Nudging a Republican Snail Into a Democrat


Cristina Grande and Nipam Patel

DIFFERENCES In this pair of land snails, the one on the right, with the shell opening on the right, is the more common of the species.

My children and I recently "caught" a mud snail off the coast of New Jersey, and it got me thinking...

I've always been fascinated that some snails have left-handed shells and others right-handed. Forgiving the "left/right" political belief reference, do you think it would be possible to nudge a snail towards one form over the other? If so, how could you do it?

I've been exploring this question as one of my research projects, and it turns out that it is very difficult to do. {My students and I, along the way, have learned a lot about snails. See our commentary on this question in The New York Times here. }

A research group at The University of Tokyo did figure out a way, by literally pushing the cells away from the direction in which they would normally develop, at an early stage of development:

we used two glass rods to push the animal surface of each blastomere in the directions opposite to the normal third cleavage

Simply brilliant!


This scheme summarizes the development of left- and right-handed snails from the one-cell stage to mature adults. In L. stagnalis, reversing the chirality by micromanipulation at the first or second cleavage stage does not alter the organismal chirality, as the manipulated embryos revert to form eight-cell embryos of original handedness (thin arrow). In contrast, embryos whose chirality is reversed by micromanipulation at the third cleavage grow to chirality inverted juvenile and then to healthy and fertile adult snails, with oppositely-coiled shell and situs inversus viscerum (thick arrow). nodal and Pitx expressions are also reversed by this manipulation. Dextralized snails are produced from sinistral snails without SD (spiral deformation), a unique feature observed only at the third-cleavage metaphase-anaphase of dominant dextral snails, and directly linked to the handedness-determining gene(s).

It turns out that, for a snail, whether you're "right" or "left" is a matter of survival:


Watch the video here.

More like this

Developmental biologists are acutely interested in asymmetries in development: they are visible cues to some underlying regional differences. For instance, we'd like to know the molecules and interactions involved in taking a seemingly featureless sphere, the egg, and specifying one side to go on…
My first column in the Guardian science blog will be coming out soon, and it's about a recent discovery that I found very exciting…but that some people may find strange and uninteresting. It's all about the identification of nodal in snails. Why should we care? Well, nodal is a rather important…
Since Coturnix turned me on to this paper on snail chirality in PLoS (pdf), I had to sit down and learn something new this afternoon. Chirality is a fascinating aspect of bilaterian morphology. We have characteristic asymmetries—differences between the left and right sides of our bodies—that are…
My wife thought this story about left-handed snails having a competitive advantage, in that they seem to be better able to escape predation by right-handed crabs, was pretty cool. She also recalled that I'd scribbled up something about snail handedness before, so to jump on the bandwagon, I've…