The Takeaway

I was on The Takeaway this morning talking about the ineffectiveness of Human Growth Hormone (HGH) and the potency of the placebo effect. Even though most studies demonstrate that HGH does little to enhance athletic performance, world class athletes continue to take the banned hormone. Why? Because they're convinced that HGH is effective. As a result, the drug gives them a mental edge - because athletes expect to perform better, they do perform better. The illusion of an advantage, if it's sincerely believed, can be a real advantage.

Here's more on why I'm in favor of taking HGH off the banned substance list. And here's more on the neuroscience of the placebo effect.

More like this

Another study purports to find that, for most people, Prozac and the other members of the antidepressant family of pharmaceuticals are no better than sugar pills. Expect Big Pharma to object, but not too loudly. At least, don't expect them to expend too much effort and money denouncing the findings…
The latest edition of 'Life Extension' as once again provided me with a bounty of lols. For instance, did you know that "For the past fourteen years, the gerontological establishment has sought to persecute anti-aging physicians, anti-aging health practitioners, and the American Academy of Anti-…
Did you know that acupuncture is very much related to astrology? No, it's not just because both of woo. Rather, it's likely true that the whole concept of "meridians," those invisible "channels" through which our life energy (a.k.a. qi) allegedly flow were indirectly based on astrological signs,…
A lot of people are talking about a new study showing a 40% increase risk of "psychosis", which I first heard news of in this story, from the Daily Mail: A single joint of cannabis raises the risk of schizophrenia by more than 40 percent, a disturbing study warns. The Government-commissioned…

Because I'm telling everyone: I can not express how much I dislike The Takeaway, especially because I only get the AM variant of our NPR affiliate, and The Takeaway has taken over the only two hours I am able to listen.

I want news. I want hard news. I don't want three people amiably chatting about news, trying to present us with NPR's attempt to inject as much "morning zoo" into their morning programming as they think they can get away with (which isn't much, but it's still horrible).

By Jimmyjojo (not verified) on 12 Aug 2008 #permalink

Jimmyjojo, I could not agree more. I started listening to NPR about a year ago and I was so thrilled to have found a place where I could actually listen to quality, in-depth news stories without all of the inane chatter. The first time I listened to The Takeaway, I was shocked. It was exactly the same kind of crap from which I was trying to get away. I gave it a couple of more chances in the following weeks to see if it would improve, but it did not. Nowadays I usually listen to NPR via podcasts and I have a choice between AM and FM variants so it's not very hard for me to find alternatives to The Takeaway, but I wholeheartedly agree that it is lousy.

Ok Jonah, sorry for continuing this OT ranting. This is actually the first time that I've ever heard that HGH has not really been shown to enhance athletic performance. Interesting stuff.

PS - I have listened to you on the Brian Lehrer show (which is fantastic) a couple of times and found the segments very interesting.