra showing a high energy x-ray source at the same location, suggestive of a low luminosity
active galactic nucleus with a jet.

The authors suggest an estimate black hole mass of about a million solar masses.
If this is the case, it also suggests that at least some supermassive black holes form directly with
masses of hundreds of thousand of solar masses, through some direct collapse mechanism, rather than growing
slowly from a lower mass seed black hole.



click to embiggen

An actively accreting massive black hole in the dwarf starburst galaxy Henize 2-10, Reines, Sivakoff, Johnson and Brogan, Nature 2011

NRAO press release

More like this

"Einstein was wrong when he said, 'God does not play dice.' Consideration of black holes suggests, not only that God does play dice, but that he sometimes confuses us by throwing them where they can't be seen." -Stephen Hawking Welcome back to Starts With A Bang after a brief vacation! Apparently,…
"Black holes, which have no memory, are said to contain the earliest memories of the universe, and the most recent, too, while at the same time obliterating all memory by obliterating all its embodiments. Such paradoxes characterize these strange galactic monsters, for whom creation is destruction…
"Our first priority was making sure we weren’t fooling ourselves." -Keith Riles, LIGO team member When LIGO announced their first discovery of a black hole-black hole merger, it came as a surprise to almost everyone. The shocking part wasn’t that LIGO had seen merging black holes, but that they…
"For something to collapse, not all systems have to shut down. In most cases, just one system is enough." -Robert Kiyosaki Do supermassive black holes form from the merger and growth of many smaller black holes, falling towards a cluster/galactic center where they find one another and grow into a…

Can this be done with early hierarchical growth of dark matter that is far heavier than the TeV scale? My gut feeling is no.

Also, given that the sample size is only one at this point, could this have been a particular case where a merger ejected an SMBH, around which the IGM is now collapsing into a new galaxy?

By Andrew Shevchuk (not verified) on 10 Jan 2011 #permalink

You really need some relaxation - ie CDM self-interaction - to get dark matter fueled SMBH growth
Ostriker had a nice paper on it a few years ago.

Very very unlikely to be an ejected SMBH