The 2% solution

Dear Medical Doctors of America: the 1% does not include you.
You are the second percent and the top percent is about to dump you overboard.
Just be clear on that.

Tags

More like this

When I first heard about the American Medical Association (AMA) opposing Obama's health care reform, I was troubled.  I almost wrote a post about it, but by the time I got home, I found that others had beaten me to it.   href="http://scienceblogs.com/effectmeasure/2009/06/revolutionary_medicine.…
Americans, as any ScienceBlogger will tell you, have a woefully poor understanding of math and science. For the most part, even the most ignorant among us are able to stumble through life, but what happens when we're confronted with a genuine scientific question with a real impact on our lives?…
Libraryland is sometimes plagued with a civility problem. We disagree but we want to be nice about it. But sometimes, being nice isn't a great way to express disagreement. Life and the world is messy and unkind and difficult. And sometimes our commitment to our ideas and passionate disagreements…
I like it like that. Webb writes dirty words in a Wall Street Journal op-ed. You know, words like "class" and "elites." Says Webb (italics mine): The most important--and unfortunately the least debated--issue in politics today is our society's steady drift toward a class-based system, the likes…

Dearest America,

Most of us aren't even in the second percent because the top 1% dropped us overboard some time ago, admittedly, we're still pretty much all in the top 5%. We have no illusions about the top 1% being on our side, we're just also so independantly minded and difficult to organize that we can't get a consistent block together to argue in our own economic or moral self interest.

Dear America,

What are you talking about?

Sincerely,
The Rest of the World

By Pseudonym (not verified) on 18 Apr 2011 #permalink

Ouch.

I can see how it'll play out if Medicare is still viable as cost control -- MDs have already moved to an 'employee' model (hospitals vs private practice) & taken shorter hours; CMS will keep pressure on their salaries and other costs until they're nowhere near the 2% they're used to.

So ... just that a voucher system mediated by insurance companies will be significantly more evil, with significantly more downward pressure on costs to sustain their profits? I see d(income)/dt being much larger magnitude, but not a different sign. MDs are screwed either way.

By FuturePostdoc (not verified) on 20 Apr 2011 #permalink

Well doctors are much like teaches. We're fat cats who get paid too much. Not like executives, who need to get paid the big bucks to take risks and make profits.
After all, we only take care of peoples health, not something important like their portfolios /sarcasm