Effects of gun control in England

I decided to check the claim that crime went up following gun control
in England in 1920. I compared the homicide rates for England for the
period 1911-1920 with the period 1921-1930 and found that the rate
declined by 8%. This change could have been caused by demographic
changes that followed from World War I, since this killed a
significant number of young males (the group that murders most.)

To check for this, I looked at all the countries in [1] for which
homicide data was available covering 1911-1930. A feature common to
almost all these countries (Japan being the major exception) was a
pronounced dip in the homicide rate in the years 1915-1918,
presumably because large numbers of young males were serving in the
war, so I excluded these years from the analysis, to get a better idea
of the true homicide rate before 1920. We also want to establish if
any changes are significant, so I did a t-test for each country.

Here are the results:

         11-14  21-30 change  Prob chance could
         19-20          %     cause this change
England   0.80  0.69  -12     0.003
Australia 0.89  0.67  -25     0.05
Germany   0.58  0.84  +41     0.001
Italy     7.85 10.2   +29     0.24
Japan     3.46  3.78  +9      0.14
Portugal  2.82  3.16  +12     0.17
Scotland  0.74  0.78  +5      0.55
USA       7.52  8.58  +14     0.006

(Note that some of the rates are for homicide offences and some for
convictions, so you cannot compare rates across countries.)

We see that in most countries the homicide rate increased, with
Germany and the US recording significant increases.

The only country beside England to record a significant decrease after
1920 was Australia. NSW (40% of Australia's population) introduced
gun control in 1920. Victoria (30%) followed in 1921, and Queensland
(15%) in 1927.

More like this

We've been around on this before, and all it does is impress me with the predilection of some pro-gun folks for self-delusion on this topic. (I'm sorry if that sounds harsh, but it seems to me that many people suspend their powers of reason on this issue.) Here are the NSW homicide rates from 1910…
Jim Zoes was kind enough to send me the data on English homicide rates that he obtained from the Home Office. I've typed it in and included it at the end of this message. The numbers are certainly higher than those recorded in the WHO Statistical Yearbook. I'll try to find out why, but for now I…
It has been pointed out to me that the 1903 gun law in England was rather weak, and that real gun control started in 1920, so I have added a line to the table below. Second and third columns are homicide rate per 100,000 Year England & Wales USA Ratio Source 1903 0.93 2.6…
Could the changes be caused by noise? This calls for a t test, to see if the average homicide rate changed. Andy Freeman said: There's an interesting thing about averages. If you take the average of a declining series and compare it to the end point, you find that the average is, not surprisingly…