Frum and Gore

David Frum, the speechwriter and conservative pundit behind Bush's "axis of evil" line, has officially endorsed Al Gore's latest policy proposal: a tax on carbon. What's even stranger is that Frum endorses this policy without believing in global warming:

You don't have to believe that global warming is a problem to believe that a carbon tax may be the solution.

A carbon tax is a tax on all activities that emit carbon dioxide, principally the burning of fossil fuels -- not just gasoline, but also natural gas, jet fuel, propane and coal.

Think of it as an energy tax with an inbuilt subsidy for renewable energy and nuclear power, our current best hopes for moving to a post-petroleum economy.

Environmentalists like the carbon tax because they blame rising carbon dioxide levels for the increase in average temperatures that has been observed in the northern hemisphere since 1970.

Now, we don't in fact know that recent warming represents anything more than a normal fluctuation in global climate.

We certainly do not know that the dangers and costs of any warming would be greater than the benefits.

So why a carbon tax? When I was at law school, cynical students used to joke that the best answer to any exam question about a judicial opinion was: "Right result; wrong reason."

And that is what the environmentalists have reached with the carbon tax.


More like this

The Nation Post's Lawrence Solomon has been writing a series of articles falsely casting scientists such as Nigel Weiss and Sami Solanki as deniers. His latest target: Roger Revelle: Then in 1991, Dr. Revelle wrote an article for Cosmos, a scientific journal, with two illustrious colleagues,…
Energy policy is one of those nerdy things that no one pays attention to until it starts to go wrong. And that's where we stand today. Electricity demand continues to rise, as documented by this report by the Energy Information Administration. And most of that electricity is generated by coal…
There are so many depressing studies on energy policy that I thought it was worth highlighting an optimistic one. The Rand Corp. just produced an analysis which predicts that alternative energy sources (like wind, solar and ethanol) could furnish as much as 25% of the U.S.'s conventional energy by…
As loyal readers of this blog know by now (I'm talking about you, Mom), I've got a soft spot for gas taxes. In fact, I'm pretty convinced that America needs a higher gas tax, phased in over several years (so the working poor can adjust their driving habits). Over the past few weeks, I've noted that…