Do the Japanese count some murders as suicides?

Tim Starr writes:

Japan classifies cases of husbands murdering their wives & kids then killing
themselves as all suicides, no homicides, thus skewing their statistics in
favor of suicides & against homicides.

This claim is easily seen to be false: You just have to look at the
Japanese suicide statistics. There are no recorded suicides of small
children.

That doesn't necessarily falsify the claim. How are "small
children" defined?

Under 5. And the suicide rate for 5-14 year olds is half of the US
rate.

How do you know that "family suicides" in Japan don't usually take place when
the children are no longer "small"?

Because I've actually read something on the subject. A typical
"family suicide" involves a mother of small children killing her
children and herself. Just because the literal translation of the
Japanese word for this is "family suicide", it does not follow that
the homicide of the children is officially recorded as suicide.

See: R, Markman & D. Bosco, "Alone with the Devil," 342ff (1989).
Iga, Mamoru "The thorn in the chrysanthemum : suicide and economic
success in modern Japan"

Tags

More like this

Cristina Yu wrote: You didn't mention Japan. Japan's such a safe place that they're murder rate is almost as low as the murder rate for Americans of Japanese descent. Almost, but not quite. Wrong. Kleck says this on page 189 of "Point Blank", but he looked up the wrong number (2.45) for the…
Paul Blackman writes: I'm not sure Kates actually prevents anyone from learning anything. He presents something with a clear bias, but he no more prevents anything than does Tim's commentary. Kates claims that he is trying "to place Malcolm's contribution in the context of extant social…
"Stephen Heyer" writes: When confronted with the fact that "In the last 16 years the number of guns owned in Australia has quadrupled. The number of firearm deaths have dropped by 46% in that period and guns are being used less in crime." What bothers me is that this bogus "fact" has been…
Edgar Suter wrote: From an early DRAFT of Gary Kleck's TARGETING GUNS : FIREARMS AND THEIR CONTROL scheduled to be published this month: The Medical/Public Health Literature on Guns and Violence False Citation of Prior Research In a 1992 article [Kellermann AL, Rivara FP, Somes G, et al. Suicide…