Effectiveness of gun defence against rape

Greg Booth said:

A 1979 US Justice Department study of 32,000 attempted
rapes show that overall, when rape is attempted, the
completion rate is 36%. But when a woman defends herself
with a gun, the completion rate drops to 3%.

"Rape victimization in 26 American Cities" is indeed a US Justice
Department study, so I can correct all the inaccuracies in the above

  1. 32,000 is the estimated number of rapes and attempted rapes by
    strangers in the 26 cities surveyed. The number of rapes and
    attempted rapes by strangers in the sample was about 1600.

  2. The completion rate for rapes by strangers was 32%.

  3. The 3% completion rate was when the woman "used/brandished gun or
    knife" (Response 1, Question 136 on the original survey.)

  4. gun/knife was used for self defence in only 2% of the cases. The
    study marks the 3% statistic as "statistically unreliable" since it is
    based on less then 50 sample cases.

To give you an idea of how unreliable the 3% statistic is,
the completion rate for white women who used a gun/knife is 14%, while
the completion rate for white women who "resisted without force/took
evasive action" was 6%.

Can we conclude that running away is better than resisting with a gun?


More like this

Since Scripter argues so badly, litters his postings with insults and outright lies, deliberately cooks his statistics and frequently gets his facts wrong, it seems to me that he he is trying to convince people that the pro-gun case is totally without merit. Is Charles Scripter an HCI plant?…
Diederich Andrew Richard said: According to a 1986 survey of 2,000 imprisoned felons: 57% believed encountering an armed victim is the worst thing that could happen. False. The closest thing I could find in Wright and Rossi [1] to this is 57% agreed that "Most criminals are more worried about…
Since guns are very rarely used to defend against rapists, and only a small fraction of rapes are committed at gun point, and there is no good evidence for any deterrent effect for guns preventing rape, I doubt if gun control has a major effect on rape. Eric Johnson said: I assume you mean 'in…
Lowell Savage writes: Sorry, Ron. Much as I agree with your position, I have to say that you haven't addressed Tim's issue: why is it that 37% of non-gun defenders were injured before they began self-defensive actions while only 13% of gun defenders were injured before they began self-defense…